Wombat 554 Posted November 2, 2025 Share Posted November 2, 2025 As we all know, Gaga released Harlequin about 1 year ago, an album featuring one of her best ballads. Did it have a potential to become a hit? Was Happy Mistake truly, a mistake? perhaps not making it a single is actually a very sad mistake.. interesting… I've become a notorious being Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Creyk 18,958 Posted November 2, 2025 Share Posted November 2, 2025 I love seeing the trend I started. Feels like Gaga thoughts is alive again! About this one, yes, it definitely WAS a mistake. BOG should have been on harlequin. It would fit in better with the rest of Harlequin quality-wise. And if Happy Mistake was on Mayhem it would receive more attention, which it deserves. It also fits the theme of the album better than BOG. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lextyr97 20,861 Posted November 2, 2025 Share Posted November 2, 2025 I understand why it’s on Harlequin. Thematically and with its placement it really works, BUT god damn does it fit like a GLOVEEEE on Mayhem after The Beast. Seriously, if you haven’t heard it in that context, do yourself the favor. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
meltedplastic 915 Posted November 2, 2025 Share Posted November 2, 2025 it should have been on mayhem. but id omit a few songs off mayhem i dont like and totally change the tracklisting 1. Disease 2. Abracadabra 3. Garden Of Eden 4. Vanish Into You 5. Killah 6. The Dead Dance 7. Zombieboy 8. LoveDrug 9. Happy Mistake 10. Perfect Celebrity 11. The Beast 12. How Bad Do U Want Me 13. Die With A Smile this is how i listen to it LOL Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
gemein3 1,489 Posted November 2, 2025 Share Posted November 2, 2025 I think it’s one of the most gorgeous and haunting songs Gaga’s ever written. I don’t listen to it often because it makes me emotional lol Its biggest mistake was not being in Mayhem. Agreed with those above me ^ Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Creyk 18,958 Posted November 2, 2025 Share Posted November 2, 2025 14 minutes ago, meltedplastic said: 12. How Bad Do U Want Me 13. Die With A Smile Wait this is genius. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
meltedplastic 915 Posted November 2, 2025 Share Posted November 2, 2025 2 minutes ago, Creyk said: Wait this is genius. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
meltedplastic 915 Posted November 2, 2025 Share Posted November 2, 2025 i tend to think it was supposed to be on it "my head is full of broken mirrors" and then the whole mayhem aesthetic literally being broken mirrors. ugh dont . now im mad Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
jackweller 571 Posted November 2, 2025 Share Posted November 2, 2025 It should’ve been in the film and would easily get an Oscar nod Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
AVeryGagaHolyDick 32,748 Posted November 2, 2025 Share Posted November 2, 2025 Wasn’t it written for Chromatica? Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
bpmMonkey 7,996 Posted November 2, 2025 Share Posted November 2, 2025 HM doesn't fit the Mayhem theme at all. Sonically, sure, but other than that it would have no place on the record. I am very happy she found place for it on Harlequin tho and she even performed it live. It's a beautiful song and could have been tied in more with the movie. saving people, hunting things - the family business Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
ActualPatient 2,516 Posted November 2, 2025 Share Posted November 2, 2025 59 minutes ago, meltedplastic said: it should have been on mayhem. but id omit a few songs off mayhem i dont like and totally change the tracklisting 1. Disease 2. Abracadabra 3. Garden Of Eden 4. Vanish Into You 5. Killah 6. The Dead Dance 7. Zombieboy 8. LoveDrug 9. Happy Mistake 10. Perfect Celebrity 11. The Beast 12. How Bad Do U Want Me 13. Die With A Smile this is how i listen to it LOL without even reading the whole thing i already know you’d be ditching dont call tonight! as you should 💅 If symptom persists, consult your doctor. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
ActualPatient 2,516 Posted November 2, 2025 Share Posted November 2, 2025 Just now, bpmMonkey said: HM doesn't fit the Mayhem theme at all. Sonically, sure, but other than that it would have no place on the record. I am very happy she found place for it on Harlequin tho and she even performed it live. It's a beautiful song and could have been tied in more with the movie. wdym… there’s no other song i could think of that encapsulated the visuals and theme of MAYHEM other than Happy Mistake. she probably knows it could potentially carry Harlequin and sacrificed it. If symptom persists, consult your doctor. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Bronco 29,663 Posted November 2, 2025 Share Posted November 2, 2025 2 minutes ago, bpmMonkey said: HM doesn't fit the Mayhem theme at all. Sonically, sure, but other than that it would have no place on the record. I am very happy she found place for it on Harlequin tho and she even performed it live. It's a beautiful song and could have been tied in more with the movie. See I'm the opposite way around, I don't think it fits sonically but lyrically and thematically I think it fits. Lyrically it feels like a sister of Perfect Celebrity/The Beast/HBDUWM with the reflections on her fame and the disconnect between Gaga & Stefani. The gays know how to party Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
faysalaaa 5,388 Posted November 2, 2025 Share Posted November 2, 2025 Die With A Smile should have been the Joker album single. And Happy Mistake should have been on Mayham. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Featured Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.