Better Pop Star: Dua Lipa vs Charli XCX

[ANVEEROY 65,206]

Choose the better one!

[NUTELLA 26,155]

Dua has a better voice... but often makes boring songs

Charli has a more interesting approach to pop music... but often makes annoying songs

 

Gun to my head... Charli

[JohnPokerface 696]

1 minute ago, NUTELLA said:

Dua has a better voice... but often makes boring songs

Charli has a more interesting approach to pop music... but often makes annoying songs

 

Gun to my head... Charli

so you'd rather be annoying than boring? 

checks out 

[NUTELLA 26,155]

Just now, JohnPokerface said:

so you'd rather be annoying than boring? 

checks out 

I suppose I strive to be both  ✅✅

On a strictly song-for-song basis, Charli also has more NUTELLA-approved tracks:

DUA
Don't Start Now, If It Ain't Me, Pretty Please, Physical

CHARLI
Good Ones, Porsche, Claws, Anthems, 360, 1999, I Got It, Talk Talk

[Monstermilo 5,471]

dua has a better voice and makes better music 

i feel like brat was really overrated

[Starmie25 22,549]

Charli xyz 

[Blackout19 15,679]

[DESTROY UR DISEASE 19,544]

Dula La Peeps

[BeyonkaAte 932]

overal i enjoy miss Peep more than miss Xbox

[Ladle Ghoulash 52,154]

Charli’s music is more exciting/interesting by far. Charli and it’s not even close tbh

[Ladle Ghoulash 52,154]

25 minutes ago, Monstermilo said:

i feel like future nostalgia was really overrated

So, so, so true

[loveandpeace 1,706]

none of them for me 

[Monstermilo 5,471]

42 minutes ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

So, so, so true

numbers dont lie babe future nostagia has 15 billion streams and is the most streamed female album on spotify 

im not even a big dua stan but FN is bigger than brat and dua has a better voice 

dont start now and levitating dominated the charts from 2019-2021, brat barely had any hits, it was more about the cultural phenomena, not the music tbh 

duas levitating spent 70 weeks on the hot 100, the longest  charting song in hot 100 history for a woman

Edited yesterday at 04:39 PM by Monstermilo

[Ladle Ghoulash 52,154]

6 minutes ago, Monstermilo said:

numbers dont lie babe future nostagia has 15 billion streams and is the most streamed female album on spotify 

im not even a big dua stan but FN is bigger than brat and dua has a better voice 

dont start now and levitating dominated the charts from 2019-2021, brat barely had any hits, it was more about the cultural phenomena, not the music tbh 

duas levitating spent 70 weeks on the hot 100, the longest charting song in hot 100 history 

Why do you always act like commercial success is the be all end all? By that metric, Taylor Swift is the greatest artist to ever live and McDonald’s is the greatest restaurant on Earth we all know that ain’t true lmao. Idgaf how it performed commercially, I form my own opinions based on my own preferences and evaluation of more objective criteria andI think FN is a fairly middle of the road nu disco/synth pop revival record. Wasn’t even the best record in that vein to come out *that year* (which would be Jessie Ware’s What’s Your Pleasure, which is a far more emotionally dynamic and compositionally interesting record with far better vocals).

Dua’s voice is *fine*, but imo Charli has more expressive range as a vocalist, whereas Dua’s delivery is generally emotionally flat and vacant. Have never once felt anything listening to a Dula Peep track.

Edited yesterday at 04:45 PM by Ladle Ghoulash

[Monstermilo 5,471]

1 minute ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

Why do you always act like commercial success is the be all end all? By that metric, Taylor Swift is the greatest artist to ever live and we all know that ain’t true lmao. Idgaf how it performed commercially, I form my own opinions based on my own preferences and I think it’s a fairly middle of the road nu disco/synth pop revival record. Wasn’t even the best record in that vein to come out *that year* (which would be Jessie Ware’s What’s Your Pleasure, which is a far more emotionally dynamic and compositionally interesting record with far better vocals). Dua’s voice is *fine*, but imo Charli has more expressive range as a vocalist, whereas Dua’s delivery is generally emotionally flat and vacant. 

well then thats youre opinion and not everyone has the same opinion 

i personally feel like brat isnt a good album and charli cant really sing, FN was more consistent and dua has a more soulful, sultry voice thats more recongnizable 

if you dont wanna bring up objective stats then its just my subjective opinion versus yours