Did Tim Burton fail to deliver?

[robotvoiceinalice 1,681]

i thought they did well together and the video is very well made

so far in the Mayhem era id rank the videos

1) Abracadabra 

2) The Dead Dance/ Die With A Smile

3) Disease 

 

[Gardevoir 9,877]

1 minute ago, robotvoiceinalice said:

am i the only one who liked the video?

No you’re not. It’s only gagadaily at its finest. 

[Lemon Blood 187]

Compared to Disease or Abracadabra the Dead Dance video is definitely the weakest. But that’s because Disease and Abracadabra are two of her best videos. I like the Dead Dance video, it’s camp and spooky, just what the song needed 

[Ashley 9,566]

2 hours ago, 27monster27 said:

He was only the director, not the writer or the producer. He put together the shots but did not do the story line.

This made me wonder, was Parris involved at all? Creative direction is definitely one of her strengths with Disease, Abra, and the Mayhem Ball. Not that it was all her and not Gaga coming up with the concepts, but they clearly work really well together.

[Lord Mayhem 1,056]

1 hour ago, nATAH said:

why would they lie tho? people tend to be proud that they've used AI + burton is anti-AI

Then explain the horrible warpy effects on those dolls cuz it's giving 99% AI use...

[darkgaga 5,522]

1 minute ago, Lord Mayhem said:

Then explain the horrible warpy effects on those dolls cuz it's giving 99% AI use...

Because it is still a doll that was standing still and not 3D animated, and not in front of a greenscreen. Which means even VFX artist have to warp the still image to make it move

[Zilla 13,424]

Honestly no, as a huge fan of his work if they didn’t announce Tim was the director I wouldn’t have known it was him. I get fitting the theme of the show etc but he could be wayyyy creepier. It wasn’t terrible, but kind of left me wanting more 

[Economy 50,083]

I actually lowley agree. I love the song but video is kinda meh. Cute to whatch, not her worst, but nothing all that special either.

[Monstermilo 4,667]

i feel like the whole wednesday thing: tdd, video and show appearance are underwhelming and couldve been kept in the drafts. 

[Cavadour 2,415]

1 hour ago, Zilla said:

if they didn’t announce Tim was the director I wouldn’t have known it was him

Did you watch Frankenweenie ?

[StrawberryBlond 14,900]

It was good for a video for a song that was an addition to an era. If it was on Mayhem originally, I'd expect maybe a bit more but considering this is a standalone single and we weren't even expecting it, I'll take it. I don't think such a song needed a storyline. The intro of her coming to life was good enough for me. Focusing on the song and dance will make more people focus on the song anyway. It's a choreo-filled Gaga video, which is something fans have been wanting for years, and it's the second video she's done like this in a row, what more do you want? I mean, DWAS just involves her playing a piano, at least she's actually moving about and dancing here. How many singers make music videos for songs from soundtracks these days? We should be grateful. And no one complained when HMH was almost all clips from the movie yet here, these is a pure Gaga video with no Wednesday cutaway scenes and is made like it's a lead single. So many artists aren't even making music videos anymore, so we're spoilt really. A Gaga song and video that's a hit? Let's celebrate that. 

[LadyxGaGa 2,204]

i genuinely don’t get the complaints the still from the mv looks like old horror movies like night of the living dead and bride of frankenstein and baby jane lmao but like its old horror reminiscent of old addams family idk what people were wanting 

[salty like sodium 1,922]

8 hours ago, palma said:

Yes. The video is ok (I mean it's a cvnty tiktok dance tutorial but it is what it is) but given the hype we had hearing the news that she went to the cursed-doll island in Mexico w/ Tim Burton for a video, the expectations were SKY HIGH. 

A bit more grit, more outfits would do the trick. The first 40 seconds of the video was quite good but had me worried that it'd keep going like that and then it did 

Not particularly blaming Gaga or the Haus but Tim Burton really just phoned it in.

My guess is he was just too expensive for the Haus but because they had committed and didn't want to admit it was too expensive they just cut down on sets and costumes as a result. Which is a shame because they definitely could have done a much better video with a better budget imo.

[Matt 469]

I've never really been a fan of Tim Burton, I feel he is a bit over rated. But yes, I expected something more. I expected more of a story/short film. I was hoping for more MAYHEM songs to be included too. 

[elijahfan 26,409]

8 hours ago, TheFrenchGuy said:

I'm a bit confused about Tim Burton and his recent projects. He seems barely involved in the actual creative work anymore. In the case of a music video where the styling and set design are handled by others, what exactly is his contribution? I get that people expect a certain visual signature from him, but here it feels like his role was limited to directing Gaga. So maybe it makes sense that we don’t see much of his touch in the final video. So... What's the point ? Did he even choose the setting and the concept? 

He draws for every project that he directs, which usually serves as a work basis for his collaborators. He’s always worked that way. Set and costume designers are someone else’s job, even for movies whose directors have a strong visual identity.

I think the video is quintessential Tim if you have actual knowledge of his work and not just a superficial and clichéd view of what he does. The black and white German expressionist inspiration, the doll character, the giallo-like colors, the stop motion animation… It’s literally all there.