Lets Be Honest: Perfect Illusion is a Letdown

[CLLGaga 928]

1 hour ago, Karl said:

I think she wants to discontinue making music but didn't want ARTPOP to be the lasting memory from her discography so she made a personal record that will probably be well received by critics but not the general public. I think that's why she's not too bothered about promotion or anything.

Honey no. She just said a few days ago that she'll make music until she's really old. 

And btw PI got mixed reviews from critics so I wouldn't be too sure that Joanne will be well received.

[littlepotter 75,132]

Honey, you have every right to have an opinion, AND you have every right to create a thousand thread about it, but PLEASE. It's ignorant to assume the thousands of people who like the song are just 'delusional' or whatever else just because YOUR expectations weren't met. 'Let's be honest'? That is 100% the equivalent of 'let's not lie to ourselves'. Assuming PI is a letdown for everybody is pathetic.

[President Trump 3,508]

31 minutes ago, Mood Ring said:

@Ma Ma Pa Pa Pa Your posts are mildly disturbing. Are you ok?

Ad hominem attack blowing off my entire point because you don't like PI LOLOLOL

[Lextyr97 19,909]

5 minutes ago, Levine said:

I'm biased towards this weak fanbase and you know why?

Because if this song was currently PERCHED at #1 on iTunes, we would never have these kind of threads.

And y'all know it's the truth.

Don't quote me, thank you.

This. All of this.

[StarstruckIllusion 52,605]

This. Glad I'm not a cupcake & can process Gaga criticism other than "hate."

[littlepotter 75,132]

5 minutes ago, CLLGaga said:

Honey no. She just said a few days ago that she'll make music until she's really old. 

And btw PI got mixed reviews from critics so I wouldn't be too sure that Joanne will be well received.

where tho

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_Illusion

12 positive vs. 3 mixed or negative reviews. Mixed would be half in half. Critics are clearly more on her side this era than last.

[StarstruckIllusion 52,605]

10 hours ago, Lord Temptation said:

Not buying your arguments. If Perfect Illusion didn't affect you you wouldn't have written an essay about it. You definitely love it but want to act like you don't. Like a bottom who acts like a top.

What sort of backwards ass reply 

[Guest]

i lowkey agree too. its no banger for sure, but i love the direction/concept/style about it.

if she wants to create soul-healing music that brings people together, she should try harder tbh ...  bc lets be real: you have to be into gaga to let Perfect Illusion grow on you (which takes quite a few spins  ... )

[zexion_armando 241]

My favorite argument is "that's well like your opinion man."

 

you know it's because they have nothing to contribute 

[StarstruckIllusion 52,605]

10 hours ago, chiuga said:

I love how the fans keep bashing her and she still doesn't seem to care

"Bashing." Imagine thinking constructive criticism is attacking Gaga 

She doesn't care if & when we constantly praise her, either. Point cancelled.  

[Titan 632]

52 minutes ago, Beto said:

she needed to go full commercial this time IF WHAT SHE WANTS IN THE MUSIC INDUSTRY IS LONGEVITY AND LEGENDARY STATUS because that's something the GP gives to you

I'm sorry, for some reason I can't edit it but what I meant was she needed to go full commercial unless she created a masterpiece, which PI clearly isn't.

[Antonio 27,768]

40 minutes ago, littlepotter said:

Honey, you have every right to have an opinion, AND you have every right to create a thousand thread about it, but PLEASE. It's ignorant to assume the thousands of people who like the song are just 'delusional' or whatever else just because YOUR expectations weren't met. 'Let's be honest'? That is 100% the equivalent of 'let's not lie to ourselves'. Assuming PI is a letdown for everybody is pathetic.

TEA 

[BradP 387]

uh oh guys the art police is here

[Fiona Apple 13,006]

51 minutes ago, Levine said:

I'm biased towards this weak fanbase and you know why?

Because if this song was currently PERCHED at #1 on iTunes, we would never have these kind of threads.

And y'all know it's the truth.

Don't quote me, thank you.

The thing is that it's not a matter of luck if a song goes #1. There is a reason this song is not doing well and the reason is not that it has rock vibes or that it's alternative  I personally don't really HATE thes ong but it's really really weak for her standards

[nikola 4,342]

LOL i love this threads......not because i agree with them.....because i think most of them are stupid......just like this one.....but thanks to this thread i can see which user to ignore......thank god for ignore feature in this toxic times