culturalbaptism 2,759 Posted Friday at 11:36 PM Author Share Posted Friday at 11:36 PM 3 minutes ago, Kayi said: They were drunk to put Chromatica higher than ARTPOP but at least they aknowledge her recent works. I know right? ARTPOP is so much bolder and fun. Judas is coming, let the cultural baptism begin. 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Chesescake 3,857 Posted Friday at 11:44 PM Share Posted Friday at 11:44 PM JUST ANOTHER WAY TO to PROVE I LOVE YOU, WHEN IT'S HARD TODAY I'LL LAY BACK IN MY CHAIR AND FIND A WAY 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
floppyhatboy 87 Posted Friday at 11:48 PM Share Posted Friday at 11:48 PM Thank you, Andrew Unterberger, writer for Billboard, for your opinion. Next. Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
HelloHangoverz 16,925 Posted Friday at 11:48 PM Share Posted Friday at 11:48 PM IS NO ONE GOING TO HELP ME WITH THE POST OFFICE?! 1 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
bornthisway135 533 Posted Friday at 11:54 PM Share Posted Friday at 11:54 PM 3 hours ago, robotvoiceinalice said: “….Also why are they including ASIB?” Well Gaga wrote/produced/ or both on the majority of that soundtrack so it stands to be up with the other official releases. produced only/didn’t write: Black Eyes, La Vie En Rose, Maybe It’s Time, and Diggin’ My Grave. wrote/co-wrote/produced: Alibi, Shallow, Music To My Eyes, Always Remember Us This Way, Look What I Found, Heal Me, I Don’t Know What Love Is, Is That Alright?, Why Did You Do That?, Hair Body Face, Before I Cry, and I’ll Never Love Again. Those stats speak for themselves, imo. Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
HelloHangoverz 16,925 Posted yesterday at 12:00 AM Share Posted yesterday at 12:00 AM 3 minutes ago, bornthisway135 said: Well Gaga wrote/produced/ or both on the majority of that soundtrack so it stands to be up with the other official releases. produced only/didn’t write: Black Eyes, La Vie En Rose, Maybe It’s Time, and Diggin’ My Grave. wrote/co-wrote/produced: Alibi, Shallow, Music To My Eyes, Always Remember Us This Way, Look What I Found, Heal Me, I Don’t Know What Love Is, Is That Alright?, Why Did You Do That?, Hair Body Face, Before I Cry, and I’ll Never Love Again. Those stats speak for themselves, imo. The whole classification system about what does and doesn't constitute an album is starting to get real confusing since Harlequin. Sometimes these lists include her but exclude C2C, but ASIB is included which is itself a collab with Bradley? As a fanbase we should just do this: LG1: The Fame LG2: The Fame Monster LG3: Born This Way LG4: ARTPOP LG5: Cheek To Cheek LG6: Joanne LG7: A Star Is Born LG8: Chromatica LG9: Love For Sale LG10: Harlequin LG11: Mayhem IS NO ONE GOING TO HELP ME WITH THE POST OFFICE?! 1 2 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
27monster27 12,231 Posted yesterday at 12:05 AM Share Posted yesterday at 12:05 AM This is such a 2013 "tired of Lady Gaga" ranking. Stuck in the past it looks like. he/him/his 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
darkgaga 4,154 Posted yesterday at 12:21 AM Share Posted yesterday at 12:21 AM All of you acting like Chromatica is a piece of trash, probably because we have bad memories of it due to Covid, and praising Joanne, probably because we link it to the superbowl, when the only good tracks on that album are DH, PI and MR. It is by far her most boring album, and not something to revisit after all those years. Also I wont stand the ASIB slander here, that album has some of her best songs lyrically and melody wise. Only the Bradley songs and duets bring it down for me 1 2 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
pachinko 10,194 Posted yesterday at 12:28 AM Share Posted yesterday at 12:28 AM Why is Mayhem not higher? The Fame doesn’t deserve to be so high. Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
