Anveeroy 57,876 Posted May 30, 2021 Author Share Posted May 30, 2021 10. 1000 Doves (Piano Demo) - 7.70 Highest Score: 10 Lowest Score: 1 COMMENTS: Spoiler LittleMonster20 Beautiful version of the song although I do prefer the dance version. Still a great song. Monstruous I love this rendition, it’s breathtaking, but it doesn’t make since on Chromatica so it’s a good thing it’s just a bonus Aphroditus Much better than the official one but would like better Suspiria Personally don't like piano ballads. But a nice addition on the deluxe version for those that do. Trixie "Mother****ing" Mattel I'm afraid that even amongst Gaga's ballads, this is still a bit of a meh track. Babylon Dynasty unnexpected deluxe track, I would asolutely LOVE a B side of traumatica with all the songs in piano named Monochromatica BUT I sould stop being delulu and finish this rate. Oreo Should've been on the album instead of the bloodpop oonts oonts version. Teus flying like a 1000, flying like 2000, flying like 10 000 do-oves' stunningly beautiful. Pennywise This should have been in the regular version instead of the regular 1000 Doves, because it is a very good ballad. whoresup Better than the normal version because it suits the more emotive delivery but still not overly special. Poltergeist 1 more point because I like it more than the album version Stephen Beautiful and heartbreaking. Love the alternate lyrics. Butters Stotch Love this as a ballad, and I'm glad we have this version, because it sounds better this way, though I get why they chose the electronic version for the album, because it's was meant to have no ballads. martiniglistens Honestly does not do much for me I will say it... Judas Society So I prefer this version definitely, since it's church-y. Spyro Great demo but I have a love for the final sound. FRANK1991 I can't choose between the original and the piano coz they are both very good so same score. cav07 Such a haunting ballad. Really ironic considering how light and happy the chorus sounds on the final version. This song is incredible. ReplayBoss The piano version is much better and probably the only reason why the previous version has a dance beat is to fit with the album's theme. ProfessionalClown Not a fan of it as a piano version ngl Candy GagaOriginal is better czarnyptak I love 1000 Doves and I actually gave it 10, but the piano demo is as good or even better Blown Away This song is still painfully basic. The structure needs to be rethought entirely, because this could be a great piano ballad. Lionel Ronaldo I really like this version better than the album version however, both a very nice. BloodyMary08 1000 times better than the original. Should've replaced the original. Kadikaado Sounds much better than the album dance version holy scheisse Never heard it, so neutral rating HausOfAntonio The increasing number of doves is a bit cringey to me ngl. Dance version blows this out of the water. Huttont Much better as a piano ballad. Dadru This song works better as a ballad, still love the original tho. dimitristhe Better than the album version, still not a good song though. grigioboi Absolutely freakin beautiful. My poor heart when I first heard the piano demo . I LOVE the dance version but if she sings it live one day, it has to be this version. It is hands down one of Gaga’s best ballads PERIOD. TopazBlue Ended up in last place but so beautiful ♥ PARTICIPANTS: Spoiler @ARTPOPe @LittleMonster20 @bionic @Monstruous @Cello @Aphroditus @Sneaky @lilboyblue @CubbyGaga @nightadieu @pdrgst @Suspiria @Reputation King @Quenty @Sofianer @Agunimon @androiduser @Trixie Mattel @vpez @Babylon Dynasty @Rahrahbitchson @Oreo @littlepotter @GagaSine @Thomatica @NicoB @venuspop @Teus @Pennywise @Secret @Rj Barker @franminervini @EvilBunny @ICE911 @gagaxsebert @whoresup @Poltergeist @ARTGOD @Gabi001 @Tony @My Name Is Alice @Stephen @BeyerJ @Butters Stotch @JakubM316 @martiniglistens @ManMan @Judas Society @iamjune @Matt @DutchHooker @Spyro @Born This Way @Helloo @MaryJaneHolland @Why am I on GGD @Mars @Watershed @GaGaLB @FRANK1991 @Reez @barbietingz @slayo @cav07 @StarryNight @ReplayBoss @BELLYACHE @ProfessionalClown @Yakul @Yxilon @v3sp @S4lander @MANiCURE 6 @Waad @Yabogachka @k00ns @enissa11 @H3Y @uanapereira @Candy Gaga @Magnetic Moon @auburn @King J @StrawberryBlond @czarnyptak @Wood @Fernster7 @tigerteeth @Blown Away @LoLaA @Spock @N8L @highwithenemy @MoonIight @oaklatinx @MonsterPawPR @r4m @Gagaism @Cersei Lannister @ANTI WP @Smother Em Eh @musicland @Nao tem @HIMe @The Clown @Sherry @alsemanche @Clarity @Double J @Biagio2103 @UnnamedArtist @BloodyMary08 @Animal Claws @woowaguy @McSine @S0436 @Ivy @Glamourpuss @Kadikaado @chromatic puzea @holy scheisse @Anderson123 @flyaway @Guille @Lucas @777777777777777777 @Stanley Digaga @pdrgst @HausOfAntonio @Yennefer Stark @italianmonster92 @huttont @Sherry @GaGaAst @good @Massive Monster @GagaIsMyCure @Ronk @Dadru @Hey Boy @ororo munroe @p1uto @Chromatican @dimitristhe @Touranese @SamanthaC @grigioboi @TopazBlue @Tinnitus15 Stream Kylie-Janet Discographies! Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
