Throwback when Gaga said ARTPOP sequel won’t be using old songs if she makes it

[monketsharona 86,613]

'When I make my records, there is a reason why some songs are left off. It's because some are simply not good enough for you. I'm not saying it's a never but I'm saying I'm not gonna take my demos that I specifically left off the record and put them on an album and put a number 2 on it. I'm not saying it's impossible, I'm just saying it's not gonna happen like that.'

https://x.com/gaga_latest/status/1950286434797310016?t=FYzWDwth3xtop07069c3sA&s=19

[dynamite 61,817]

1 minute ago, monketsharona said:

It's because some are simply not good enough for you.

We must have upset her the day she added Jewels n Drugs 

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 27,657]

1 minute ago, dynamite said:

We must have upset her the day she added Jewels n Drugs 

I love itttt

[NUTELLA 14,887]

Genuinely curious:

Is the ARTPOP Act II crowd hoping for more of that early-2010s EDM sound?

Or for modernized versions of those various (bad) AP demos?

What exactly do they want?

Edited July 29 by NUTELLA

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 27,657]

She basically says she could release ARTPOP Act II if she reworks the songs or makes new ones lol

That said, the Act II rumor based on the peace sign is funny af 

Also, “there is a reason why some songs are left off. It's because some are simply not good enough for you” is bullsh*t, as proved many, many, many times. 

Edited July 29 by AVeryGagaHolyDick

[monketsharona 86,613]

1 minute ago, NUTELLA said:

Genuinely curious:

Is the ARTPOP Act II crowd hoping for more of that early-2010s EDM sound?

Or for modernized versions of those various (bad) AP demos?

I would love a recent version of ARTPOP featuring new songs written with her current mind on ART and POP with how she feels creatively right now. With her current writting and producing. With new people involved.

Not necessarily a loud EDM record. Something that represents her now on how she feels about pop music.

[Ladle Ghoulash 31,287]

The title of this thread isn’t really accurate lol. She basically said she’s not gonna release a bunch of old *demos*, but that she would be open to potentially reworking older material. But again, because she’s so vague here, reworking is pretty broad: does she mean remastering them? Does she mean re-writing them? Does she mean re-recording them? It’s pretty hard to draw anything super conclusive from this because she’s being vague to keep her options somewhat open lol

[NotoriousEden 351]

Damn you opened your own thread about this cause you didn’t like the smackdown in the Swine one 

[Ladle Ghoulash 31,287]

9 minutes ago, NUTELLA said:

Genuinely curious:

Is the ARTPOP Act II crowd hoping for more of that early-2010s EDM sound?

Or for modernized versions of those various (bad) AP demos?

What exactly do they want?

I mean, I’m curious to hear the songs that she seemed to imply were ready/done that she raved about that haven’t been leaked/released (Tea, Tinnitus, Temple, Onion Girl etc). 

Edited July 29 by Ladle Ghoulash

[NotoriousEden 351]

7 minutes ago, NUTELLA said:

Genuinely curious:

Is the ARTPOP Act II crowd hoping for more of that early-2010s EDM sound?

Or for modernized versions of those various (bad) AP demos?

What exactly do they want?

Honestly Ive been waiting for this since 2013. Legit all I want is a small EP that includes TEA and Temple 

(I’d also kill for Onion Girl cause the name sounds like a psychedelic rave song to me but I don’t think it was even fully conceptualized)

[monketsharona 86,613]

5 minutes ago, NotoriousEden said:

Damn you opened your own thread about this cause you didn’t like the smackdown in the Swine one 

Smackdown of two people who haven't moved on since 2013 ? 

I just like breaking some hearts

[NotoriousEden 351]

21 minutes ago, monketsharona said:

'When I make my records, there is a reason why some songs are left off. It's because some are simply not good enough for you. I'm not saying it's a never but I'm saying I'm not gonna take my demos that I specifically left off the record and put them on an album and put a number 2 on it. I'm not saying it's impossible, I'm just saying it's not gonna happen like that.'

https://x.com/gaga_latest/status/1950286434797310016?t=FYzWDwth3xtop07069c3sA&s=19

This really isnt the smoking gun you’re lead to believe lmao. Her answer is so vague. It could legit just mean anything (as we stated multiple times in the Swine thread lol). Her rerecording the songs could legit mean it. I believe the literal intention of her words were that she won’t take unfinished 2012/13 demos and release them. They’ll be rerecorded or revamped

Edited July 29 by NotoriousEden

[Ladle Ghoulash 31,287]

[dynamite 61,817]

16 minutes ago, AVeryGagaHolyDick said:

I love itttt

Oh that's ok i don't judge 

[Quentin 6,502]

12 minutes ago, NotoriousEden said:

I’d also kill for Onion Girl

My mom works at Netflix and told me some lyrics of it: 

♫♪ I'm the Onion Girl, come come unwrap me, cut me in a swirl ♫♪

Edited July 29 by Quentin