17-track Born This Way vs 17-track MAYHEM

[SidewalkUnicorn 114]

1.Marry the Night

2.Abracadabra 

3.Garden of Eden

4.Judas

5.Can’t Stop the High

6.Vanish Into You

7.Scheibe

8.Bloody Mary

9.Dead Dance

10.LoveDrug 

11.How Bad Do U Want Me

12.Highway Unicorn 

13.Kill for Love

14.Shadow of a Man

15.The Beast

16.You and I

17.The Edge of Glory

Mayhem wins 10-7

I think BTW has higher highs and lower lows while Mayhem is super consistent which is why I think some people still favor it despite Mayhem winning track for track for them. Plus, nostalgia is one hell of a drug.

[HermesG 1,703]

1. Marry the Night 👑 vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

OMG! I m sorry i did this! Lol! 

BTW= 11 #*my forever love

MAYHEM= 6 *i mean its ok

Funny thing is the not so favs from fans songs from MAYHEM only wins for me here. 

[LeoReplay 329]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance (too early to say maybe but I'm really feeling TDD)
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

BTW 11 x MAYHEM 6

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 26,787]

Abracadabra > Born This Way

the rest is all Born This Way > MAYHEM

[Plastic Flower 5,308]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

Born This Way 7

MAYHEM 10

[melon 3,620]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

BTW 5 

SLAYHEM 11

Tie = 1

[Taumaturg0 727]

5 hours ago, Controversiaga said:

No for real where is it ???????

All streaming platforms

[ElektrikUniCorn 529]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

 

Born This Way: 8

MAYHEM: 9

[Jack3257 786]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity (this one was the hardest!!)
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High (eh their both lowkey skips for me)
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance (this could change, need more time with TDD)
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man (again, not in love with either of these songs)
15. The Queen vs. The Beast (hot take: The Beast is one of the best songs on Mayhem)
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass (Blade of Grass is the one song preventing Mayhem from being 10/10 for me)
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile (tbh I love TEOG on piano but don't love the studio version)

BTW: 7

Mayhem: 10

[thedirtymonster 745]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug - IT'S A TIE FOR ME
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

BTW (10) and Mayhem (8) (There was one tie)

[Alxjcgn 812]

15 hours ago, palma said:

Now that we have 17 tracks for two of Gaga's best alberms I think it's only natural we celebrate with another poll

Choose the better track of the two based on their appearance on the track list 

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

My rihsults: BTW: 8 vs. MAYHEM: 9. Kinda shocking considering BTW is bible to me 

Discuss and stream The Dead Dance in the background 

Hair vs Vanish into You is a criminal decision to make ahaha theyre both so good

[TheMontebello 662]

1. Marry the Night

2. Born This Way

3. Government Hooker

4. Judas

5. Americano

6. Vanish Into You

7. Scheiße

8. Bloody Mary

9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion

10. LoveDrug

11. Fashion of His Love

12. Highway Unicorn

13. Heavy Metal Lover

14. Electric Chapel

15. The Beast

16. Yoü and I

17. The Edge of Glory

[LadyEnigma 1,300]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast 
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

 

BTW: 10

MAYHEM: 7

 

guys I didn't know we could have ties...I was over here making very hard decisions lmao

Edited September 4 by LadyEnigma

[REALITY 77,817]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

BTW: 8, MAYHEM: 9

[TEANUS 15,769]

1. Marry the Night vs. Disease
2. Born This Way vs. Abracadabra
3. Government Hooker vs. Garden of Eden
4. Judas vs. Perfect Celebrity
5. Americano vs. Can't Stop the High
6. Hair vs. Vanish Into You
7. Scheiße vs. Killah
8. Bloody Mary vs. Zombieboy
9. Black Jesus + Amen Fashion vs. The Dead Dance
10. Bad Kids vs. LoveDrug
11. Fashion of His Love vs. How Bad Do U Want Me
12. Highway Unicorn vs. Don't Call Tonight
13. Heavy Metal Lover vs. Kill for Love
14. Electric Chapel vs. Shadow of a Man
15. The Queen vs. The Beast
16. Yoü and I vs. Blade of Grass
17. The Edge of Glory vs. Die With a Smile

Born This Way - 11

MAYHEM - 6

Wow I really expected it to be closer. The deep cuts from BTW are just too good