JFAD & Katy #2 and #1 on BBC News List of 2024 Flops

[SimonBaetens 9,384]

what’s the point of negative lists like these

[Lucas 30,665]

Just now, SimonBaetens said:

what’s the point of negative lists like these

clicks

[Anderson123 42,232]

2 hours ago, Red said:

How about we pretend 2024 didn’t happen 

Not when it's been one of the best Gaga years in a long time. Disease, Die With A Smile, Happy Mistake and all of Harlequin.

[Guest]

3 minutes ago, Anderson123 said:

Not when it's been one of the best Gaga years in a long time. Disease, Die With A Smile, Happy Mistake and all of Harlequin.

And sorry, you missed JFAD on that list 

[Anderson123 42,232]

46 minutes ago, AMRer said:

And sorry, you missed JFAD on that list 

I was meant to say good year in Gaga music but the movie itself wasn't that bad in my opinion. It had it's issues but it didn't deserve the hate it got.

[Mr S 8,790]

JFAD absolutely deserves a spot in this list. I'm just glad the writer was neutral. A fan of certain artists would totally make this about LG.

[elijahfan 27,423]

5 hours ago, thierryrreiht said:

Wait a minute

Sounds like some good old British vs French unhealthy competition... It is my understanding that the ceremony was overwhelmingly well-received and that the rain actually made it more epic. Stay mad, BBC.

[Monstermilo 5,441]

im just confused that with her acclaimed performance in ASIB she chose HOG and FAD as her next choices. if she had picked better roles - she would literally be one of the biggest actresses right now- shes got the chops she just isnt picking the right roles

[Economy 52,549]

Its one thing to poke humour at flops in a forum where a few dozen alike minded individuals see those comments but I always found bigger official mags commenting in such things to be rather condescending as they are trend setters and more "official" 

 

While ive certainly made Katy Perry jokes before, i wouldnt humaliate her publicly with a large magazine and a public flop list for hundreds of thousands to see

[juicyjuicy 2,004]

I think calling it a flop is incorrect. Doesn’t it have some of the highest home streams of any film released this year or something like that?

[juicyjuicy 2,004]

1 hour ago, Economy said:

Its one thing to poke humour at flops in a forum where a few dozen alike minded individuals see those comments but I always found bigger official mags commenting in such things to be rather condescending as they are trend setters and more "official" 

 

While ive certainly made Katy Perry jokes before, i wouldnt humaliate her publicly with a large magazine and a public flop list for hundreds of thousands to see

Thank you! I agree. Especially from a respected institution like the BBC. They should really know better.

[Economy 52,549]

12 hours ago, juicyjuicy said:

I think calling it a flop is incorrect. Doesn’t it have some of the highest home streams of any film released this year or something like that?

Well flop is kinda relative to budget and expectations

 

Given the budget that went into the movie and how well the 1st movie did, it was expected to do far better. If you take public reception into account that flop is even higher

 

So yeah, id say calling it a flop is an accurate assment

[MOT 3,572]

You know you're a megastar when your flops are labelled as the biggest flops.