What would a 15 song Lady Gaga Greatest Hits album tracklist look like?

[A Fried Egg 8,479]

5 hours ago, River said:

Yasss Free Woman and Scheiße made it!! 

[Ladle Ghoulash 22,067]

Limiting to 15 was tough and def think there’s potential for more hits from MAYHEM, but based on where things are rn:
 

I. BAD ROMANCE

II. ABRACADABRA

III. JUDAS

IV. POKER FACE 

V. ALEJANDRO

VI. JUST DANCE

VII. TELEPHONE 

VIII. BLOODY MARY  

IX. PAPARAZZI 

X. RAIN ON ME

XI. BORN THIS WAY 

XII. SHALLOW

XIII. ALWAYS REMEMBER US THIS WAY 

XIV. DIE WITH A SMILE

XV. THE EDGE OF GLORY 

Edited Sunday at 09:08 PM by Ladle Ghoulash

[Controversiaga 10,583]

7 hours ago, Stephen said:

Anybody skipping the hits from TF/TFM is insane 

I don’t think anybody did??? Did they???

[Controversiaga 10,583]

1. Just Dance

2. Poker Face

3. Paparazzi 

4. Bad Romance 

5. Telephone

6. Alejandro

7. Born this Way

8. Judas 

9. Applause

10. Million Reasons

11. Rain On Me 

12. Shallow

13. Always Remember Us This Way

14. Die with a Smile

15. Abracadabra 

[CubbyGaga 2,490]

1) Just Dance

2) Poker Face

3) Paparazzi

4) Bad Romance

5) Telephone 

6) Alejandro 

7) Born This Way

8) Judas

9) The Edge of Glory

10) Applause

11) Million Reasons

12) Shallow

13) Rain on Me

14) Die with a Smile

15) Abracadabra 

[StrawberryBlond 14,763]

Most of your lists are pretty sound but there's a big discrepancy regarding her international hits. Every artist has songs that were hits in certain parts of the world but flopped in others. Therefore, there have been international variations of greatest hits albums to include or omit certain songs. In the US, for example, Y&I and MR were hits but in the UK, only the fans cared about those songs and if they were on a greatest hits album, the public wouldn't recognise them which defeats the purpose. Disease and Abracadabra were also top ten songs here but didn't reach that high in America. That's why no 15 song tracklist will truly be applicable for everyone. But then the easiest way forward is to just work out what the overall total sum of each single's sales are and submit the top 15. But sales don't always correlate with impact. 

[Savage 1,782]

1. Just Dance

2. Poker Face

3. LoveGame

4. Paparazzi

5. Bad Romance

6. Telephone

7. Alejandro 

8. Born This Way

9. The Edge of Glory

10. Bloody Mary

11. Applause

12. Shallow

13. Rain On Me

14. Die With A Smile

15. Abracadabra 

[2School4Cool 6,431]

15 is hard to do because she has more than that!! Realistically it’d be something like this:

1. Just Dance
2. Poker Face
3. Paparazzi
4. LoveGame
5. Bad Romance
6. Telephone
7. Alejandro
8. Born This Way
9. The Edge of Glory
10. Applause
11. Shallow
12. Rain On Me
13. Bloody Mary
14. Die With a Smile
15. Abracadabra

Bonus Tracks
16. Marry The Night
17. Judas
18. Yoü and I
19. Perfect Illusion
20. Million Reasons
21. Always Remember Us This Way
22. Stupid Love
23. Disease
 

Edited Monday at 04:33 AM by 2School4Cool

[UnreleasedMadonna 2]

01 Just Dance w Colby O’

02 Poker Face

03 Paparazzi

04 Bad Romance

05 Telephone w Beyonce

06 Alejandro

07 Born This Way

08 Judas

09 The Edge of Glory

10 Applause

11 Million Reasons

12 Shallow

13 Rain On Me w Ariana Grande

14 Die With a Smile w Bruno Mars

15 Abracadabra

[Kevbev 402]

13 hours ago, Brainiac said:

1. Just Dance
2. Poker Face
3. Paparazzi
4. Bad Romance
5. Telephone
6. Alejandro
7. Born This Way
8. Judas
9. The Edge Of Glory
10. Applause
11. Million Reasons
12. Shallow
13. Rain On Me
14. Die With A Smile
15. Abracadabra

This is the only tracklist that makes sense

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 24,747]

Just Dance

Poker Face

Paparazzi

Bad Romance

Telephone

Alejandro

Born This Way

Judas

The Edge Of Glory

Bloody Mary

Applause

Shallow

Always Remember Us This Way

Die With A Smile

Abracadabra

 

[artdoll 46,015]

I came up with this off the top of my head. I think it has a nice flow 

1 Just Dance
2 Telephone
3 LoveGame
4 Poker Face
5 Bad Romance
6 Alejandro
7 Paparazzi
8 Bloody Mary
9 Abracadabra
10 Judas
11 Applause
12 Born This Way
13 Shallow
14 Die With A Smile
15 The Edge of Glory

Spoiler

Apologies in advance to Chromatica and Joanne 

 

[Killa 17,360]

1 just dance

2 Lovegame

3 paparazzi 

4 poke her face

5 Alejandro

6 bad bromance

7 telephone

8 - Born this way

9 Judas

 10 Always Remember US

11 shallow

12 due with a smile

13 abracadabra

14 Edge of glory

15 Bloody mary

And I oop i completely disregarded ARTPOP and Apple sauce plus Joanne

Maybe million reasons instead of abracadabra. Though the second seems to have more impact in the career. One Is part of superbowl the other gagacabana. Both impactful. Applause may had Better numbers but seems less important in a career retrospettive

14 - million reasons instead of Edge of glory

[Hadrian 546]

I love hypothetical lists like this because you could add a song like Heavy Metal Lover to this list because it's one of those fan favorites, Bloody Mary because it went viral a few years ago, and Angel Down because of it's cultural impact when it was released... and DOPE because of that weird glitch/technicality or whatever that gave it some virality.

Anyway, here's mine! It was pretty challenging to compile and I don't necessarily agree with it, but I think it's a pretty objective list of songs. I tried to keep it aligned with her big/viral/award-winning moments.

01. Just Dance
02. Poker Face
03. Bad Romance
04. Telephone
05. Bloody Mary
06. The Edge of Glory
07. Applause
08. Angel Down
09. Million Reasons
10. Joanne (Where Do You Think You're Goin'?) (Piano Version) (Gaga's Version) (10 Minute Version) (Taylor's Version) (From The Vault) (Lyric Video) [UNTAGGED] [320kbps]
11. Always Remember Us This Way
12. Shallow
13. Rain on Me
14. Die with a Smile
15. Abracadabra

Spoiler

Sorry, as soon as I put (Piano Version), I just couldn't help myself