Brooklyn Nights vs. Earthquake

[gagacabana 8,147]

Gotta be Brooklyn Nights for me 

I can't even imagine what it must have felt like to experience these songs in real time tho. I'd be so pissed off at her for not releasing them 

[Lucas 31,401]

Love both but Brooklyn Nights clears. Would've been the best song on ARTPOP by far  I'd even go as far as saying that it's top 15 in her entire discography

Edited 9 hours ago by Lucas

[peggyhill 2,097]

2 minutes ago, gagacabana said:

Gotta be Brooklyn Nights for me 

I can't even imagine what it must have felt like to experience these songs in real time tho. I'd be so pissed off at her for not releasing them 

Earthquake literally shook us to the core when it leaked

[MaybeKermit 5,222]

Brooklyn Nights is one of Gaga’s most emotional songs to me tbh. From the second the song starts I just start cryingggg

like it’s so beautiful, but sad, but beautiful  

it just perfectly captures that feeling of looking back at a failed relationship but still remembering some beautiful moments, so u kinda grieve it but u also know it was doomed, and u are at peace with it..: bittersweet

this is what I miss in some of her recent works: that raw honesty 

Edited 9 hours ago by MaybeKermit

[BabylonSaints 5,364]

Brooklyn Nights every single time. I love Earthquake, but BN just hits different. I get goosebumps every time I listen to it, and not just from the lyrics either.

[gagacabana 8,147]

13 minutes ago, Lucas said:

it's top 15 in her entire discography

This made me remember @Ladle Ghoulash 's 111 ranking list   where is BN at, Mary?

[Bronco 26,866]

Its not that I dont wanna love you

[Controversiaga 16,835]

Earthquake.

BN is so overrated by this fan base 

[Duella Dvil 11,759]

I FOUND AN OLD PAIR OF KEYS IN MY PURSE THAT OPENED THE WALKUP WE SHARED

[DESTROY UR DISEASE 21,082]

2 hours ago, Controversiaga said:

BN is so overrated by this fan base 

so is your existence here

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 32,078]

Both are really great

but I have to go with Earthquake even though we only have a small portion of the song and it’s clearly unfinished

[Cherry Blues 460]

9 hours ago, Lucas said:

Love both but Brooklyn Nights clears. Would've been the best song on ARTPOP by far  I'd even go as far as saying that it's top 15 in her entire discography

Brooklyn Nights has a beautiful melody, but ARTPOP would have needed more tracks like Venus or the title track ARTPOP to represent the concept of the record.