Best Movie Gaga was in?

[DESTROY UR DISEASE 17,489]

so for me it's gonna be:

1. The Devil Wears Prada 2

2. A Star Is Born

3. House Of Gucci

and I haven't seen the rest

[gagacabana 4,367]

1 minute ago, tainaga said:

pov you're in a competition to see who has the worst filmography, but your opponent is Lady Gaga.

Girl's been on terrible movies AND terrible tv shows only like... pick a struggle 

[gagacabana 4,367]

1 minute ago, DESTROY UR DISEASE said:

and I haven't seen the rest

JFAD? Omg gorl go for it! But maybe after watching Moulin Rouge because then the bar will be already so low it'll be hard to hit lower  

[princedeeblebleble 3,010]

Despite not watching it yet, I'm pretty sure DWP2 is gonna be my fave. Machete comes as second, other's were just bad, boring or not worth watching. She should do more AHS

[Ophelia 5,222]

Machete Kills - cool, love a b-movie stylized trash like this

Sin City: a Dame to Kill for - mid, part I was miles better

A Star is Born - cookie-cutter, predictable oscar bait. the music was the best part. cinematography was okay

House of Gucci - ehhhhhh ridley  it should be re-cut. boring af. i liked gaga's acting a lot, more than in asib.

Joker 2 - beautifully shot! music was okay, but could be better, wish Gaga got more screen time but i see what they were going for. this is the one i voted for.

The Devil Wears Prada 2 - haven't seen it yet!

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 30,611]

ASIB really is a great film

The second half is a bit messy but it’s still a great watch

[gagacabana 4,367]

I realized I came across as a huge hater but like, I have watched it all. 

And I'm a huge lover of stories, a huge fan of movies, and it's because I care so much about this, and about Lady Gaga, that I am so thoroughly disappointed 

[Ivy 13,564]

I only saw ASIB, HOG, and JFAD so far so definitely ASIB 

I still wish HOG was made to be a series instead 

JFAD I love but it's hard to watch since it's depressing

[jackweller 495]

It’s a tough one because her best acting is definitely in HOG but it’s definitely not a good film. If only they made up their minds on what story they wanted to tell. The film should’ve focused on her relationship with Mauricio and why she did what she did. Everything else-the uncle, cousin,sale of the company should’ve been cut. It could’ve been a campy cult classic but the bits that move away from Patrizia/Gaga are way too long for anyone to sit through.

ASIB doesn’t do it for me but I will always love it for the music and what it did to Gaga’s career

Not much to say about Joker because Gaga is barely in it.

[Ladle Ghoulash 43,172]

1 hour ago, gagacabana said:

Objectively, none. 

We can’t be acting like ASIB isn’t good 

[Ladle Ghoulash 43,172]

Honestly such a shame that they so thoroughly botched JFAD because it honestly had the potential to be her best film.

[Ladle Ghoulash 43,172]

24 minutes ago, Ivy said:

I only saw ASIB, HOG, and JFAD so far so definitely ASIB 

I still wish HOG was made to be a series instead 

JFAD I love but it's hard to watch since it's depressing

HOG series directed by Ryan Murphy as a season of American Crime Story would’ve honestly been really good. I have my issues with him, but I think HOG is the type of narrative he handles really well.

[TheFrenchGuy 4,341]

32 minutes ago, Ladle Ghoulash said:

HOG series directed by Ryan Murphy as a season of American Crime Story would’ve honestly been really good. I have my issues with him, but I think HOG is the type of narrative he handles really well.

Well he for sure would have kept the lesbian lovers subplot Gaga and Selma wanted 

Imagine how unhinged that show would be with Gaga AND Murphy going full camp

[warhol killah 8,861]

The only right answer is The Muppets Most Wanted

 

Edited 20 hours ago by warhol killah

[princedeeblebleble 3,010]

6 minutes ago, gagacabana said:

I realized I came across as a huge hater but like, I have watched it all. 

And I'm a huge lover of stories, a huge fan of movies, and it's because I care so much about this, and about Lady Gaga, that I am so thoroughly disappointed 

Honestly she did chose pretty meh movies.. Machete and Sin city are sort of fun but really kind of guilty pleasures if you're a fan of the originals, while the later three were such Oscar grabs, but in a reallly boring way.  AHS hotel was the only acting role that I genuinely enjoyed. It was Gaga on steroids, while others got me thinking why is Gaga in this random situation on screen