Jump to content

Edge Of Glory/You and I


Giorgiii

Featured Posts

Tommy Monster

since when youtube views determine the quality of a song

 

They don´t determine it, but are part of the determination after all... look at BR or Alejandro... great songs with great vids and many views... and I think that we can all agree that You and I was the worst single choice when there were bangers like Scheisse and HML on the album...

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 41
  • Created
  • Last Reply
VforVendetta

America was the only country where it didn´t flop... :ohwell: they hardly ever played it here + do you really think that with that great video, it would have so little views if the song was acctually good or appealing to the public???

You are very wrong here. Y & I is country, it's a completely unfriendly gerne outside of the US. Not even Taylor Swift managed to get any country hits outside of the US in her whole career. (except from maybe 1-2 exceptions the most).
Link to post
Share on other sites

MonsterOfSpain

They don´t determine it, but are part of the determination after all... look at BR or Alejandro... great songs with great vids and many views... and I think that we can all agree that You and I was the worst single choice when there were bangers like Scheisse and HML on the album...

 

Then Marry The Night and Do What U Want are bad songs too

 

I love your logic :legend:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Tommy Monster

You are very wrong here. Y & I is country, it's a completely unfriendly gerne outside of the US. Not even Taylor Swift managed to get any country hits outside of the US in her whole career. (except from maybe 1-2 exceptions the most).

 

That´s what I´m telling... it didn´t appeal anywhere else, but in America :shrug:

Then Marry The Night and Do What U Want are bad songs too

 

I love your logic :legend:

 

Well, MTN IS a bad song imo, but I don´t wanna start a war here :laughga: and DWYW doesn´t have a video... 

Link to post
Share on other sites

VforVendetta

That´s what I´m telling... it didn´t appeal anywhere else, but in America :shrug:

Well, MTN IS a bad song imo, but I don´t wanna start a war here :laughga: and DWYW doesn´t have a video...

This has nothing to do with the quality of the song though...
Link to post
Share on other sites

MonsterOfSpain

That´s what I´m telling... it didn´t appeal anywhere else, but in America :shrug:

 

Well, MTN IS a bad song imo, but I don´t wanna start a war here :laughga: and DWYW doesn´t have a video... 

 

:laughga:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Tommy Monster

This has nothing to do with the quality of the song though...

 

Well then I guess it has to do with Gaga´s decision that wasn´t right in my oppinion...

Link to post
Share on other sites

I just realized

 

TEOG- good song with a floppy video

Yuyi- flawless video with a flawless song

 

Gags, couldn´t you combine it a little bit???  :laughga:

fixed :legend:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Seriously, what do you all see about that song??? It was overplayed even before BTW was released :toofunny:

I just love it, and the video is my favorite from the BTW era. :flutter: Just my personal preference but I love it. :music:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Tommy Monster

I just love it, and the video is my favorite from the BTW era. :flutter: Just my personal preference but I love it. :music:

 

Well, the video is really great, I have to admit, but the song feels like ripped out of 70´s... from time to time I can enjoy it, but I just don´t feel it should have been a single... poor Scheisse and HML... but I think we´ll never stop moaning about those two :ohwell:

Link to post
Share on other sites

VforVendetta

Well then I guess it has to do with Gaga´s decision that wasn´t right in my oppinion...

It wasn't the best single choice but its a beautiful song that hes elements from Queen's We will rock you and Brian May plays the guitar. The lyrics are very beautiful and the vide if the song great.
Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, the video is really great, I have to admit, but the song feels like ripped out of 70´s... from time to time I can enjoy it, but I just don´t feel it should have been a single... poor Scheisse and HML... but I think we´ll never stop moaning about those two :ohwell:

The two singles that should have been... :emo: #NEVERFORGET

Link to post
Share on other sites

Tommy Monster

The two singles that should have been... :emo: #NEVERFORGET

 

Get ready, there is gonna be even more of them on ARTPOP...  :emo:  :emo:

Link to post
Share on other sites

America was the only country where it didn´t flop... :ohwell: they hardly ever played it here + do you really think that with that great video, it would have so little views if the song was acctually good or appealing to the public???

Actually the whole idea behind Y&I was PRACTICALLY the original TEOG Idea. The original TEOG one featured mermaids (and Marines), a transformation scene, a doctor, an old looking hospital, New York and the Brooklyn Bride

Of course the director left so they made the TEOG video we have now

I'm not even lying if you look it up you'll see set photos

 

Anyway, everybody in my town + everyone I knew from other places really liked the song :shrug:

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Shadow locked this topic

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...