Scheiße vs. Heavy Metal Lover

[Head Empty 26,732]

Both are in my top 5 and both have been my #1 favourite Gaga song in recent times...

But seeing Scheiße at the Mayhem Ball was the most waist-slimming sh*t I'll ever have, so it's back at the top

Edited 7 hours ago by Head Empty

[Future Lovers 7,391]

HML easily 

[Ilia Malinin 2,704]

i don't speak german, and i can't even if you'd like so...

HML 

[JohnnyVersace 9,245]

Scheiße is pop perfection

it is arguably her best song imo

 

[Laxy 356]

I prefer HML but Scheiße is more iconic in every way. 

[HotLikeMexico 6,338]

I love both but there’s a reason Schieße is the one that keeps coming back time and time again. 
 

HML is good but I hope it remains a fan deep cut and away from the GP.

 

Some of yall might disagree but I loved HML because I immediately felt like Gaga was channeling Janet Jackson and at the time of the album release and all the discourse on inspos from Madonna, to Whitney to Bruce Springsteen, I was here for Janet even if it was in my own little coconut brain and wasn’t her intention. 

[JoeCool 837]

They are both great songs.

 

But I give the edge to Schiebe after discovering what that word means.  I mean I think the whole world is a Schiebe show 

[Ouranos 970]

I don’t speak German…. But I can if you like?