Would you rather Joanne be like I Want Your Love or Til It Happens To You?

[mucinex 4,260]

If Gaga went in a different direction for Joanne, which would you prefer: A more soft-rock/cinematic sound like Til It Happens To You, or a more Disco sound like I Want Your Love? 

I think songs like Perfect Illusion(see previous thread by @DontDoubtDavid) & Dancin' In Circles would sound better if they had a more disco influence:

 

I think songs such as Million Reasons(see Victoria Secret performance) & Angel Down would sound better with a cinematic sound:

 

 

[Gia Gunn 7,265]

Definetely disco  I didn't know I needed it til i heard it 

[Anderson123 35,415]

I Want Your Love by far. Gaga's voice suits disco, pop and many other genres and she's great at making that type of music. I like Til It Happens To You but I honestly never listen to it, I just don't enjoy Gaga's voice when she sings about tragedy because she drags it to this melancholic tone that I just have to be in the mood for, like Dope, Million Reasons or Angel Down. (Where are OUR LEADERRRSSSSS part)

[En_Sabah_Nur 9,356]

Is this even a question tho???!

 

[FATCAT 58,870]

"Would you rather be able to fly, as fast and as high as a plane, or would you rather be tortured for war crimes?"

[PMKKARDASHiAN 8,570]

Neither because both are tragic songs and neither are worthy of gagas discography

Fight me. 

Both ****in suck. 

Get over it. 

[RadioIsOurs 13,835]

[LaLuna 12,732]

No to both. I don't like either song and Joanne is perfect as it is. 

[Gonzi 2,800]

Although Til it happens to you suits very well in the Joanne tracklist imo, I think the album is perfect for what it was intended to do.

[ItsTommyBitch 12,640]

I think I was expecting something with elements of both I Want Your Love (in terms of the glamour and extravagance) and Perfect Illusion (the rock/psychedelic elements; the raw energy, a bit of the production)  

[macca 1,315]

Anything would have to be better than what we got 

[Poissonche 12,365]

49 minutes ago, macca said:

Anything would have to be better than what we got 

I feel them coming inside me through my eyes, my ears and my nostrils...

Spoiler

THE LIES.

Spoiler

joking, everyone is entitled to their own opinion.

Spoiler

their WRONG opinion.

Spoiler

but I respect it without sharing it.

Spoiler

and an opinion is never wrong.

Spoiler

I shall now invite myself out.