61/100 American Horror Story Season 5 on Metacritic - 52% on RT

[Hellspont 1,468]

glad its green lol, the show has become more about the acting and visuals than horror the last 3 seasons anyways

[AgusPop 4,064]

How can they make a review of a whole serie just based on the first episode. 

Its like make a review of an entire album only listening one song. Mess   the critics always amaze me

[Fiona Apple 13,006]

Still good tho.. Asylum has 67

[Stef 60,758]

Still good tho.. Asylum has 67

and freakshow has 69  

[Mr Ricky 8,775]

I already stopped caring when I saw this hateful post. The gaga hater is real in this one. 

---

The cast is mostly terrific, of course, including Mare Winningham as an unhinged hotel maid. The exception, unfortunately, is Lady Gaga.

---

[Fiona Apple 13,006]

and freakshow has 69  

Freakshow is great + it had a GREAT first EP... I was actually wrong btw .Asylum has 65 

[Fiona Apple 13,006]

I already stopped caring when I saw this hateful post. The gaga hater is real in this one. 

---

The cast is mostly terrific, of course, including Mare Winningham as an unhinged hotel maid. The exception, unfortunately, is Lady Gaga.

---

At least every other critic was positive about her

[Cry 77]

It’s as if Stefani Germanotta’s Lady Gaga was conjured for the precise purpose of starring in American Horror Story. Everything about her jaw-dropping presence, sheer star power and always outrageous eccentricity makes her an ideal fit for the FX show. While she may not fill the void left by former AHS heroine Jessica Lange (who could?), she does bring a glistening, diva-centric magnetism to the lead female role. Murphy wants you to gasp every moment Gaga’s Countess appears on screen, whether it’s from her stunning attire or ghostly bleached eyebrows and pale skin, and it’s hard not to. But can she act? That remains to be seen, since Gaga does little more than play a heightened version of her own pop star persona. Gaga’s Countess plays like a caricature of Old Hollywood starlets, with her few lines of dialogue tinged with an uneven Transatlantic accent. She’s not great, but the less she says the more intriguing she becomes. After all, we don’t watch American Horror Story for great acting, we watch it for the characters, and Gaga is the most striking character in pop culture today.

http://screencrush.com/american-horror-story-hotel-review-lady-gaga/



NOOOOOOOOOOOO OMG NOOOOOOO "She’s not great" 

[Cry 77]

At least every other critic was positive about her

No  There is another negative review 

[mister max 18,480]

is this good or....  

[mister max 18,480]

It’s as if Stefani Germanotta’s Lady Gaga was conjured for the precise purpose of starring in American Horror Story. Everything about her jaw-dropping presence, sheer star power and always outrageous eccentricity makes her an ideal fit for the FX show. While she may not fill the void left by former AHS heroine Jessica Lange (who could?), she does bring a glistening, diva-centric magnetism to the lead female role. Murphy wants you to gasp every moment Gaga’s Countess appears on screen, whether it’s from her stunning attire or ghostly bleached eyebrows and pale skin, and it’s hard not to. But can she act? That remains to be seen, since Gaga does little more than play a heightened version of her own pop star persona. Gaga’s Countess plays like a caricature of Old Hollywood starlets, with her few lines of dialogue tinged with an uneven Transatlantic accent. She’s not great, but the less she says the more intriguing she becomes. After all, we don’t watch American Horror Story for great acting, we watch it for the characters, and Gaga is the most striking character in pop culture today.

http://screencrush.com/american-horror-story-hotel-review-lady-gaga/



NOOOOOOOOOOOO OMG NOOOOOOO "She’s not great" 

so they are actually saying that the less gaga speaks the better it is  

[Fiona Apple 13,006]

No  There is another negative review 

Link or it doesn't exist  Btw I do believe that.But some negative reviews always exist so it's okay to me 

[Cry 77]

so they are actually saying that the less gaga speaks the better it is  

Basically I don't like this review 

[Cry 77]

Link or it doesn't exist  Btw I do believe that.But some negative reviews always exist so it's okay to me 

The link is below the post http://screencrush.com/american-horror-story-hotel-review-lady-gaga/

[Fiona Apple 13,006]

It’s as if Stefani Germanotta’s Lady Gaga was conjured for the precise purpose of starring in American Horror Story. Everything about her jaw-dropping presence, sheer star power and always outrageous eccentricity makes her an ideal fit for the FX show. While she may not fill the void left by former AHS heroine Jessica Lange (who could?), she does bring a glistening, diva-centric magnetism to the lead female role. Murphy wants you to gasp every moment Gaga’s Countess appears on screen, whether it’s from her stunning attire or ghostly bleached eyebrows and pale skin, and it’s hard not to. But can she act? That remains to be seen, since Gaga does little more than play a heightened version of her own pop star persona. Gaga’s Countess plays like a caricature of Old Hollywood starlets, with her few lines of dialogue tinged with an uneven Transatlantic accent. She’s not great, but the less she says the more intriguing she becomes. After all, we don’t watch American Horror Story for great acting, we watch it for the characters, and Gaga is the most striking character in pop culture today.

http://screencrush.com/american-horror-story-hotel-review-lady-gaga/



NOOOOOOOOOOOO OMG NOOOOOOO "She’s not great" 

This is not a negative review.. It says that she is good but she is not a great actor or as good as Jessica..And it pretty much says that she is good for the show because she doesn't need to have great acting skills for it but a great character. You took the only negative phrase on the review.... Why could you do that?