(Spoilers) Rank All Stars Seasons + Winners

[Bling 31,452]

21 minutes ago, Julien Mayer said:

Omg where's this from ?  I love her so much OMG

Oh I thought she was good in that season, she wasn't meant but the other girls was a little bit fragile like Stacy

I thought this one was a terrible experience for Yara and Alexis tho when I saw them on all stars ... 

I think it's from one of the later seasons when they bring back previous winners. I can't place it just yet...

Yeah idk I mean, now we know that the producers manipulate so much and create situations for the queens so it will make good TV. So the "mean queens" could really just be responding to producers questions and they thought they could trust them, so they are truly unfiltered. Anyways, I don't hold it against her. She's in tons of videos on YouTube and super nice.

The fact that Yara and Alexis are some of the best queens of the entire franchise, and the earlier seasons did them SO dirty. They got some justice in the newer All Stars tho

[Bling 31,452]

19 minutes ago, Kimmo said:

I’m not here to ply the game but ask why everyone is so in love with Alaska? 
 

When I watch her seasons she gave me the impression of a very arrogant person, her drag was very bad as well. 
 

In the other hand, Aquaria blew me away. The most creative drag I have ever seen, her talent is beyond  

Alaska was really unique at the time because no one was really doing what she did, or as good as she did. She came back in AS2 SUPER POLISHED and she could be fishy, fashion, funny, sexy, dance, singing, everything. A drag of all trades.

[TheOriginalOne 10,850]

Imho 

2>>>>>>>>>>>>>6>>>>>>>1>4>>>3>5
 

AllStars 2 is the best season of Drag Race. The drama, the stories, the queens, and the talent were all top tier. 

 

Oh as for AllStars winners

Alaska>Monét>Kylie>Shea>Chad>Trinity>Trixie

[Bling 31,452]

50 minutes ago, TheOriginalOne said:

Imho 

2>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>1>4>>>3>5
 

AllStars 2 is the best season of Drag Race. The drama, the stories, the queens, and the talent were all top tier. 

 

Oh as for AllStars winners

Alaska>Monét>Kylie>Shea>Chad>Trinity>Trixie

What about AS6 sis? The trans erasure 

[FFXSoul91 1,098]

Seasons:

AS2 > AS6 > AS4 > AS3 > AS5 > AS1

Winners:

Alaska > Shea > Kylie > Monét > Trixie > Trinity > Chad

[Bling 31,452]

1 hour ago, FFXSoul91 said:

Seasons:

AS2 > AS6 > AS4 > AS3 > AS5 > AS1

Winners:

Alaska > Shea > Kylie > Monét > Trixie > Trinity > Chad

We have almost the same rankings, just curious why you hate Chad so much 😅

[Enigma 7,182]

2 > 6 > 4 > 3 > 1 > 5

Alaska > Monét > Shea > Kylie > Chad > Trinity > Trixie

Disclaimer I haven't even watched AS1, but I know Chad did good on his season so I'm not putting him last. Also the cast was stellar and AS5 was utter ****. Thinking about it it's kinda crazy how after AS2, every winner is  debatable.

AS3: Ben and Shangela leaving

AS4: Manila chop/weird double crowning where Trinity technically performed better than Monét but absolutely flopped the finale, and the fact Monique was right there

AS5: Hot take but even if Shea is definitely one of the top 10 strongest Rugirls, her AS5 run was weak as **** considering they had a mediocre cast so she'd win without a doubt. Despite that, she couldn't even have the best TR? Her talent show was very underwhelming, and her looks were not as good as I would have expected from her. The only shoot she had that season was the nude runway.

AS6: I love love love Kylie and have been wanting her to win All Stars for so long, but she clearly didn't perform the best that season? She had one win and that was on a challenge where she struggled a ton and where her win was debatable. I honestly thought she could/should have won the ball and Snatch Game so maybe it evens out, but looking at the actual track record she got, it made no sense for her to win over Ra'jah or Ginger. 

