Whether JOANNE flops or not

[mic 1,415]

2 minutes ago, Clip said:

But she literally said that PI wasn't representing Joanne's sound

I know about that, what I meant was more like overall quality, that timeless/iconic feel - which is missing. And songs from Back to black had it. But yeah it's just my opinion.

[DeanWinchester 41,390]

54 minutes ago, GagaInArt said:

I CAN'T BELIEVE THAT YOU ARE NOW SWITCHING SIDES  , good to have you back 

This but slay your change of heart @Bobbins 

[ScotHML 392]

2 minutes ago, LG said:

Why does this thread come after Adele? She's nothing but genuine and a sweetheart to everybody, and her music is also extremely genuine. Don't loathe her just because she's successful.

Exactly. She's consistent and very successful  

[PassTheTime 1,448]

1 minute ago, A Gaga Lad said:

This but slay your change of heart @Bobbins 

Gaga's spell is too strong 

[Bobbins 1,760]

3 minutes ago, LG said:

Why does this thread come after Adele? She's nothing but genuine and a sweetheart to everybody, and her music is also extremely genuine. Don't loathe her just because she's successful.

Didn't come for her. Lemonade is the better album and the critics agree. Adele will regurgitate the same sound, the same topics and the same chords in her music and people will endlessly praise her for that. She's the type of artist that chooses to release music to appeal to everyone. She's basically a more talented and successful Dido. It's not for me but she's a great singer. 

[Gaga Medicine 265]

11 minutes ago, Vague said:

Lemonade is visually dope. I really like that she did a film to go along with the record. Is it entirely her idea? Is it? I doubt it. Beyonce is one of those people of whom I sometimes like their output but I think its obvious she is not the leader of her domain. Shes perfectly crafted. Some people want to praise that, or they want to delude themselves into believing its all her all day. But I look at her output and I see a polished bore. I take no issue with her success and popularity though, at the end of the day I do generally like her. But I just can't say I find anything she does inherently innovative. Theres being a product and theres being a product with soul. The masses may be blinded but im not.

Wow. I completely agree.

[arthurhmangum 4,408]

Listen up, when Joanne drops, I DO NOT WANT TO SEE A SINGLE ****ING NASTY OPINION ABOUT THIS RECORD. This is the most personal record Gaga has made to date, and it’s new territory for her. You don’t like Perfect Illusion? Fine. You don’t like the record? Ok. BUT DO NOT POST ANY NASTY THINGS WHERE GAGA CAN SEE IT. Keep your opinion to yourself. Do not bash her for writing about what is most personal to her. We are not about to have an ARTPOP reaction 2.0.