'Katy Perry has more self-written songs in her debut album than Gaga.'

[Sugarfall 3,723]

And yet won 0 grammys for it

​Where's 1Ds Grammys?

This Grammy thing is so old and stupid  

[LoveandMagic 1,731]

I don't have a problem with Katy getting songwriting credit where it's due. Good for her for penning some very likable and popular songs, but can we stop with this fan warring? Some people don't like Katy. That's fine, not every Gaga fan is "pressed" or a Nazi for the actions of a few or for even making a criticism, so let's stop the constant bashing of Gaga and her fans (like I couldn't go to a Katy fan site and see Gaga and Taylor/Monsters and Swifties ripped to shreds there by dozens of Katy Kats ). As for Katy, there are certain trolls on here that are making a bad name for the lot of us. They need to stop instigating and let Katy fans enjoy her music, tours, accomplishments, and videos, etc, (and not just Katy). 

Katy and Gaga are two completely different artists. Let's stop comparing the two and try to "one up" each other. People can criticize both, but let's be respectful. This should be a fun place to hang out. Everyone has different tastes and standards. I'm tired of the trolling here and on twitter. We are all (Monsters and Katy Kats) better than that. 

And I am not trying at all to attack the OP here, I just think things snowball too easily downhill. Let's not make this like every other fan forum on the internet. 

[Fiona Apple 13,006]

 Where's 1Ds Grammys?

This Grammy thing is so old and stupid  

​1D suck

[Sugarfall 3,723]

​1D suck

​Cool, that wasn't what I was talking about. 

[ShockPop 7,747]

If we're counting "Katy Hudson" why aren't we counting "Red and Blue"? How ridiculous. 

[Supersonic 49,376]

Appearently if you got a co-writer who changed like some of the harmonies, you have not written the song anymore. Because there can only be one true songwriter who receives a picture of Tyra Banks at the end of the episode.

[Fiona Apple 13,006]

​Cool, that wasn't what I was talking about. 

You said "Where's 1Ds Grammys?" They don't have grammys because they don't deserve any

[Vernier 3,786]

Why are people bothered? it's been documented how generous Gaga is with her writing credits(unlike some people, cough), so this is hardly something to be salty over  

[Kayla 7,595]

thought we couldnt make threads about nothing but a tweet but i guess thats just an azealia banks rule  

It's for social media stuff an artist does. So if Katy were to tweet about writing music, it'd go in her thread. 

 

This tweet/thread includes Gaga too though, so I'm lenient about it. 

[Kayla 7,595]

I don't have a problem with Katy getting songwriting credit where it's due. Good for her for penning some very likable and popular songs, but can we stop with this fan warring? Some people don't like Katy. That's fine, not every Gaga fan is "pressed" or a Nazi for the actions of a few or for even making a criticism, so let's stop the constant bashing of Gaga and her fans (like I couldn't go to a Katy fan site and see Gaga and Taylor/Monsters and Swifties ripped to shreds there by dozens of Katy Kats ). As for Katy, there are certain trolls on here that are making a bad name for the lot of us. They need to stop instigating and let Katy fans enjoy her music, tours, accomplishments, and videos, etc, (and not just Katy). 

Katy and Gaga are two completely different artists. Let's stop comparing the two and try to "one up" each other. People can criticize both, but let's be respectful. This should be a fun place to hang out. Everyone has different tastes and standards. I'm tired of the trolling here and on twitter. We are all (Monsters and Katy Kats) better than that. 

And I am not trying at all to attack the OP here, I just think things snowball too easily downhill. Let's not make this like every other fan forum on the internet. 

:yes:

[Ronk 14,762]

If we're counting "Katy Hudson" why aren't we counting "Red and Blue"? How ridiculous. 

​Gaga was the only writer on all the songs in Red and Blue.

[liz89 373]

I don't have a problem with Katy getting songwriting credit where it's due. Good for her for penning some very likable and popular songs, but can we stop with this fan warring? Some people don't like Katy. That's fine, not every Gaga fan is "pressed" or a Nazi for the actions of a few or for even making a criticism, so let's stop the constant bashing of Gaga and her fans (like I couldn't go to a Katy fan site and see Gaga and Taylor/Monsters and Swifties ripped to shreds there by dozens of Katy Kats ). As for Katy, there are certain trolls on here that are making a bad name for the lot of us. They need to stop instigating and let Katy fans enjoy her music, tours, accomplishments, and videos, etc, (and not just Katy). 

Katy and Gaga are two completely different artists. Let's stop comparing the two and try to "one up" each other. People can criticize both, but let's be respectful. This should be a fun place to hang out. Everyone has different tastes and standards. I'm tired of the trolling here and on twitter. We are all (Monsters and Katy Kats) better than that. 

And I am not trying at all to attack the OP here, I just think things snowball too easily downhill. Let's not make this like every other fan forum on the internet. 

This this this  !!!

[ShockPop 7,747]

​Gaga was the only writer on all the songs in Red and Blue.

​Then Gaga wrote more of her debut than Katy. Unquestionable.

[Holland 7]

Katy has two self written tracks (Thinking of You, Mannequin) on her debut album (One Of The Boys), those are the only self written tracks on all of her albums, others tracks' writing credits are shared with the producers. Gaga has two self written tracks (Speechless, You & I) on all of her albums, and just like Katy all the other tracks' writing credits are shared with the producers. I would say Katy and Gaga are both similar song writers, where they create songs together with the producers. So the tweet in the OP obviously isn't true. 

[ShockPop 7,747]

Katy has two self written tracks (Thinking of You, Mannequin) on her debut album (One Of The Boys), those are the only self written tracks on all of her albums, others tracks' writing credits are shared with the producers. Gaga has two self written tracks (Speechless, You & I) on all of her albums, and just like Katy all the other tracks' writing credits are shared with the producers. I would say Katy and Gaga are both similar song writers, where they create songs together with the producers. So the tweet in the OP obviously isn't true. 

​Wrong. "Again Again" (which was on the uk version of The Fame) had Gaga as the sole writing credit.