Can anyone do Gaga but Gaga?

[MonSwiftAnton 3,734]

Just before this, I was dancing home from the grocery store, swirling and twirling to HBDUWM, and had a thought. Since that song is very Taylor-coded, I thought: while I love them both, Gaga can pull off Taylor, but not vice versa.

Then my next thought was: can anyone do Gaga but Gaga? I thought of all the pop girls and honestly don’t think anyone else could pull off Abracadabra, for example.

What do you think?

[RAMROD 108,173]

No. Many have tried. And failed. 
 

She is often imitated but never duplicated. And these people and their fans would never admit it that they do either. But the real ones knows, we can feel the vibe. And that's fine we ought to take it as flattery instead. 

[Bronco 9,725]

I think Michael does Gaga

[lastpopicon 27,136]

Nah, nevermind pop, Gaga is one of the best artists of all time , she runs circles around any other pop act, even the legends that I will not mention. 

[Zombiecat 16,307]

honestly.. I don't think so

[Allan 3,849]

I think enough time passed to say that she's for sure a once in a lifetime artist. She truly is every icon.

[DelusionalGaga 29,573]

Yes, Rita is outgagaing her in every way tbh

[Nite 5,367]

No, I think there are some artists like Gaga and MJ that are so unique in a way nobody else gets it right.

[Ashley 9,294]

I had this thought while listening to Judas the other day, I can’t picture anyone else singing that.

[River 114,494]

You can see the difference when other people are working with producers she worked with, no one could replicate Poker Face, BR, Judas, Scheiße with RedOne

And then you can see the difference between Cirkut's old work with other artists and then with Gaga, it's like a totally different producer, she basically challenged him to create new sounds  with her, she pushed him further.

 

[Lucas 26,091]

No one but Gaga could make songs like Bad Romance, Bloody Mary or Abracadabra work. She truly shines with dark over-the-top songs 

[bionic 48,779]

Rita can do Gaga but Gaga could never do Rita

[Anderson123 37,946]

28 minutes ago, Ashley said:

I had this thought while listening to Judas the other day, I can’t picture anyone else singing that.

This was my issue with Born This Way 10. Big Freedia did her own version of Judas and it was ok for what she was doing but not a song you can easily cover or do another version of. 

Orville snapped with BTW Country Road, Ben made a beautiful version of You and I, Olly made a fun electro version of The Edge of Glory, Kylie (and Adam Lambert) have done Marry The Night in their respective styles and that was also great to hear. 

11 minutes ago, River said:

You can see the difference when other people are working with producers she worked with, no one could replicate Poker Face, BR, Judas, Scheiße with RedOne

And then you can see the difference between Cirkut's old work with other artists and then with Gaga, it's like a totally different producer, she basically challenged him to create new sounds  with her, she pushed him further.

 

I love and respect RedOne so much, his chemistry with Gaga was like no other. He really tried to bring that sound to other artists then like JLo, Porcelain Black and Nicole Scherzinger but Gaga has that magic that pushed the songs to a whole new level. 
 

[nATAH 47,444]

who was it that made a thread saying ava max could do abracadabra?

[Obobo 3,019]

Nobody at the moment, she’s truly one of a kind. I’ve been on a hunt for a Gaga type artist to diversify my library and there just isn’t. Shes the perfect blend of talent and artistic vision that strongly brands her visuals and sound.