How would you define EarlyGa?

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 32,066]

 

I feel that most people would say EarlyGa was from early The Fame to late ARTPOP, but is that how you guys see it?

If you split Gaga’s career into two halves, the middle is mid-2017, right after the Super Bowl, the days of The Cure, when she was filming A Star Is Born.

Do you consider ASIB the start of Gaga’s latest adventures? Do you even consider there’s an EarlyGa time at all?

Discuss!

[Controversiaga 16,824]

Anything up to ARTPOP yes

 

[LOVEDRUG 11,321]

I would consider it to be The Fame up to ARTPOP.

I kind of disagree with the premise of splitting her career into two parts though. I think three works better. One for The Fame up to ARTPOP, one for Cheek to Cheek up to Love for Sale, and one from Harlequin onwards. I don't see how Mayhem is part of the same phase of her career as Joanne.

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 32,066]

18 minutes ago, Controversiaga said:

Anything up to ARTPOP yes

 

 

6 minutes ago, LOVEDRUG said:

I would consider it to be The Fame up to ARTPOP.

Would that include ARTPOP itself or would it be right before ARTPOP’s start?

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 32,066]

7 minutes ago, LOVEDRUG said:

I think three works better. One for The Fame up to ARTPOP, one for Cheek to Cheek up to Love for Sale, and one from Harlequin onwards. I don't see how Mayhem is part of the same phase of her career as Joanne.

I see what you mean, but if there’s three parts, I feel that it’s weird to put C2C and LFS in the same part… it’s hard to tell why, but I feel that Gaga was in a drastically different atmosphere. C2C (to me) belongs to the time of The Fame, Born This Way and such, while LFS is when Gaga was undeniably down, if not dead on the inside, with Enigma, Chromatica, Tudor etc.

C2C feels like it was done with EarlyGa’s eye of the tiger 

[LOVEDRUG 11,321]

6 minutes ago, AVeryGagaHolyDick said:

I see what you mean, but if there’s three parts, I feel that it’s weird to put C2C and LFS in the same part… it’s hard to tell why, but I feel that Gaga was in a drastically different atmosphere. C2C (to me) belongs to the time of The Fame, Born This Way and such, while LFS is when Gaga was undeniably down, if not dead on the inside, with Enigma, Chromatica, Tudor etc.

C2C feels like it was done with EarlyGa’s eye of the tiger 

I think Cheek to Cheek is definitely a transitionary period, between those two phases of her career. I'd put it at the very start of the second phase, but considering how entangled it was with the artRAVE and whatnot, I can absolutely see why you wouldn't.

[LOVEDRUG 11,321]

11 minutes ago, AVeryGagaHolyDick said:

 

Would that include ARTPOP itself or would it be right before ARTPOP’s start?

I would include ARTPOP in that early phase. In terms of management, commercial success and public perception, it was, up until that point, the low point of her career, and I think it works best as the project to close that chapter.

[gagacabana 8,066]

EarlyGa being 2007-2017 makes sense to me as in the first decade of Lady Gaga, but in all honesty, it feels like EarlyGa ended the moment GaGa turned into Gaga (so like, BTW i think?) 

From ARTPOP to House of Gucci, it was the Dark Ages, which marks Joker-Mayhem as the Renaissance 

[Starmie25 22,702]

25 minutes ago, AVeryGagaHolyDick said:

if not dead on the inside, with Enigma, Chromatica, Tudor etc.

[Lucas 31,381]

Imo:

The Fame to ARTPOP: EarlyGa
Cheek To Cheek to Love For Sale: Gaga trying to rediscover herself/Trying new & different things
Harlequin to now: A "return to form" somehow

[VTV 14,052]

its pre-Bobby Campbell and post-Bobby Campbell

[TEANUS 16,159]

Pre-The Fame / The Fame - Jurassic Era

The Fame Monster / Born This Way - Ancient Era

ARTPOP / Cheek to Cheek - Medieval Era

Joanne / A Star Is Born - Renaissance Era / Age of Enlightenment 

Chromatica / Love For Sale - Post-Classical Era

Harlequin / MAYHEM / Devil Wears Prada -  Modern Era

Edited 37 minutes ago by TEANUS

[Controversiaga 16,824]

1 hour ago, AVeryGagaHolyDick said:

 

Would that include ARTPOP itself or would it be right before ARTPOP’s start?

Including ARTPOP yes

even tho at the time for me ARTPOP felt like the beginning of new Gaga , but now in hindsight, it really was AFTER ARTPOP 

[imogen2133 617]

Yes I would easily split it as EarlyGa was from The Fame to ARTPOP and newGa is from Joanne to now. A lot changed after ARTPOP so it is easy for me to split the 2 like that. 

[gagacabana 8,066]

1 hour ago, gagacabana said:

EarlyGa being 2007-2017 makes sense to me as in the first decade of Lady Gaga, but in all honesty, it feels like EarlyGa ended the moment GaGa turned into Gaga (so like, BTW i think?) 

From ARTPOP to House of Gucci, it was the Dark Ages, which marks Joker-Mayhem as the Renaissance 

@Ladle Ghoulash I gagged you with FACTS ?