The single that got away? Heavy Metal Lover or Bloody Mary

[Aphasic 4,033]

Those two songs to me seem like huge misses. 

[Bio 23,538]

Tbh at the time I don’t see any of them smashing. Maybe Scheisse? 

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 25,797]

Imo Bloody Mary is better but HML would be a better pick for a single 

[yes and 4,884]

None of them would be quite successful. They are fan-favourites for sure, but they are not GP-friendly at all 

[LittleMonster20 9,858]

I could see Heavy Metal Lover doing well, imagine a video of it with the same vibe as the 2011 VMA teaser!

[Pennywise 36,079]

I'm offended that you would make me choose between two of the top 5 songs from Gaga's discography 

[Aphasic 4,033]

2 minutes ago, Sour Candy said:

None of them would be quite successful. They are fan-favourites for sure, but they are not GP-friendly at all 

Electro Dance wasn't GP friendly and Gaga made it happened. She could have if she wanted to. Judas is great but wasn't a huge success with the GP. 

[Aphasic 4,033]

4 minutes ago, Pennywise said:

I'm offended that you would make me choose between two of the top 5 songs from Gaga's discography 

I know but if you had to choose one for a single. Which one would it be?

[Pennywise 36,079]

Just now, Aphasic said:

I know but if you had to choose one for a single. Which one would it be?

Bloody Mary because she's honestly THAT birch 

[Magic Mike 2,739]

i’d chose HML but it’d confuse people so much  would love to see it though. 

[Cookie Tookie 10,546]

Scheiße as a single >>>

[Aphasic 4,033]

Just now, Cookie Tookie said:

Scheiße as a single >>>

That is also great (all songs in Born This Way are exquisite)

[Sir 1,545]

HML was sent to radio but it was scrapped 

[imitalian 3,163]

Being realistic, after MTN underperformed with all that promo, no other song from the album would have smashed.

I could see Scheiße doing good in summer 2011 tho.

[Aphasic 4,033]

15 minutes ago, iamamiwhoami said:

HML was sent to radio but it was scrapped 

I didn't know that. Wow