#5 Lady Gaga: Billboard's The 25 Greatest Pop Stars of the 21st Century

[James Gibson 3,438]

#1 will obviously be Beyoncé or Taylor, tho I'm heading (or hoping) towards the former.

Hope Gaga can get a top 5 hopefully

[Mister G 9,945]

1 minute ago, James Gibson said:

#1 will obviously be Beyoncé or Taylor, tho I'm heading (or hoping) towards the former.

Hope Gaga can get a top 5 hopefully

I honestly can see her up there especially if they're basing it off her charting success. She's had 4 of her main albums debut #1 and a handful of singles that charted Top 10 on the Hot 100 including Judas (oh yes it may have dropped off the week after because of religious backlash but it counted LOL). Not to mention what is it 13 Grammy's and an Oscar. She is easily Top 5 material but it's gonna be a close one between her, Beyonce, Taylor, possibly Michael Jackson as well as Whitney Houston because I can't imagine they wouldn't be celebrated posthumously, and of course Madonna.

[James Gibson 3,438]

6 minutes ago, Mister G said:

I honestly can see her up there especially if they're basing it off her charting success. She's had 4 of her main albums debut #1 and a handful of singles that charted Top 10 on the Hot 100 including Judas (oh yes it may have dropped off the week after because of religious backlash but it counted LOL). Not to mention what is it 13 Grammy's and an Oscar. She is easily Top 5 material but it's gonna be a close one between her, Beyonce, Taylor, possibly Michael Jackson as well as Whitney Houston because I can't imagine they wouldn't be celebrated posthumously, and of course Madonna.

This is 21st century only so out of the 3 major legends you mentioned I believe only Madonna fits in as her work was continuosly impactful up to Confessions on a Dance Floor (and all her tours ever since). MJ and Whitney didn't have new work impacting much of this century really.

Out of remaining spots I believe Britney and Rihanna are obvious given but now I'm having a hard time predicting who would fit in next to them.

Edited October 8 by James Gibson

[juicyjuicy 1,624]

Hmmm, I’m going to guess these people will round out the Top 5 (in no particular order): Britney Spears, Michael Jackson, Madonna, Beyonce, Taylor Swift.
 

And I guess Rihanna and Gaga will be in the Top 10.

 

Gaga and Rihanna should be the top 2 imo.

[ssslyboy 3,273]

24 minutes ago, juicyjuicy said:

Hmmm, I’m going to guess these people will round out the Top 5 (in no particular order): Britney Spears, Michael Jackson, Madonna, Beyonce, Taylor Swift.
 

And I guess Rihanna and Gaga will be in the Top 10.

 

Gaga and Rihanna should be the top 2 imo.

I'm trying to figure out how Michael Jackson and Madonna could be even close to the top 5 on a 2000 - 2024 list.  Madonna could be there if they are including concert sales in their formula, but it looks like it's based mainly on chart performance and awards.  Madge had several #1 albums but her sales aren't collectively that strong, only one #1 single since 2000, and she hasn't won many awards.  And, Michael ...  

Edited October 8 by ssslyboy

[YASKALE 430]

36 minutes ago, Mister G said:

I honestly can see her up there especially if they're basing it off her charting success. She's had 4 of her main albums debut #1 and a handful of singles that charted Top 10 on the Hot 100 including Judas (oh yes it may have dropped off the week after because of religious backlash but it counted LOL). Not to mention what is it 13 Grammy's and an Oscar. She is easily Top 5 material but it's gonna be a close one between her, Beyonce, Taylor, possibly Michael Jackson as well as Whitney Houston because I can't imagine they wouldn't be celebrated posthumously, and of course Madonna.

When you say 4 of her main albums, do you mean 4 out of 5 or 4 out of 6 i.e. Fame/Fame Monster?

[Mister G 9,945]

6 minutes ago, YASKALE said:

When you say 4 of her main albums, do you mean 4 out of 5 or 4 out of 6 i.e. Fame/Fame Monster?

4 out of 6. Born This Way, ARTPOP, Joanne and Chromatica. I know a lot of outlets don't consider The Fame Monster as a standalone album. The Fame I think only peaked at 12 on the Hot 200 and TFM only peaked at #2. Still pretty impressive in the end because The Fame is still charting to this day. 

Edited October 8 by Mister G

[LateToCult 39,465]

59 minutes ago, SimonBaetens said:

 

Usher had a chokehold on millennials like no other. 

[LordByron28 857]

In no particular order it’s going to be Mariah Carey, Madonna, MJ, Whitney, Britney, Beyonce, Taylor, Rihanna, Gaga and Adele. 

[Anderson123 35,145]

40 minutes ago, Mister G said:

4 out of 6. Born This Way, ARTPOP, Joanne and Chromatica. I know a lot of outlets don't consider The Fame Monster as a standalone album. The Fame I think only peaked at 12 on the Hot 200 and TFM only peaked at #2. Still pretty impressive in the end because The Fame is still charting to this day. 

The Fame peaked at #2. 

[datlastfam 4,684]

Gaga will be no. 7 in honour of her releasing LG7 

My prediction will be

1. Taylor Swift

2. Beyonce

3. Drake

4. Justin Bieber

5. Rihanna

6. Britney Spears

7. Lady Gaga

8. Madonna

9. Ariana Grande

10. Adele

 

Not mentioned but I think deserved top 15 - Mariah, Black Eyed Peas, Kanye, wtf Billboard 

[James Gibson 3,438]

13 minutes ago, LordByron28 said:

In no particular order it’s going to be Mariah Carey, Madonna, MJ, Whitney, Britney, Beyonce, Taylor, Rihanna, Gaga and Adele. 

Still unsure of Whitney and Michael cause of the 2000-2024 metric.

Also I think Drake should be shoo in for how massive his Billboard success is (sadly). He also won Artist of the Decade with them for the 2010a. And they included Kendrick in the honorable mentions so they are open to hip hop acts.

[Mister G 9,945]

48 minutes ago, Anderson123 said:

The Fame peaked at #2. 

Oops I thought when I looked it up that it was the other way around my bad.

[nodandsmile 9,741]

they never put Gaga at the top of these lists! She's earn these publications' respect in recent years but they don't really suck up to her like they do some of her peers!

[StarstruckIllusion 49,000]

3 hours ago, James Gibson said:

#1 will obviously be Beyoncé or Taylor, tho I'm heading (or hoping) towards the former.

Hope Gaga can get a top 5 hopefully

@Teletubby Wrap this thread up the moment Gaga gets announced like we’ve already been tortured enough by being reminded of the existence of Usher and JT