bornthisway135 533 Posted yesterday at 12:29 AM Share Posted yesterday at 12:29 AM 2 minutes ago, darkgaga said: All of you acting like Chromatica is a piece of trash, probably because we have bad memories of it due to Covid, and praising Joanne, probably because we link it to the superbowl, when the only good tracks on that album are DH, PI and MR. It is by far her most boring album, and not something to revisit after all those years. Also I wont stand the ASIB slander here, that album has some of her best songs lyrically and melody wise. Only the Bradley songs and duets bring it down for me I don’t think Chromatica is trash by any means. But the final production of the album and short track lengths disappointed me. Joanne was her first album where her true vocals really shined which is why I stack Joanne higher than Chromatica. I will admit the pandemic really threw a wrench in everything is could have been, but the music itself just fell short imo. Don’t get me wrong, I really like that album and what it stands for in terms of healing and whatnot. I just feel differently from every other piece of art she’s put out there. Love Chromatica, but one of them had to be last. 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
elegidadedios 1,070 Posted yesterday at 12:32 AM Share Posted yesterday at 12:32 AM 9 minutes ago, darkgaga said: All of you acting like Chromatica is a piece of trash, probably because we have bad memories of it due to Covid, and praising Joanne, probably because we link it to the superbowl, when the only good tracks on that album are DH, PI and MR. It is by far her most boring album, and not something to revisit after all those years. Also I wont stand the ASIB slander here, that album has some of her best songs lyrically and melody wise. Only the Bradley songs and duets bring it down for me I do enjoy the Bradley songs too it gets me to the straight mode I like to play sometimes Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
cachapatratorian 415 Posted yesterday at 12:36 AM Share Posted yesterday at 12:36 AM Pobre Juanita 1 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Noir 16,074 Posted yesterday at 12:46 AM Share Posted yesterday at 12:46 AM Joanne is great. Billboard take numbers and charts into consideration far too much. The Taylor Swift of the critics. 1 1 Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
robotvoiceinalice 1,352 Posted yesterday at 12:49 AM Share Posted yesterday at 12:49 AM 52 minutes ago, bornthisway135 said: Well Gaga wrote/produced/ or both on the majority of that soundtrack so it stands to be up with the other official releases. produced only/didn’t write: Black Eyes, La Vie En Rose, Maybe It’s Time, and Diggin’ My Grave. wrote/co-wrote/produced: Alibi, Shallow, Music To My Eyes, Always Remember Us This Way, Look What I Found, Heal Me, I Don’t Know What Love Is, Is That Alright?, Why Did You Do That?, Hair Body Face, Before I Cry, and I’ll Never Love Again. Those stats speak for themselves, imo. but its not a "Gaga" album tho since its a soundtrack album Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
robotvoiceinalice 1,352 Posted yesterday at 12:59 AM Share Posted yesterday at 12:59 AM 51 minutes ago, HelloHangoverz said: The whole classification system about what does and doesn't constitute an album is starting to get real confusing since Harlequin. Sometimes these lists include her but exclude C2C, but ASIB is included which is itself a collab with Bradley? As a fanbase we should just do this: LG1: The Fame LG2: The Fame Monster LG3: Born This Way LG4: ARTPOP LG5: Cheek To Cheek LG6: Joanne LG7: A Star Is Born LG8: Chromatica LG9: Love For Sale LG10: Harlequin LG11: Mayhem i mean honestly, in the countdown for this era (mayhem) she had the scratch card thing on her website which stated: LG1 - The Fame LG2 - The Fame Monster LG3 - Born This Way LG4 - ARTPOP LG5 - Joanne LG6 - Chromatica LG6.5 - Harlequin (idk why maybe she feels some personal attachment to it, or maybe it was supposed to signify the bridge between Chromatica and Mayhem sonically idk idk) LG7 - Mayhem any other album should not be counted as a "Gaga" album because this is straight from Gaga herself. it shouldn't be that complicated. and yeah ASIB is critically acclaimed and has Shallow which was a big hit, but the album is a soundtrack album and not one she includes on her album list. same goes for her Jazz albums (perhaps they hold a different place in Gaga's heart and thats why shes not counting them). Billboard should have paid attention to Gaga's count down to Mayhem on her website Quote Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Featured Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.