And don't get me started about UK vs the world lol

[Bling 31,452]

30 minutes ago, Enigma said:

2 > 6 > 4 > 3 > 1 > 5

Alaska > Monét > Shea > Kylie > Chad > Trinity > Trixie

Disclaimer I haven't even watched AS1, but I know Chad did good on his season so I'm not putting him last. Also the cast was stellar and AS5 was utter ****. Thinking about it it's kinda crazy how after AS2, every winner is  debatable.

AS3: Ben and Shangela leaving

AS4: Manila chop/weird double crowning where Trinity technically performed better than Monét but absolutely flopped the finale, and the fact Monique was right there

AS5: Hot take but even if Shea is definitely one of the top 10 strongest Rugirls, her AS5 run was weak as **** considering they had a mediocre cast so she'd win without a doubt. Despite that, she couldn't even have the best TR? Her talent show was very underwhelming, and her looks were not as good as I would have expected from her. The only shoot she had that season was the nude runway.

AS6: I love love love Kylie and have been wanting her to win All Stars for so long, but she clearly didn't perform the best that season? She had one win and that was on a challenge where she struggled a ton and where her win was debatable. I honestly thought she could/should have won the ball and Snatch Game so maybe it evens out, but looking at the actual track record she got, it made no sense for her to win over Ra'jah or Ginger. 

And don't get me started about UK vs the world lol

Ok sis in WHAT WORLD does Monet X Change place higher than Kylie,like whut?

I forgive you tho for confessing your love for Kylie bc she really is one of my new favs 

She has everything.

I agree that AS5 was a "different" crop of girls, but it made me appreciate Cracker, Blair, Mayhem, and Mariah more

[Enigma 7,182]

2 minutes ago, WheresMy911Alice said:

Ok sis in WHAT WORLD does Monet X Change place higher than Kylie,like whut?

I forgive you tho for confessing your love for Kylie bc she really is one of my new favs 

She has everything.

I agree that AS5 was a "different" crop of girls, but it made me appreciate Cracker, Blair, Mayhem, and Mariah more

I love Kylie!!! And she's one of my favs for sure. I just don't think she won her season, idk? It really came out of nowhere considering the judging/her TR/her looks etc. 

The look you posted is a ****ing slay, her best look ever tbh. But on other runways I thought she sometimes was overshadowed. For instance I thought her look for the alter ego challenge at the end of the season was extremely basic. Or like, the fact she would wear actual designer (ie: her crowning and Lady Gaga looks) that she borrowed... she looked amazing but it was less impressive than Ra'Jah making everything herself or queens who at least had the idea for the look.

It's kinda like Shea, I love them and wanted them to win 100% but it's a bit disappointing that they were overshadowed by other girls. Kinda tarnishes their win imo

AS5 was... not it for me lol. It was so short and just... whatever. Ongina and Mayhem giving up ruined a good chunk of the season. Mariah was underappreciated so there was really no point bringing her back, they treated her as filler. India isn't likeable and her biggest appeal was her beef with Derrick... who they booted first. I can't stand Cracker so having her be the front runner wasn't great. And Blair is so deadly boring to me, the fact she made it that far wasn't it. I only loved Shea, Juju and Alexis. But overall that season was too short, the queens didn't have time to each get their moment. Really hated it haha

[Bling 31,452]

5 minutes ago, Enigma said:

I love Kylie!!! And she's one of my favs for sure. I just don't think she won her season, idk? It really came out of nowhere considering the judging/her TR/her looks etc. 

The look you posted is a ****ing slay, her best look ever tbh. But on other runways I thought she sometimes was overshadowed. For instance I thought her look for the alter ego challenge at the end of the season was extremely basic. Or like, the fact she would wear actual designer (ie: her crowning and Lady Gaga looks) that she borrowed... she looked amazing but it was less impressive than Ra'Jah making everything herself or queens who at least had the idea for the look.

It's kinda like Shea, I love them and wanted them to win 100% but it's a bit disappointing that they were overshadowed by other girls. Kinda tarnishes their win imo

AS5 was... not it for me lol. It was so short and just... whatever. Ongina and Mayhem giving up ruined a good chunk of the season. Mariah was underappreciated so there was really no point bringing her back, they treated her as filler. India isn't likeable and her biggest appeal was her beef with Derrick... who they booted first. I can't stand Cracker so having her be the front runner wasn't great. And Blair is so deadly boring to me, the fact she made it that far wasn't it. I only loved Shea, Juju and Alexis. But overall that season was too short, the queens didn't have time to each get their moment. Really hated it haha

Sissssssssss

JK we can agree to disagree. Idk I just love everything she is about and has TONS of stage presence and the IT factor.

