Better Song: Judas vs Disease

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 28,937]

Both are 10/10s, but Judas is better both lyrically and melodically 

[Borisapillar 9,966]

I voted for Judas because the single cover has texture

[ANVEEROY 63,389]

Disease 39! Wow!

[dynamite 64,895]

Judas by a biblical mile

[NickiMinajStan 6,894]

Judas and it's not even close 

[Yasux35 33]

Disease I’m not down with blasphemy 

[medicub 189]

Love disease but Judas

[Arcane 208]

In my heart, Judas to Disease: 

[bim 773]

They’re both amazing songs, but Disease is growing to be one of my favorite songs of all time. Considering I could write an entire thesis on Disease, she takes the crown for me.

[OMF 3,536]

Hard for me because I think Judas is catchier and camp even while Disease hits harder and has more of an industrial pop rock feel to it. 

[ANVEEROY 63,389]

19 hours ago, nATAH said:

 

19 hours ago, Blackout19 said:

Judas 100%

 

19 hours ago, lastpopicon said:

I fear this is impossible  I'll compromise:

Music Video- Judas

Song- Disease

 

18 hours ago, Toyga said:

Both 

 

18 hours ago, Mister Gaga said:

I’m afraid this is impossible

 

18 hours ago, Flippy said:

Not doing this  they’re both so good but each in their own way so, no

 

18 hours ago, PartySick said:

Judas really aged like milk for me. It needs the live instrumentalization to take it up a notch.

If it's "Judas (Enigma Version)" vs "Disease" then Judas wins

But if it's the album version of both songs, Disease wins easily

 

17 hours ago, River said:

Disease hits my culo so hard

 

16 hours ago, brizoda said:

Disease by a very low margin

 

16 hours ago, Killa said:

idk judas is amazing honestly. the instrumental in disease is really insteresting but there are some clunky moments which i dont understand if it's the mix or what. The outro is amazing, it's the chorus that's slighty weak. The vocals are wow. Judas has that hard cute pop extravaganza, super grand and dramatic. The song seems a bit too fast, there's something unsettling about the rythmic section, could have less instrumentation on the oooohooooh lm in love with judas in chorus. Prefer these lyrics and the topic is so much clear.

Maybe disease

 

16 hours ago, Gagaism said:

Girl got so many great songs that feels painful to pick a choice on these polls tbh 

 

16 hours ago, Killa said:

wait i just rewatched both videos, Disease hasn't hitted like this since first week. That song is amazing??!"!!

 

16 hours ago, Nathaniel Arven said:

as much as i love and loved judas, i will go for disease because J reminds me of my ex and of bad romance a bit to much and disease feels so fresh.

 

16 hours ago, Guille said:

Disease is a better song, production-wise and as a whole concept. It just feels more polished and neat.

Judas has a good production, but it feels messier in general, and the Bad Romance shadow is too big. Lyrically, though, it is incredibly perfect.

 

15 hours ago, Lucas said:

I love both but the entire Born This Way album is on another level 

 

15 hours ago, KennyRichie said:

I adore Disease but Judas was the song that made me a little monster, sorry there’s no real competition here 

 

15 hours ago, Haldy said:

Disease just can't be topped by any Gaga song for me (bar Perfect Celebrity), a career highlight.

 

13 hours ago, bionic said:

judas clears in every category

you know its true

 

12 hours ago, Bradley said:

I've said this before and I'm going to say it again

You have really interesting opinions 

  Reveal hidden contents

I'm just joking, all love 

 

 

12 hours ago, Murakami27 said:

Disease. 
 

I never loved Judas that much tbh. 

 

12 hours ago, SlaeUrAnus said:

Judas because it starts at 100% and ends at 100%. 

 

12 hours ago, chromaticainmyhead said:

I barely listen to Judas anymore

 

12 hours ago, NashvilleGAGA said:

Disease is Gaga perfection for me. Judas, I respect. Disease, I love

 

12 hours ago, Anderson123 said:

Disease 100%

She really did it with this song. It’s high up there with the big ones Bad Romance, Dance In The Dark, Scheiße, Marry The Night etc. 

 

11 hours ago, Controversiaga said:

Judas in 2025 feels tacky sometimes. Disease is really good 

 

6 hours ago, dubstep111 said:

I have a freakin Judas tattoo, but dang disease never gets old! Hits so hard♥️

 

6 hours ago, AVeryGagaHolyDick said:

Both are 10/10s, but Judas is better both lyrically and melodically 

 

5 hours ago, Borisapillar said:

I voted for Judas because the single cover has texture

 

58 minutes ago, dynamite said:

Judas by a biblical mile

 

58 minutes ago, OliviaRodrigoStan said:

Judas and it's not even close 

 

56 minutes ago, Yasux35 said:

Disease I’m not down with blasphemy 

 

49 minutes ago, medicub said:

Love disease but Judas

 

35 minutes ago, Arcane said:

In my heart, Judas to Disease: 

 

33 minutes ago, bim said:

They’re both amazing songs, but Disease is growing to be one of my favorite songs of all time. Considering I could write an entire thesis on Disease, she takes the crown for me.

 

6 minutes ago, OMF said:

Hard for me because I think Judas is catchier and camp even while Disease hits harder and has more of an industrial pop rock feel to it. 

Don't forget to vote! 

 

[LUST FOR GAGA 69]

disease is her best song idc

[Lord Axel 857]

Judas is amazing and its production is top-notch and was so different for RedOne at the time, even if it was Bad Romance 2.0, but the "Judas-Juda-ah" hook is pretty generic/forced and the chorus having "baby" twice (technically four times since it repeats) is a sin tbh - So I have to go with Disease, which I can honestly say is one of Gaga's best songs ever

[RickMonster98 7,472]

it's impossible

disease is probably a better song overall

but judas is iconic af

 

[pachinko 10,644]

Love both but didn’t like Disease music  video. 
 

Better song: Disease

Better video: Judas

Better overall: Judas

Edited March 23, 2025 by pachinko