17-track Born This Way vs 17-track MAYHEM

[meltedplastic 356]

Mayhem really is Born this Way’s older mother 

[Head Empty 25,245]

I feel dirty after doing this 

Born This Way is my preferred album yet I ended with 7 vs. 10

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease

2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra

3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden

4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity

5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High

6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You

7. Scheiße vs. Killah

8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy

9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance

10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug

11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me

12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight

13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love

14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man

15. The Queen vs. The Beast

16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass

17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

Edited 11 hours ago by Head Empty

[GAGASEXUAL 3,795]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

BTW: 11

MAYHEM: 6

[Santanasay 51]

As a selfish monster, I would've loved a deluxe with 21-23 tracks total. This era has been so much fun. I don't want it to end just yet. She and the team literally broke their backs from the music to the videos and the tour. Excellent! I also loved the build-up to “The Dead Dance”. The mystery behind the track made it more fun. Still, I'd be content with whatever she gives us. It's her vision after all. She definitely came through with MAYHEM. I'm very appreciative of all her hard work on this project. 

[Jolt 1,692]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

 

BTW - 7

MAYHEM - 10 (not surprised though)

[elegidadedios 2,169]

The way MAYHEM ties or surpasses BTW to most of us... This is really her best body of work I'll never get tired of saying it

Edit: apparently i'm blind because it's actually the opposite lmao bye

Edited 11 hours ago by elegidadedios

[A Fried Egg 8,978]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

 

BTW: 5

Mayhem: 12
 

Edited 10 hours ago by A Fried Egg

[RudraCNG 15,162]

Just now, elegidadedios said:

The way MAYHEM ties or surpasses BTW to most of us... This is really her best body of work I'll never get tired of saying it

In my case, I think it's really hard to be unbiased when BTW has been there for almost 15 years and MAYHEM not even 1, nostalgia is really a bitch. But yeah, time will probably prove MAYHEM it's her magnum opus.

[elegidadedios 2,169]

1 minute ago, RudraCNG said:

In my case, I think it's really hard to be unbiased when BTW has been there for almost 15 years and MAYHEM not even 1, nostalgia is really a bitch. But yeah, time will probably prove MAYHEM it's her magnum opus.

Agreed, I actually chose some BTW songs over MAYHEM ones like "damn how am I suppose to not choose this one because this and that etc" so yeah

[faysalaaa 4,700]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

[palma 7,926]

4 minutes ago, RudraCNG said:

In my case, I think it's really hard to be unbiased when BTW has been there for almost 15 years and MAYHEM not even 1, nostalgia is really a bitch. But yeah, time will probably prove MAYHEM it's her magnum opus.

BTW has some career highlights but then again so does MAYHEM... and MAYHEM's most filler'd songs are still good quality pop songs and not... Bad Kids 

When we move into our mid 30-s as a fanbase I think MAYHEM will be considered as her best album. 

[Sarah H 3,713]

16 minutes ago, elegidadedios said:

The way MAYHEM ties or surpasses BTW to most of us... This is really her best body of work I'll never get tired of saying it

Edit: apparently i'm blind because it's actually the opposite lmao bye

It looks pretty even at the moment. 

[elegidadedios 2,169]

5 minutes ago, palma said:

BTW has some career highlights but then again so does MAYHEM... and MAYHEM's most filler'd songs are still good quality pop songs and not... Bad Kids 

When we move into our mid 30-s as a fanbase I think MAYHEM will be considered as her best album. 

Is it bad that I'm 27 and I already consider it her best album

[elegidadedios 2,169]

7 minutes ago, faysalaaa said:

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

I respect you as a person

That's all I'm gonna say ❤️❤️❤️

[palma 7,926]

1 minute ago, elegidadedios said:

Is it bad that I'm 27 and I already consider it her best album

no because same