holy scheisse 21,698 Posted May 30, 2021 Share Posted May 30, 2021 6 minutes ago, ARTPOPe said: Top 3 probably going to be 1 Replay 2 911 3 Alice Rain on me is gon be there mama Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
LittleMonster20 9,788 Posted May 30, 2021 Share Posted May 30, 2021 Deserves higher it’s so beautiful. But I think it’s fine. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
LoLaA 2,284 Posted May 30, 2021 Share Posted May 30, 2021 1 minute ago, Kantakyakirno said: 10. 1000 Doves (Piano Demo) - 7.70 Highest Score: 10 Lowest Score: 1 COMMENTS: Reveal hidden contents LittleMonster20 Beautiful version of the song although I do prefer the dance version. Still a great song. Monstruous I love this rendition, it’s breathtaking, but it doesn’t make since on Chromatica so it’s a good thing it’s just a bonus Aphroditus Much better than the official one but would like better Suspiria Personally don't like piano ballads. But a nice addition on the deluxe version for those that do. Trixie "Mother****ing" Mattel I'm afraid that even amongst Gaga's ballads, this is still a bit of a meh track. Babylon Dynasty unnexpected deluxe track, I would asolutely LOVE a B side of traumatica with all the songs in piano named Monochromatica BUT I sould stop being delulu and finish this rate. Oreo Should've been on the album instead of the bloodpop oonts oonts version. Teus flying like a 1000, flying like 2000, flying like 10 000 do-oves' stunningly beautiful. Pennywise This should have been in the regular version instead of the regular 1000 Doves, because it is a very good ballad. whoresup Better than the normal version because it suits the more emotive delivery but still not overly special. Poltergeist 1 more point because I like it more than the album version Stephen Beautiful and heartbreaking. Love the alternate lyrics. Butters Stotch Love this as a ballad, and I'm glad we have this version, because it sounds better this way, though I get why they chose the electronic version for the album, because it's was meant to have no ballads. martiniglistens Honestly does not do much for me I will say it... Judas Society So I prefer this version definitely, since it's church-y. Spyro Great demo but I have a love for the final sound. FRANK1991 I can't choose between the original and the piano coz they are both very good so same score. cav07 Such a haunting ballad. Really ironic considering how light and happy the chorus sounds on the final version. This song is incredible. ReplayBoss The piano version is much better and probably the only reason why the previous version has a dance beat is to fit with the album's theme. ProfessionalClown Not a fan of it as a piano version ngl Candy GagaOriginal is better czarnyptak I love 1000 Doves and I actually gave it 10, but the piano demo is as good or even better Blown Away This song is still painfully basic. The structure needs to be rethought entirely, because this could be a great piano ballad. Lionel Ronaldo I really like this version better than the album version however, both a very nice. BloodyMary08 1000 times better than the original. Should've replaced the original. Kadikaado Sounds much better than the album dance version holy scheisse Never heard it, so neutral rating HausOfAntonio The increasing number of doves is a bit cringey to me ngl. Dance version blows this out of the water. Huttont Much better as a piano ballad. Dadru This song works better as a ballad, still love the original tho. dimitristhe Better than the album version, still not a good song though. grigioboi Absolutely freakin beautiful. My poor heart when I first heard the piano demo . I LOVE the dance version but if she sings it live one day, it has to be this version. It is hands down one of Gaga’s best ballads PERIOD. TopazBlue Ended up in last place but so beautiful ♥ PARTICIPANTS: Reveal hidden contents @ARTPOPe @LittleMonster20 @bionic @Monstruous @Cello @Aphroditus @Sneaky @lilboyblue @CubbyGaga @nightadieu @pdrgst @Suspiria @Reputation King @Quenty @Sofianer @Agunimon @androiduser @Trixie Mattel @vpez @Babylon Dynasty @Rahrahbitchson @Oreo @littlepotter @GagaSine @Thomatica @NicoB @venuspop @Teus @Pennywise @Secret @Rj Barker @franminervini @EvilBunny @ICE911 @gagaxsebert @whoresup @Poltergeist @ARTGOD @Gabi001 @Tony @My Name Is Alice @Stephen @BeyerJ @Butters Stotch @JakubM316 @martiniglistens @ManMan @Judas Society @iamjune @Matt @DutchHooker @Spyro @Born This Way @Helloo @MaryJaneHolland @Why am I on GGD @Mars @Watershed @GaGaLB @FRANK1991 @Reez @barbietingz @slayo @cav07 @StarryNight @ReplayBoss @BELLYACHE @ProfessionalClown @Yakul @Yxilon @v3sp @S4lander @MANiCURE 6 @Waad @Yabogachka @k00ns @enissa11 @H3Y @uanapereira @Candy Gaga @Magnetic Moon @auburn @King J @StrawberryBlond @czarnyptak @Wood @Fernster7 @tigerteeth @Blown Away @LoLaA @Spock @N8L @highwithenemy @MoonIight @oaklatinx @MonsterPawPR @r4m @Gagaism @Cersei Lannister @ANTI WP @Smother Em Eh @musicland @Nao tem @HIMe @The Clown @Sherry @alsemanche @Clarity @Double J @Biagio2103 @UnnamedArtist @BloodyMary08 @Animal Claws @woowaguy @McSine @S0436 @Ivy @Glamourpuss @Kadikaado @chromatic puzea @holy scheisse @Anderson123 @flyaway @Guille @Lucas @777777777777777777 @Stanley Digaga @pdrgst @HausOfAntonio @Yennefer Stark @italianmonster92 @huttont @Sherry @GaGaAst @good @Massive Monster @GagaIsMyCure @Ronk @Dadru @Hey Boy @ororo munroe @p1uto @Chromatican @dimitristhe @Touranese @SamanthaC @grigioboi @TopazBlue @Tinnitus15 I like this version better than the other one so yea, above 1000 doves, this is a nice ranking Always be kind to others, you may need them once Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ronk 14,499 Posted May 30, 2021 Share Posted May 30, 2021 1 minute ago, Kantakyakirno said: 10. 1000 Doves (Piano Demo) - 7.70 Highest Score: 10 Lowest Score: 1 COMMENTS: Reveal hidden contents LittleMonster20 Beautiful version of the song although I do prefer the dance version. Still a great song. Monstruous I love this rendition, it’s breathtaking, but it doesn’t make since on Chromatica so it’s a good thing it’s just a bonus Aphroditus Much better than the official one but would like better Suspiria Personally don't like piano ballads. But a nice addition on the deluxe version for those that do. Trixie "Mother****ing" Mattel I'm afraid that even amongst Gaga's ballads, this is still a bit of a meh track. Babylon Dynasty unnexpected deluxe track, I would asolutely LOVE a B side of traumatica with all the songs in piano named Monochromatica BUT I sould stop being delulu and finish this rate. Oreo Should've been on the album instead of the bloodpop oonts oonts version. Teus flying like a 1000, flying like 2000, flying like 10 000 do-oves' stunningly beautiful. Pennywise This should have been in the regular version instead of the regular 1000 Doves, because it is a very good ballad. whoresup Better than the normal version because it suits the more emotive delivery but still not overly special. Poltergeist 1 more point because I like it more than the album version Stephen Beautiful and heartbreaking. Love the alternate lyrics. Butters Stotch Love this as a ballad, and I'm glad we have this version, because it sounds better this way, though I get why they chose the electronic version for the album, because it's was meant to have no ballads. martiniglistens Honestly does not do much for me I will say it... Judas Society So I prefer this version definitely, since it's church-y. Spyro Great demo but I have a love for the final sound. FRANK1991 I can't choose between the original and the piano coz they are both very good so same score. cav07 Such a haunting ballad. Really ironic considering how light and happy the chorus sounds on the final version. This song is incredible. ReplayBoss The piano version is much better and probably the only reason why the previous version has a dance beat is to fit with the album's theme. ProfessionalClown Not a fan of it as a piano version ngl Candy GagaOriginal is better czarnyptak I love 1000 Doves and I actually gave it 10, but the piano demo is as good or even better Blown Away This song is still painfully basic. The structure needs to be rethought entirely, because this could be a great piano ballad. Lionel Ronaldo I really like this version better than the album version however, both a very nice. BloodyMary08 1000 times better than the