Why do people keep saying that whistle note was from Ariana?

[YourEvilTwin 1,379]

4:16 Isn't that quite obviously from Gaga, especially since Ariana was singing her verse as the exact same time? How could it possibly be Ariana unless since she possess another vocal cord somewhere?

 

 

[Memento 881]

lol the "raaaain ooon meeeeee" in the back is obviously gaga i don't know why some people are having a hard time figuring this out

[paradox 4,568]

It was Ariana... and it wasn't live. Most of the vocals were prerecordered 

[macca 1,318]

Gurl. It’s Ariana. 

[OMF 3,442]

Not that was definitely NOT Gaga. It’s not as if it’s something many singers can do, Mariah was the last big name I know of, and Ariana as of more recent

[alsemanche 93,421]

It's literally Ariana and it sounds like Ariana tf

[Ryusei 61,036]

Have you ever heard Gaga whistle?

[paradox 4,568]

This thread can be closedT now 

[REALITY 76,234]

6 minutes ago, paradox said:

It was Ariana... and it wasn't live. Most of the vocals were prerecordered 

It was live. The takes were different, but I'm sure both Gaga and Ari were singing live for each take. 

[Twitter 14]

8 minutes ago, Memento said:

lol the "raaaain ooon meeeeee" in the back is obviously gaga i don't know why some people are having a hard time figuring this out

I reached my reaction limit so here’s what I think of this comment.

[paradox 4,568]

1 minute ago, M Monstre said:

It was live. The takes were different, but I'm sure both Gaga and Ari were singing live for each take. 

[hELXIG 42,954]

It's 100% Ariana, Gaga sung the other part, but she sure did sound like Ariana singing "rain onn meeee". When she starts that part you can tell it's Gaga

[REALITY 76,234]

3 minutes ago, paradox said:

Let's be real here.

911, for example, didn't sound the greatest live. Do you think if they had a chance to pre-record the vocals, they wouldn't have done a better job?  

Whether or not she sang it live for that PARTICULAR take doesn't matter. She still sang the songs live. You can very evidently hear her breathe and stop. I don't know what your point is  

[JusKeepBreathin 19,311]

It's raining on your thread gurl. 

Gaga hitting whistle notes. 

[TSUNAMI 20,935]

I need to wash my ears today and give it another go.