And sorry to break it to you but since like season 10 I think, maybe even before, the queens have been bringing stuff they bought versus having to make it from scratch like the earlier seasons. So I get your reasoning, but majority of the queens these days buy stuff and bring it versus make it unless it's a ball challenge or specific design challenge. Kinda disappointing but makes OG queens stand out more who sew everything like Alexis, Utica, Gigi, etc.

Yeah Blair and Cracker aren't my faves wither but idk, I really like seeing what queens will do with another chance and I love when they are so much more polished. Like Jiggly and Scarlet, etc.

 

[Enigma 7,182]

3 minutes ago, WheresMy911Alice said:

Sissssssssss

JK we can agree to disagree. Idk I just love everything she is about and has TONS of stage presence and the IT factor.

And sorry to break it to you but since like season 10 I think, maybe even before, the queens have been bringing stuff they bought versus having to make it from scratch like the earlier seasons. So I get your reasoning, but majority of the queens these days buy stuff and bring it versus make it unless it's a ball challenge or specific design challenge. Kinda disappointing but makes OG queens stand out more who sew everything like Alexis, Utica, Gigi, etc.

Yeah Blair and Cracker aren't my faves wither but idk, I really like seeing what queens will do with another chance and I love when they are so much more polished. Like Jiggly and Scarlet, etc.

 

She really does! And so does Shea, but like... it's a competition. There'd be no point in All Stars even being a thing if they just crowned the queen with the most IT factor out of the gate. They also got to perform the best on the actual show. 

Gigi doesn't sew anything lol it's all her mom (part of why I don't live for her)

Cracker legit had a downgrade from season 10, did you see her tighs? They were YELLOW 

And yeah I know the queens work with designers now, but at least they have input on the concept and it's custom made for them. Most of what Kylie brought was just borrowed, it already existed. She's kinda the only queen to have worn only pre-existing designer stuff on almost every runway. 

[Bling 31,452]

48 minutes ago, Enigma said:

She really does! And so does Shea, but like... it's a competition. There'd be no point in All Stars even being a thing if they just crowned the queen with the most IT factor out of the gate. They also got to perform the best on the actual show. 

Gigi doesn't sew anything lol it's all her mom (part of why I don't live for her)

Cracker legit had a downgrade from season 10, did you see her tighs? They were YELLOW 

And yeah I know the queens work with designers now, but at least they have input on the concept and it's custom made for them. Most of what Kylie brought was just borrowed, it already existed. She's kinda the only queen to have worn only pre-existing designer stuff on almost every runway. 

We will agree to disagree 

Tbh it's just fun chatting with others about Drag Race without someone getting catty AF. It's such a cultural phenomenon but damn, gheys be getting ANGRY in the Drag Race threads. I'm like sis, it's just a show.

I'm so curious what the next All Stars will be. There's rumored All Winners cast and also "first out" or like queens who got eliminated super early. I live for the Lip Sync Assassin rules tho.

[FFXSoul91 1,098]

15 hours ago, WheresMy911Alice said:

We have almost the same rankings, just curious why you hate Chad so much 😅

I really don’t! I think Chad is great. I just don’t find her as exciting as the other winners, I guess. I debated switching her and Trinity.

[Noir 17,446]

Ranking of Seasons: 

1. AS2
2. AS3
3. AS5
4. AS6
5. AS4
6. AS1

Ranking of Winners:

1. Shea Coulee
2. Alaska
3. Kylie Sonique Love
4. Chad Michaels 
5. Trinity Tuck
6. Trixie Mattel
7. Monet X Change 

[TheOriginalOne 10,850]

17 hours ago, WheresMy911Alice said:

What about AS6 sis? The trans erasure 

I- 

How did I forget about the second best AS season?