Ranking Chromatica Tracks Nearly 2 Years Later

[Dr Fudge 8,340]

Definitely a weird change:

before:

1. Babylon
2. Replay
3. Alice
4. Fun Tonight
5. 911
6. Rain on Me
7. Stupid Love
8. Enigma
9. Sine From Above
10. Plastic Doll
11. Free Woman
12. Sour Candy
13. 1000 Doves

 

now:

1. 911
2. Alice
3. Babylon
4. Rain on Me
5. Stupid Love
6. Replay
7. Enigma
8. Fun Tonight
9. Sine From Above
10. Plastic Doll
11. Sour Candy
12. 1000 Doves
13. Free Woman

Mostly a shift in top 6 and bottom 7, but weird that Fun Tonight and Replay used to be such top favorites and now they’re fine, but don’t do it for me the way they used to. 

 

Visuals make all the difference and 911 served, hard.

 

[Jack3257 482]

1) 911

2) Rain on Me

3) Babylon

4) 1000 Doves

5) Sine From Above

6) Fun Tonight 

7) Alice 

8) Replay

9) Free Woman

10) Stupid Love

11) Enigma

12) Sour Candy

13) Plastic Doll

[Mirrion Rizzons 9,947]

1. 911

2. Replay

3. Sour Candy

4. Fun Tonight

5. Rain On Me

6. Stupid Love

7. Babylon

8. Alice

9. Enigma

10. Plastic Doll

11. 1000 Doves

12. Free Woman

13. Sine From Above

[Sherry 4,064]

58 minutes ago, PlastiscGuy said:

Meh tier:

#12 Enigma 

[PlastiscGuy 19,845]

4 minutes ago, Sherry said:

[Sherry 4,064]

1. Rain On Me

2. Chromatica II/ 911

3. Babylon

4. Chromatica I/ Alice

5. Enigma

6. Chromatica III/ Sine from Above

7. Replay

8. Sour Candy

9. Free Woman

10. Stupid Love

11. 1000 Doves

12. Plastic Doll

13. Fun Tonight

[KindnessPunk 1,465]

1. Free Woman 

2. Plastic Doll

3. Stupid Love

4. Alice 

5. 911

6. Babylon 

7. Replay

8. Sour Candy 

9. 1000 Doves

10. Rain on Me

11. Enigma

12. Sign From Above

13.  Fun Tonight 

[Tonymel 99]

1. 911

2. Rain on Me

3. Alice

4. Free Woman

5. Fun Tonight

6. 1000 Doves

7. Plastic Doll

8. Babylon

9. Stupid Love

10. Sine From Above

11. Sour Candy

12. Replay

13. Enigma

[Roronoa 6,324]

All this Free Woman love 

Free Woman

Rain On Me

Alice

Sour Candy

Fun Tonight

Plastic Doll

Enigma

Babylon

Replay

911

1000 doves

Sine From Above

Stupid Love

 

 

[Sir 1,385]

1. Free Woman

2. Replay

3. Plastic Doll

4. Alice

5. Enigma

6. Babylon

7. Rain on Me

8. 1000 Doves

9. Rain on Me

10. 911

11. Sour Candy

12. Love Me Right

13. Stupid Love

14. Sine from Above

[Guest]

I remember everyone creamed over Shite from above when it came out now its at the bottom of the list for many! Justice!!!!!!!

[Enigma 7,182]

1. Replay

2. Sour Candy

3. Babylon

4. 911

5. Alice

6. Sine from above (that one live tho… y’all are not ready)

(VERY hard to rank up until that point. These songs are elite and have not aged at all. They honestly could be in any order)

7. Enigma (That one one will skyrocket once I hear it live. It was MEANT to be performed in a stadium. It doesn’t sound as good as an album track but I can tell the live version will be my #1)

8. Rain on me

9. Stupid Love

(Songs I don’t care for)

10. 1000 Doves

11. Plastic Doll

12. Free Woman

13. Fun Tonight

[ItsCaseyPaul 1,310]

I never understood (and still dont) the hate for Enigma.

It is one of her best songs in her entire discography in my opinion. Though, maybe my taste is questionable. 

1. Enigma

2. 911

3. Replay

4. Sine From Above

5. Free Woman

6. Alice

7. Fun Tonight

8. Rain on Me

9. Babylon

10. 1000 Doves

11. Sour Candy

12. Stupid Love

13. Plastic Doll

[Starmie25 8,593]

7 minutes ago, Enigma said:

. Enigma (That one one will skyrocket once I hear it live. It was MEANT to be performed in a stadium. It doesn’t sound as good as an album track but I can tell the live version will be my #1)

This! It's such an anthemic song. So much going on! I swear most of these will go off live. Maybe you can talk with Gaga's team about a live album for Chromatica. 

[Starmie25 8,593]

So much "Plastic Doll" hate agh. 

It's a melancholy bop. Thank you Sktills.