Jump to content
question

Delete one album from Gaga's discography


Aglaya

Featured Posts

ThatGagaBoobStan

Just Dance(the remixes)-EP:ohwell:

“I’ve got rain stored in the boobs”-Boobga 2020🤡
Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 148
  • Created
  • Last Reply
VOLANTIS
12 hours ago, Rio said:

ARTPOP allowed her to experiment with her sound, even if she believed in it and the media didn't it. It allowed her to fall and rebuild her artistry in a way that developed her into the legend she has become since. 

ARTPOP always has a place in her discography. Far less generic and experimental than her debut, for example. It was always original music, not covers like C2C. Each of her albums are so different, I welcome diversity 😉

We're celebrating ARTPOP for.. failing?? :bear:

And respectfully I have to disagree. The Fame sounds generic now but at the time the recycled redone tracks were not the mainstream pop sound. ARTPOP however feels like a playlist of memories from her previous works. Songs like manicure could easily have been on The Fame (a sound we both agree felt dated in 2012 so thank you). It doesn't help that Aura, Donatella and Mary Jane Holland have been LITERALLY recycled (legally ofc ofc). Which in my mind is not above a cover album. The album is her least original body of work when reviewing the dated sounds, recycled tracks and overall aimless direction. 

Personally I don't hate the album. How could I, my fave made it. But it is my least favorite Lady Gaga album. 

Again. It's good to love. But the reasons people dislike the album are obvious and understandable as well. 

I'll lift you 3 inches off the ground and drag you to a meter and a half
Link to post
Share on other sites

AURAOFSHEISSE

I hate to say it but,,,,,Miss ARTPOP. I'ts my second favorite in her discography but it did the least for her personally. Every other album furthured her reputation,fame,mental health,finances,influence,critical acclaim.

“Hands on your knees, I’m Angelina Jolie”
Link to post
Share on other sites

hijadeputa

I’d choose Joanne to go, the only songs that I would really miss are Million Performances, John Wayne and Perfect Illusion. Maybe DIC as well. But comparing to her other albums, imo, it’s the album with less bops. Sorry Joanne :heart:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Schizophonic

if it was about what i could do without musically: c2c

but i have to get rid of the entire era i propably have to say chromatica because the lack of an era. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

some of you guys need to chill. the topic is to delete an album from her discography. one's gotta go in people's replies, sorry you don't like their choice. :koons:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Born This Way. Bloated, over promoted, quite frankly just generally the weakest as a whole album. Plus the intensity of the album cycle an tour lead to direct problems when ARTPOP came around. If Born This Way didn't happen the way it did than maybe BTWB wouldn't have happened the way it did. Maybe Gaga wouldn't have fibro that causes her such tremendous pain that affects her daily life, touring and even sometimes her general ambition to do pop. That era put such a tremendous weight on her and literally took one of the biggest physical tolls.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Uh Joanne was cute but it'd be nonsense to erase the stuff she's actually known for :shrug:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...