"Lady Gaga doesn't think the government should decide if a crime happened"

[Azor Ahai 18,861]

"Lady Gaga doesn't think the government should be deciding whether or not crimes happened"

https://www.reddit.com/r/TumblrInAction/comments/46q501/lady_gaga_doesnt_think_the_government_should_be/

A post was created on Reddit with that title, based on this image :

 

They are completely missing the point

 Gaga said they should help the victim first and provide him or her with help but the Redditors thought she meant people should get charged for rape without any proof.

[Dominic 11,922]

One of the images is being shared on Facebook and it's so out of context.  

She is saying we should help the victim first before we even consider the evidence.  

[Church 849]

How are people not understanding what she is saying? She is clear in the way she speaks and she expressed the idea eloquently. Also, why are people not agreeing with her?

[Creyk 18,025]

What you were wearing is not beside the point though

 

[Helix 1,487]

People on sites like reddit usually tend to love tearing down ""SJWs"" regardless of point or reason, so I'm not surprised. 

[BestFriend 646]

6 minutes ago, Azor Ahai said:

"Lady Gaga doesn't think the government should be deciding whether or not crimes happened"

https://www.reddit.com/r/TumblrInAction/comments/46q501/lady_gaga_doesnt_think_the_government_should_be/

The post was created based on this image :

 

They are completely missing the point

 Gaga said they should help the victim first and provide him or her with help but the Redditors thought she meant people should get charged for rape without any proof.

 

4 minutes ago, Dominic Marc said:

One of the images is being shared on Facebook and it's so out of context.  

She is saying we should help the victim first before we even consider the evidence.  

With all honesty, Gaga was wrong to phrase it that way. The government is the final arbiter and it's best for all of us that way.

I get what she meant anyway. I'm just saying that celebs should be extremely careful of what they say.

[Azor Ahai 18,861]

Just now, Church said:

How are people not understanding what she is saying? She is clear in the way she speaks and she expressed the idea eloquently. Also, why are people not agreeing with her?

That picture is out of context, and espesially the first one makes it as if Gaga is a comunist or something  

[OmgSum1Actually 3,041]

But the important thing is that this pic went viral, any promo is good promo 

[Church 849]

2 minutes ago, Azor Ahai said:

That picture is out of context, and espesially the first one makes it as if Gaga is a comunist or something  

Not for anyone who has a brain. I can look at that picture and understand the context perfectly. It's just a case of more people desperately searching for something to be offended by and bitch about.

[Duella Dvil 10,614]

Wow. That stayed a lot cleaner than a lot of the debates on here.

[Brainiac 11,097]

6 minutes ago, Creyk said:

What you were wearing is not beside the point though

 

Yes...Yes it is...  

A woman could be walking butt ass naked down the street and that still doesn't excuse a man from going up to her and touching/penetrating her without consent. Dressing "provocative" is not saying "come and get it!"

 

[Sizzily 14,555]

I'm subscribed to TiA and I was like "Nooooooo" when I saw it. Thank god she's getting good publicity at the Oscars so this can be swept under the rug 

[Creyk 18,025]

1 minute ago, Brainiac said:

Yes...Yes it is...  

A woman could be walking butt ass naked down the street and that still doesn't excuse a man from going up to her and touching/penetrating her without consent. Dressing "provocative" is not saying "come and get it!"

 

 Do you sometimes live in the real world, or are you just in this internet space?

That is not realistic and you know it

 

[Azor Ahai 18,861]

1 minute ago, Sizzliy said:

I'm subscribed to TiA and I was like "Nooooooo" when I saw it. Thank god she's getting good publicity at the Oscars so this can be swept under the rug 

I'm subscribed aswell but lately half the posts have been borderline stupid. People want more karma I guess.

[BestFriend 646]

1 minute ago, Brainiac said:

Yes...Yes it is...  

A woman could be walking butt ass naked down the street and that still doesn't excuse a man from going up to her and touching/penetrating her without consent. Dressing "provocative" is not saying "come and get it!"

 

I agree Brainiac!!! Gaga should have just summarised her point by saying that we shouldn't trivialize the victim's plight by asking value-neutral questions. Questions should be kept objective, straightforward, relevant, non-condescending and unassuming.