Which songs aged the best on Chromatica?

[Notthebling 1,894]

Curious to hear from all of you. What was your top 3 when the album came out and what is it today, right before Mayhem officially comes out.

Here is mine : 

2020 :

1. Alice

2. ROM

3. 911

 

2025 :

1. Alice

2. Replay

3. ROM

 

I think Alice hasn’t aged a DAY. It’s such a great song. Same goes with ROM. 
 

911 did fall lower in my ranking, same as Babylon and Stupid Love

 

Replay really grew on me, partly because of TCB performance. The choreo and energy level of the stadium… that was insane.

 

Honorable mention to Enigma, which didn’t stand out at first but is one of my favorite to this day.

Edited 6 hours ago by Notthebling

[PinkJelly 1,706]

I only really go back regularly to Replay, and even then it’s usually the Dorian Electra remix. Chromatica hasn’t had as lasting an impact on me as most of Gaga’s other pop releases. Probably my least listened to alongside Joanne.

[NUTELLA 5,120]

The only ones I ever revisit nowadays are Rain On Me, Replay, Enigma & Babylon (and only rarely).

Still dislike Alice, 911, Stupid Love, Sine From Above, Fun Tonight, Sour Candy & 1000 Doves.

Overall, I found Chromatica "meh" at the time, and I still do today.

 

Edited 6 hours ago by NUTELLA

[Davidsdaze 190]

Alice

ROM

1000 Doves (I hear this played at home goods all the time lol)

Replay

[RochestrMonstr 2,550]

911, Fun Tonight, and 1000 Doves are the ones that have lasted for me. 
 

I used to listen to Stupid Love, Plastic Doll, and Sine From Above much more than I do now. 

[monstertoronto 9,016]

All of them. If I listen to the record I still listen the whole thing in order. I still love it. 

[A Very Gaga Holida 22,349]

2020:

1- Stupid Love

2- Replay

3- Enigma

 

2025:

1- Replay

2- Enigma

3- Babylon

[Lord Axel 662]

My top three are Babylon/Sine from Above/Rain on Me, and that hasn't changed since the first listen

It's honestly crazy seeing people's tepidness for Chromatica on here recently - I honestly think it's her most cohesive album, with the best art direction, and as a whole I think it aged extremely well (maybe not Fun Tonight and Free Woman though, if I had to say something lol)

Edited 5 hours ago by Lord Axel

[ThisGuyTony 29,419]

I defended this album so hard but tbh Disease and Abra make Chromatica sounds generic, bland, lifeless. But I guess that’s the point - that’s how Gaga was feeling during this time period. 

2020:

1) Replay

2) Stupid Love

3) 911

2025: 

1) Fun Tonight

2) Replay 

3) Stupid Love

[2School4Cool 6,278]

2020
1. Fun Tonight
2. Sine From Above
3. 911

2025
1. 911
2. Replay
3. Stupid Love

[Anderson123 36,518]

2020
1. Babylon
2. Sine From Above
3. Rain On Me or 911

2025 (Since 2021 actually)
1. Sour Candy
2. Babylon
3. Alice

[lil1th 38]

Personally the album as a whole hasn't aged well, 911, rain on me, Alice, and a couple others are the ones I go back to, also I listen to the babylon remix on YT by Haus of afrodita... after several listens I just got tired of the album and bored.

It always felt generic to me, it's a good album, but I feel like the thing that saved chromatica for me were the lyrics and Gaga's voice, but it feels stale and lifeless instrumentally and something I'd rather leave in 2020.

[Reez 483]

2020:

1. Rain on me

2. Alice

3. Sour Candy

 

2025:

1. Sour Candy

2. Rain on me

3. Free woman