Poll: Which unreleased song would be the biggest hit?

[Smother Em Eh 6,912]

I’d say NOBTR but if The Greatest Thing was reworked and actually sounded like it was featuring Cher instead of Gaga I think it would be a very close runner up! 

Edited 3 hours ago by Smother Em Eh

[Controversiaga 8,922]

Out of control

[The Ew from Judas 95]

Brooklyn nights is legit one of my favorite songs by her ever and the unreleased song I’d want to see the most, but I don’t know how well it’d do commercially due to it not being like-a big poppy dance song

then again shallow and DWAS are both massive hits so it’d probably be fine

[Anderson123 34,543]

Brooklyn Nights is beautiful and one of her best, can't believe we never got it officially but at least it leaked.

The Greatest Thing would've been massive between The Fame Monster and Born This Way or Born This Way and ARTPOP.

[Smother Em Eh 6,912]

6 minutes ago, Controversiaga said:

Out of control

Added

[A Very Gaga Holida 19,710]

Brooklyn Nights is the only final version we have I think? But I’d say Nothin On, if we’re talking about the 2008(?) version. The ARTPOP version is terrible

[SimonBaetens 5,851]

They would all sound dated if released today imo

[PartySick 141,692]

Princess Die for the controversy

I feel like (don't kill me) Brooklyn Nights is kinda overrated by this fanbase

[Hydrangea 4,670]

That weird adison chick has nobtr right? Why bother. Out of control was a real gem buried away 

youuuu seeeee IIIII 

 

[PartySick 141,692]

Just now, SimonBaetens said:

They would all sound dated if released today imo

Also this. Princess Die could easily be reworked into a ASIB styled song I think but the others not so much 

[HermesGr 874]

None of them is hit material.

I prefer Princes die tho..

[rvfzme 4,773]

Brooklyn Nights 

[SimonBaetens 5,851]

9 minutes ago, PartySick said:

Also this. Princess Die could easily be reworked into a ASIB styled song I think but the others not so much 

I mean, I love them as deep cuts/snippets but there's a reason why there were never released. I feel similarly about ARTPOP Act II, I understand that at some point you have moved on as an artist and want to look forward not back.

[GagaGame 2,408]

The Greatest Thing is pure commercial pop from the 2010's lmao 

[PartySick 141,692]

1 minute ago, SimonBaetens said:

I mean, I love them as deep cuts/snippets but there's a reason why there were never released. I feel similarly about ARTPOP Act II, I understand that at some point you have moved on as an artist and want to look forward not back.

Well, let's not get crazy. I still need Sire