Jump to content
Poster

LIVE: SXSW Show Official Discussion Topic


Nagel340
 Share

Featured Posts

You all do know that technically there was no bile, right? Millie Brown doesn't eat for two days prior to the performance so that the only thing actually being thrown up is the colored milk.

****ing educate yourselves.

Link to post
Share on other sites

hausoffame

She's not trying to be punk

This is how she was back in the day lighting hair spray on fire

I guess the shock value has always been there, but I think it's time she moved on. I'm not hating on her, just my opinion. I just didn't feel anything from this performance emotionally. Usually her performances touch me in some way.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Doncho

tbh... if someone puked on her onstage as part of the performance... she should've saved that for the Grammys.

:manicure:

 

She doesnt care about promotion and commercial success, remember?  :derpga:

Link to post
Share on other sites

ModernEcstasy

I don't know what to say. A little bit of my love for Gaga died tonight. I'm hoping that artRAVE is nothing like this. I hated it. Also, I'm annoyed at how hypocritical it was of her to sing Dope. She needs to stop smoking and drinking. The Gaga from Swinefest was like a completely different person. This was so difficult to watch.

If she wants to get high/drunk, then do it on your own time. Not when u have been paid millions to put on a show and can't even be f***ed to shower.

This was not art. It was lazy and rude to the fans that were there to see a well organised set.

Edited by Gagabloke
Link to post
Share on other sites

QueenMortuana

It's terribly absurd for everyone to judge her for what she did tonight. If she wasn't "honest" to her fans about her situations with addictions you all wouldn't be criticizing what she did during the performance. And just because we haven't had her in the public and telling us whats going on does not mean she has been taking a vacation from her career. She got drunk, big ****ing deal. She smokes cigarettes and she's been doing it for way longer than we've known about her. That has no result on what she's doing right now either. Maybe vocally, but she sounded great. And if she puffed on a joint all you butthurt fans can get over it too. Because once again it is something she's been doing way longer than you've listened to her and it really has no effect on her performances.

 

Even if she was taking a vacation who the **** cares?

The girl is rich, shes happy, shes been working for years and even hurt herself doing it. If she chooses to relax during and after the release of an album it is her choice. 

 

Stop getting on her case for being a human being. She's not your slave. 

 

 

Once again, if she wasn't honest about her struggles with marijuana what would you be b---hing about?

 

I can be warned for whatever I say here if I am being a dick but really she did nothing wrong tonight. She seemed fine. She is allowed to let go of the self you all know once in a while. And it's ****ing weed. She didn't even seem high; only drunk. I'd understand if she seemed coked up but she didn't so get over it. If you don't like who she is being, get over it. She is who she is and she does what she wants.

 

Bravo Gaga, bravo.

Edited by Zelenyy
Link to post
Share on other sites

I thought the entire show was great! YES, she went to the point where most of us are not used to going or expected to go. But, regardless, she did it without a single care. Thats what should be applauded here. The woman has a big pair. I enjoy the show, and was finally shock once again (its been a long wait) by the one and only lady gaga, a living rockstar. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

And i was worried that i couldn't go to the ArtRave  :troll:

 

I don't mind the puking, the bad vocals, trying to be anti-pop and so on. It's her choice, she can do what she wants. But some people shouldn't also be disrespectful to people who didn't like it. She is a pop star, she made a a pop Album and it didn't go well and now she is like "oh **** on everything bla bla", i don't care about the bling and so on. But to me she is just showing how affected she is buy ARTPOP underperforming, and i can understand why some people are sad. 

 

If she continues to go this route, i hope she is prepared for what is coming, cause i don't want to see her crying for attention.

While I do feel like artRAVE will be far more polished. I get what you're saying. I'll always love her and what she's done for me and others but I think the big divide of this performance in the fanbase is the fact that there are some people on this site that will co-sign LITERALLY EVERYTHING she does. I don't know how I'm feeling about it all but I liked the swine puking thing but other than that...idk. The entirety of this performance just made me feel some type of way.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Blueskittles

She mentioned rape

 

Being puked on = literal representation of how dirty she must have felt while it happened

This is sad but unfortunately, many victims or rape do react physically by vomiting right after the fact of experiencing rape. It's a normal reaction. This makes sense.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Golden Gangsta

I loved it so much. It w as a lot better than what I was expecting!

 

The vomiting part was my favourite. Anyone getting upset over it can go suck it :heart:

Link to post
Share on other sites

I am highly disappointed in her. This tonight went too far, this is not "art" this just seems like she lost it and is seeking attention in a Miley way. Even the twirling around when she opened the show...it was all a mess. I seriously can't believe it I'm in shock I can't even express what I feel.  :ohno:

Didn't realize the girl had so many parents out there. She's doing what she wants and if you can't support her then deuces! I understand most fans aren't going to like everything she does but the crying is getting out of control.

Like she said.. "... some of you will betray me."

Couldn't be more true now :awkney:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Judas Oyster

Some think it was rage she said though.

She clearly said "This song is about rape" *the crowd goes silent.....* "blablabla and about rage"

Edited by Judas Oyster
Link to post
Share on other sites

It's terribly absurd for everyone to judge her for what she did tonight. If she wasn't "honest" to her fans about her situations with addictions you all wouldn't be criticizing what she did during the performance. And just because we haven't had her in the public and telling us whats going on does not mean she has been taking a vacation from her career. She got drunk, big ****ing deal. She smokes cigarettes and she's been doing it for way longer than we've known about her. That has no result on what she's doing right now either. Maybe vocally, but she sounded great. And if she puffed on a joint all you butthurt fans can get over it too. Because once again it is something she's been doing way longer than you've listened to her and it really has no effect on her performances.

 

Even if she was taking a vacation who the **** cares?

The girl is rich, shes happy, shes been working for years and even hurt herself doing it. If she chooses to relax during and after the release of an album it is her choice. 

 

Stop getting on her case for being a human being. She's not your slave. 

 

 

Once again, if she wasn't honest about her struggles with marijuana what would you be b---hing about?

 

I can be warned for whatever I say here if I am being a dick but really she did nothing wrong tonight. She seemed fine. She is allowed to let go of the self you all know once in a while. And it's ****ing weed. She didn't even seem high; only drunk. I'd understand if she seemed coked up but she didn't so get over it. If you don't like who she is being, get over it. She is who she is and she does what she wants.

 

Bravo Gaga, bravo.

 

its just like beliebers melting down everytime he is seen with selena gomez or is seen smoking weed because "he broke his promise that he wouldnt smoke it again"

 

#cut4gaga

Link to post
Share on other sites

hausoffame

So sick of all the complaining. She didn't mean it in a negative light. If you follow what she says and the message of the album she's saying that she will NOT be commercially pop. This is what the world and her label wants and she's not giving in. Powerful message and I have never been more proud to be a fan than I am now

It's not complaining, I'm entitled to my opinion. Just funny that she poses for Versace, goes to the Oscars and all this glitz and glamour and then performs like this. Just seems hypocritical. Plus to say she struggles with addiction and then to smoke weed on stage, just seems desperate. I love her and the music, but she just sends mixed messages.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

 Share


×
×
  • Create New...