Jump to content
question

Wasted single material songs in Gaga's discography?


GagaMyBlood95

Single material songs  

173 members have voted

  1. 1. Which song do you think deserved the most to become a single:

    • Monster
      31
    • Dance In The Dark
      47
    • Scheisse
      39
    • Hair
      10
    • MANiCURE
      14
    • Gypsy
      32


Featured Posts

nattuggla

Monster and DITD as 4th and 5th single of TFM

Scheiße (for Europe)/You And I (for US)

Gypsy instead of G.U.Y. and MANiCURE afterwards

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 54
  • Created
  • Last Reply
lxdygxga

I think they missed a big chance with Monster, it felt like a sure fire hit at the time. Everyone seemed to love it. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Phlop

TF: Starstruck

TFM: Monster

BTW: Scheisse and Heavy Metal Lover (I'd say Hair, but I feel like a video for it wouldve been cringey AF)

AP: Gypsy, Sexxx Dreams and MANiCURE tbh. 

Joanne: pretty much the first half of the album

 

I dont think TF and TFM eras needed more singles though.

BTW should have had Scheisse as the redone track over Judas. It is somewhat formulaic to Bad Romance but edgier and wouldn't have made people think Gaga was satanic.

ARTPOP had a lot of misses. Granted I'm a Venus stan, but that track isnt really radio friendly. However, I think if they were going to go for a crazy single (GUY), Venus would have fared better because it had soo many hooks and choruses and the video would have been epic. Hell, even Aura has a better chorus than GUY and wouldve been the long awaited sequel to Telephone. Gypsy was completely radio ready and idk why they didn't service it as the second single tbh. Sexxx Dreams was amazing and MANiCURE was easy to digest. I was never team DWUW only because a track with R.Kelly was never going to smash and she performed it literally everywhere. It sounds radio friendly, and she shouldve released it solo or taken more time to find another artist to duet with (Christina Aguilera).

Joanne... well Idk why Perfect Illusion was the lead and ruined her chart success but to each their own. DH/AYO/JW/Joanne/DiC/MR are all strong tracks but due to her current struggle, I think only AYO/DiC are the real choices left tbh. Had PI not ruined her chances, the era couldve been longer.

 

BUT Scheisse should have been a single. MESS.

BYE
Link to post
Share on other sites

Scheisse would have gone straight to number one. There wasn't a single GP friend that I showed that song to that didn't become hooked

Spoiler

Dance in the Dark slays but tbh sometimes the praise for it on this site is excessive. Monster would have gone harder than DITD. I said it

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

MJHolland
6 hours ago, kevindjibouti said:

And no y'all, Venus DID NOT DESERVE TO BE A SINGLE

200_s.gif

Spoiler

Venus would have f*cking smashed. It was one of the most played/streamed non-singles from ARTPOP (was way more popular than GUY), and from personal experience everyone I played Venus for loved it (I got my three very straight male cousins to stan that song god dammit!) 

The snub of Venus by making GUY a single was tragic. GUY was tragically vulgar, just like DiC. Doomed from the start. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

AVeryGagaHolyDick
6 hours ago, MJHolland said:

200_s.gif

  Hide contents

Venus would have f*cking smashed. It was one of the most played/streamed non-singles from ARTPOP (was way more popular than GUY), and from personal experience everyone I played Venus for loved it (I got my three very straight male cousins to stan that song god dammit!) 

The snub of Venus by making GUY a single was tragic. GUY was tragically vulgar, just like DiC. Doomed from the start. 

Venus is ridiculous, pathetic. The GP hates it. And it's normal because this song is horrible and has no chance to succeed.

Link to post
Share on other sites

AVeryGagaHolyDick
10 hours ago, jvckk said:

I think they missed a big chance with Monster, it felt like a sure fire hit at the time. Everyone seemed to love it. 

I don't think it would have worked that much. I mean, it's an amazing song, but not single worthy, it's not... I can't tell you, I just feel it. Bad Romance and Alejandro have something radio friendly that Monster doesn't have.

Link to post
Share on other sites

hausofgay

Paper Gangsta

My pronouns are fâg/fâggot. If you don't accept it you're homophobic 🥴🥴🥴😵‍💫😵‍💫😵‍💫
Link to post
Share on other sites

GhettoFabulous

tumblr_o41qvzp1381v2tb3jo1_250.gif

1.Venus shoulda been a single sweeeties no tea no shade no lies. Imagine the godliness the video woulda been with just the single cover I get goosebumps now imagine how much more with an actual video.

2. Dance in the dark. :lana:like just listen to it 

3.Sheiße omg imagine the video :madge::diane:

bur overal Venus the rest can follow after ha 

Link to post
Share on other sites

GhettoFabulous
10 minutes ago, kevindjibouti said:

Venus is ridiculous, pathetic. The GP hates it. And it's normal because this song is horrible and has no chance to succeed.

In your opinion of course 

ad21B8Q.gif

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

TSUNAMI

Speechless was a promo single.

DITD was single only in Australia.

Hair was also a promo single.

So.

:neyde: 

Link to post
Share on other sites

GagaMyBlood95
34 minutes ago, JFK said:

Speechless was a promo single.

DITD was single only in Australia.

Hair was also a promo single.

So.

:neyde: 

Promo singles don't count, or singles that were released only in some countries and were left without a video or a proper live performance!

Single material is when the song actually gets proper single treatment.

Link to post
Share on other sites

TSUNAMI
15 minutes ago, GagaMyBlood95 said:

Promo singles don't count, or singles that were released only in some countries and were left without a video or a proper live performance!

Single material is when the song actually gets proper single treatment.

Hair and Speechless got more promo than G.U.Y and Perfect Illusion combined.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...