Is Born This Way the best album ever released by a major pop girl?

[Versace 7,959]

In my Opinion if we are talking mainstream POP and only POP these albums are better than Born This Way in that factor

The Fame Monster , Teenage Dream , The Dutchess, I Am...Sasha Fierce , LOUD, Loose and more tbh if we look into it. BTW is overrated in my opinion my least fav Gaga album sorry but not sorry.

To me these tracks off BTW I get being overrated

1-Born This Way

2-Judas

3-The Edge Of Glory

4-Marry The Night

5-Bloody Mary

6-Scheisse

7-Heavy Metal Lover

8-Electric Chapel

9-Government Hooker

The rest I don't get being overrated , the other half of the album is ok and nothing mind blowing

[Kacey Elizabeth 900]

No, The Fame Monster is better  

As a whole and album, The Fame Monster wins over Born This Way. However, BTW has some of Gaga's best songs (Hair, Marry The Night, The Edge Of Glory, Heavy Metal Lover, Bloody Mary, and Scheisse) which are better than some songs from TFM, but again, as a whole and album, TFM tops BTW.

[djBuffoon 12,118]

All of her albums are in the top tier in terms of quality and outside-the-box imagination. We stan for a talented ****ing woman.

[blacklistedd 599]

No

I like it a lot though.

[Yepiz92 127]

of course at least in my opinion

[Bleachella 2,932]

Not when all of Taylor's discography exists 

I'd put it at 3rd best 

[BillieGOAT 5,216]

No.

Both The Fame Monster and ARTPOP are better than Born This Way

 

[gagaisitalian 3,573]

Gagz, Dido & old school Nelly Furtado are far better

That's your opinion, and frankly, I don't care about it.

Stay on your own post and don't quote mine.

[VFD 57]

Lol no, it's literally her worst, ****ty album with few good songs (TEOG, hair, You & I, BTW), and the rest are growers, as a fan I forced myself to buy and listen to the whole album more than once Where the songs has grown on me (and I love them now), but a non-fan wouldn't give the songs a second listen.

And why is it bad if the songs are growers? The easy-listening and hook formula in pop songs is a restrictive mindset that kills musical curiosity and appreciation.

I say this because it is one of the reasons why I love Born This Way. It's still a pop album, but doesn't rely on quick, simple hooks. It takes several listens to grasp each song, and even then you can still find new sounds in the layered production. How can you call it a "****ty album", even though you've learnt to love those songs eventually?

[AIex 3,102]

ARTPOP = TFM > BTW >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> the other floppy pop girl's lives

[VasilisVas 5,164]

The Fame Monster slays Born This Way. BTW was a good album, but too many songs on there that should've have even existed.  TFM is flawless and unlike anything any other pop girl has done. 

[ItsTommyBitch 12,640]

There's at least 5 Madonna albums better than BTW  

Of your listed artists though maybe...

I don't know any, but im guessing you're thinking American Life is one?  

 

...  

[Jjang 2,262]

Why would you use the word "ever" and then carry on to dismiss the existence of artists that had a longer career. Lmao, that doesn't add up. Anyway, of course not.

[Jjang 2,262]

I don't know any, but im guessing you're thinking American Life is one?  

 

...  

Erotica 

Like a Prayer

Ray of Light

Music 

Confessions 

no need for American Life.

Although it could be included as well   

[Prismatic 4,789]

Best album ever. Nope. Far from it when there's the masterpiece, "The Fame Monster".