original. Should've replaced the original. Kadikaado Sounds much better than the album dance version holy scheisse Never heard it, so neutral rating HausOfAntonio The increasing number of doves is a bit cringey to me ngl. Dance version blows this out of the water. Huttont Much better as a piano ballad. Dadru This song works better as a ballad, still love the original tho. dimitristhe Better than the album version, still not a good song though. grigioboi Absolutely freakin beautiful. My poor heart when I first heard the piano demo . I LOVE the dance version but if she sings it live one day, it has to be this version. It is hands down one of Gaga’s best ballads PERIOD. TopazBlue Ended up in last place but so beautiful ♥ PARTICIPANTS: Reveal hidden contents @ARTPOPe @LittleMonster20 @bionic @Monstruous @Cello @Aphroditus @Sneaky @lilboyblue @CubbyGaga @nightadieu @pdrgst @Suspiria @Reputation King @Quenty @Sofianer @Agunimon @androiduser @Trixie Mattel @vpez @Babylon Dynasty @Rahrahbitchson @Oreo @littlepotter @GagaSine @Thomatica @NicoB @venuspop @Teus @Pennywise @Secret @Rj Barker @franminervini @EvilBunny @ICE911 @gagaxsebert @whoresup @Poltergeist @ARTGOD @Gabi001 @Tony @My Name Is Alice @Stephen @BeyerJ @Butters Stotch @JakubM316 @martiniglistens @ManMan @Judas Society @iamjune @Matt @DutchHooker @Spyro @Born This Way @Helloo @MaryJaneHolland @Why am I on GGD @Mars @Watershed @GaGaLB @FRANK1991 @Reez @barbietingz @slayo @cav07 @StarryNight @ReplayBoss @BELLYACHE @ProfessionalClown @Yakul @Yxilon @v3sp @S4lander @MANiCURE 6 @Waad @Yabogachka @k00ns @enissa11 @H3Y @uanapereira @Candy Gaga @Magnetic Moon @auburn @King J @StrawberryBlond @czarnyptak @Wood @Fernster7 @tigerteeth @Blown Away @LoLaA @Spock @N8L @highwithenemy @MoonIight @oaklatinx @MonsterPawPR @r4m @Gagaism @Cersei Lannister @ANTI WP @Smother Em Eh @musicland @Nao tem @HIMe @The Clown @Sherry @alsemanche @Clarity @Double J @Biagio2103 @UnnamedArtist @BloodyMary08 @Animal Claws @woowaguy @McSine @S0436 @Ivy @Glamourpuss @Kadikaado @chromatic puzea @holy scheisse @Anderson123 @flyaway @Guille @Lucas @777777777777777777 @Stanley Digaga @pdrgst @HausOfAntonio @Yennefer Stark @italianmonster92 @huttont @Sherry @GaGaAst @good @Massive Monster @GagaIsMyCure @Ronk @Dadru @Hey Boy @ororo munroe @p1uto @Chromatican @dimitristhe @Touranese @SamanthaC @grigioboi @TopazBlue @Tinnitus15 The piano demo is beautiful, tho. I live outside the space time continuum. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
ARTPOPe 10,023 Posted May 30, 2021 Share Posted May 30, 2021 1 minute ago, Ivy said: You forgot Rain On Me, it's very popular You're probably right, I somehow forgot its existence despite having listened to it earlier today Stream The Love Invention Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Yxilon 5,248 Posted May 30, 2021 Share Posted May 30, 2021 How about next one is 911? Everything could be everything (it could mean anything) Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
LoLaA 2,284 Posted May 30, 2021 Share Posted May 30, 2021 Just now, Yxilon said: How about next one is 911? How about NO and say it is time to say goodbye to SFA Always be kind to others, you may need them once Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Yxilon 5,248 Posted May 30, 2021 Share Posted May 30, 2021 At this point it must be Stupid Love tho Everything could be everything (it could mean anything) Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
LittleMonster20 9,788 Posted May 30, 2021 Share Posted May 30, 2021 Stupid Love or Sour Candy. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Hyperobject 66,768 Posted May 30, 2021 Share Posted May 30, 2021 SFA in top 10 be like Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Summerboi14 807 Posted May 30, 2021 Share Posted May 30, 2021 Wait 11 was 1000 Doves and 10 too? Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Ronk 14,499 Posted May 30, 2021 Share Posted May 30, 2021 1 minute ago, Yxilon said: How about next one is 911? NO. Periodt. I live outside the space time continuum. Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
DontCallMeAlice 1,560 Posted May 30, 2021 Share Posted May 30, 2021 Sorry I came late! What’s the listing so far? Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Anveeroy 57,876 Posted May 30, 2021 Author Share Posted May 30, 2021 . Stream Kylie-Janet Discographies! Link to post Share on other sites More sharing options...
Featured Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.