What would the tracklist of a Lady Gaga Greatest Hits album be?

[HelloHangoverz 4,969]

I'm tryna come up with a Gaga Greatest Hits playlist and have been for a while now. I don't think Gaga would do a straight chronological tracklist of her singles but would try and come up with a sequence that has an artistry of its own.

So far I have:

1. The Edge Of Glory

2. Bad Romance

3. Born This Way

4. Hold My Hand

5. Shallow

6. Poker Face

7. Rain On Me

8. Telephone

9. Applause

10. Paparazzi

11. Alejandro

12. Judas

13. Just Dance

 

I've been tinkering with it but I can't get it just right. I definitely want to open with The Edge Of Glory, go into Bad Romance then Born This Way, cause I like the way it builds until we get to the two ballads: HMH & Shallow. But after that it kinda falls apart for me. Help!

 

 

[Anderson123 31,381]

I’d start with Marry The Night and have The Edge of Glory be the final track. Then Million Reasons, Lovegame, Stupid Love, You and I, Always Remember Us This Way and maybe GUY in there.  That’d be 20 tracks. 

[HelloHangoverz 4,969]

Just now, Anderson123 said:

I’d start with Marry The Night and have The Edge of Glory be the final track. Then Million Reasons, Lovegame, Stupid Love, You and I, Always Remember Us This Way and maybe GUY in there.  That’d be 20 tracks. 

I was considering MTN to start too! I might put it at the end - I need a signature closing song, and JD feels a bit flat - it's only there because I can't think of anything else

[asfittingasmcqueen 1,745]

1. Money Honey

2. Jewels N Drugs

3. Dope

4. Why Did You Do That

5. Love for Sale

6. Christmas Tree

 

Spoiler

jokes aside, probably all of her top 10s + Bloody Mary, Sour Candy, Hold my Hand and a couple of her signature jazz covers, such as Anything Goes and Bang Bang

 

[Noir 12,740]

1. Just Dance
2. Bad Romance
3. Poker Face
4. Born This Way
5. LoveGame
6. Rain On Me
7. Stupid Love
8. Paparazzi
9. Applause
10. Bloody Mary
11. Alejandro
12. Judas
13. Marry The Night
14. Million Reasons
15. You And I
16. Shallow
17. Always Remember Us This Way 
18. The Edge of Glory

[TheSine 5,254]

I'd randomize it with 20 songs  and leave 2 live covers at the end like bang bang and new york new york if possible.

1.Just Dance

2. Born This Way

3.StarStruck (just because)

4. Telephone

5. Paparazzi

6.Applause

7. Rain On Me

8. Joanne

9. Bad Romance

10. You And I

Etc.

[Inactive 698]

I think she should wait to release one, it seems like no one does anymore because you can stream everything online now, but if she did one day it would be cool to collect if it had new artwork and a couple new songs like Britney did with My Prerogative and Christina with Keeps Gettin Better. 

[PartySick 135,174]

If I made it, it'd be pretty comprehensive and show off her best songs in each avenue she pursued. Also, a couple of my favorites because it's already huge, might as well add them

01. Marry the Night
02. Rain on Me (ft. Ariana Grande)
03. Just Dance (ft. Colby O'Donis)
04. Poker Face 
05. Bad Romance
06. Judas
07. G.U.Y.
08. Stupid Love
09. LoveGame
10. Venus
11. Paparazzi
12. Sour Candy (ft. Blackpink)
13. Telephone (ft. Beyoncé)
14. Bloody Mary
15. Born This Way
16. Do I Love You
17. Dope
18. I'll Never Love Again
19. Always Remember Us This Way
20. Yoü & I
21. Million Reasons
22. Perfect Illusion
23. Shallow
24. Alejandro 
25. Enigma
26. Applause
27. Anything Goes (ft. Tony Bennett)
28. Cheek to Cheek (ft. Tony Bennett)
29. Love For Sale (ft. Tony Bennett)
30. Joanne (Piano Version)
31. The Edge of Glory
32. Lush Life

Edited November 20, 2023 by PartySick

[Starmie25 8,737]

It would be the NEXT ABBA GOLD 

19 bangers & "Million Reasons" 

[tyler k 3,045]

12 minutes ago, LilMissThang said:

I think she should wait to release one, it seems like no one does anymore because you can stream everything online now, but if she did one day it would be cool to collect if it had new artwork and a couple new songs like Britney did with My Prerogative and Christina with Keeps Gettin Better. 

The Weeknd did a Greatest Hits in 2021 and it did rather well...  it peaked at #2 on the BB200

[PartySick 135,174]

4 minutes ago, PartySick said:

If I made it, it'd be pretty comprehensive and show off her best songs in each avenue she pursued. Also, a couple of my favorites because it's already huge, might as well add them

01. Marry the Night
02. Rain on Me (ft. Ariana Grande)
03. Just Dance (ft. Colby O'Donis)
04. Poker Face 
05. Bad Romance
06. LoveGame
07. Paparazzi
08. Telephone (ft. Beyoncé)
09. Born This Way
10. Always Remember Us This Way
11. Million Reasons
12. Shallow
13. Alejandro
14. Applause
15. Joanne (Piano Version)
16. The Edge of Glory

Truthfully, it'd probably be more like this

[jackjackjackjack13 25]

1 hour ago, HelloHangoverz said:

So far I have:

1. The Edge Of Glory

2. Bad Romance

3. Born This Way

4. Hold My Hand

5. Shallow

6. Poker Face

7. Rain On Me

8. Telephone

9. Applause

10. Paparazzi

11. Alejandro

12. Judas

13. Just Dance

If you wanted to keep this amount of tracks and song selections, I'd swap Just Dance's place with Poker Face as it flows more nicely and gives more of a better finale but if you could add more I'd place Million Reasons in Shallow's position and put Shallow last or second to last and add Marry The Night as the last track

And maybe throw in DWUW or Venus or G.U.Y. somewhere in there too but that's just my two-cent 

[Anderson123 31,381]

23 minutes ago, PartySick said:

If I made it, it'd be pretty comprehensive and show off her best songs in each avenue she pursued. Also, a couple of my favorites because it's already huge, might as well add them

01. Marry the Night
02. Rain on Me (ft. Ariana Grande)
03. Just Dance (ft. Colby O'Donis)
04. Poker Face 
05. Bad Romance
06. Judas
07. G.U.Y.
08. Stupid Love
09. LoveGame
10. Venus
11. Paparazzi
12. Sour Candy (ft. Blackpink)
13. Telephone (ft. Beyoncé)
14. Bloody Mary
15. Born This Way
16. Do I Love You
17. Dope
18. I'll Never Love Again
19. Always Remember Us This Way
20. Yoü & I
21. Million Reasons
22. Perfect Illusion
23. Shallow
24. Alejandro 
25. Enigma
26. Applause
27. Anything Goes (ft. Tony Bennett)
28. Cheek to Cheek (ft. Tony Bennett)
29. Love For Sale (ft. Tony Bennett)
30. Joanne (Piano Version)
31. The Edge of Glory
32. Lush Life

Yasss Sour Candy!!

 

Maybe throw Do What U Want solo in there and we’re talking. 

Then Sire at the end as bonus track / new release cuz gotta promo something new. 

[HelloHangoverz 4,969]

Didn't get the notifs for all the replies! But guys I'm gonna try all of these tracklists cause honestly it's harder than it appears

[HelloHangoverz 4,969]

1 minute ago, Anderson123 said:

Yasss Sour Candy!!

 

Maybe throw Do What U Want solo in there and we’re talking. 

Then Sire at the end as bonus track / new release cuz gotta promo something new. 

Maybe Tea?