Jump to content
question

TF vs. BTW vs. ARTPOP vs. Joanne vs. Chromatica


Biggest Bitch

Featured Posts

HorusRa2

Just Dance/Marry The Night/Aura/Diamond Heart/Alice

Love Game/Born This Way/Venus/A-YO/Stupid Love

Paparazzi/Government Hooker/G.U.Y/Joanne/Rain On Me

Poker Face/Judas/Sexxx Dreams/John Wayne/Free Woman

Eh,Eh/Americano/Jewels N’ Drugs/Dancin’ In Circles/Fun Tonight

Beautiful, Dirty, Rich/Hair/MANiCURE/Perfect Illusion/911

The Fame/Scheisse/Do What U Want/Million Reasons/Plastic Doll

Money Honey/Bloody Mary/ARTPOP/Sinner’s Prayer/Sour Candy

Starstruck/Bad Kids/Swine/Come To Mama/Enigma

Boys, Boys, Boys/Highway Unicorn/Donatella/Hey Girl/Replay

Paper Gangsta/Heavy Metal Lover/Fashion!/Angel Down/ Sine From Above

Brown Eyes/Electric Chapel/Mary Jane Holland/Grigio Girls/1000 Doves

I Like It Rough/You and I/Dope/Just Another Day/Babylon

Summerboy/The Edge Of Glory/Gypsy/Angel Down(work tape)/Love Me Right

Disco Heaven/The Queen/Applause/ Million Reasons(work tape)/1000 Doves(piano demo)

So the final tally goes like the below...Choosing between MTN, Aura, Diamond Heart & Alice was really hard considering I've always loved the first track on Gaga's albums more than most others. Choosing between Paparazzi, GH & Rain on me was also difficult. Choosing between Bloody Mary and ARTPOP was hard as well as Judas vs Sexxx Dreams. But other than that the decisions were pretty easy. And in retrospect looking at the below, I would say that I agree. 

I think Chromatica is her best album. I think it's really close with BTW and w/o Fame Monster, The Fame and ARTPOP keep to the rear. 

 

And honestly the only songs I really care for from Joanne anymore are the piano version of Joanne, Million Reasons and Diamond Heart. 

The Fame - 1 

Born This Way - 5 

ARTPOP - 1 

Joanne - 0 

Chromatica -7 

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 122
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Jose P

Just Dance/Marry The Night/Aura/Diamond Heart/Alice

Love Game/Born This Way/Venus/A-YO/Stupid Love

Paparazzi/Government Hooker/G.U.Y/Joanne/Rain On Me

Poker Face/Judas/Sexxx Dreams/John Wayne/Free Woman

Eh,Eh/Americano/Jewels N’ Drugs/Dancin’ In Circles/Fun Tonight

Beautiful, Dirty, Rich/Hair/MANiCURE/Perfect Illusion/911

The Fame/Scheisse/Do What U Want/Million Reasons/Plastic Doll

Money Honey/Bloody Mary/ARTPOP/Sinner’s Prayer/Sour Candy

Starstruck/Bad Kids/Swine/Come To Mama/Enigma

Boys, Boys, Boys/Highway Unicorn/Donatella/Hey Girl/Replay

Paper Gangsta/Heavy Metal Lover/Fashion!/Angel Down/ Sine From Above

Brown Eyes/Electric Chapel/Mary Jane Holland/Grigio Girls/1000 Doves

I Like It Rough/You and I/Dope/Just Another Day/Babylon

Summerboy/The Edge Of Glory/Gypsy/Angel Down(work tape)/Love Me Right

Disco Heaven/The Queen/Applause/ Million Reasons(work tape)/1000 Doves(piano demo)

The Fame: 1

Born This Way: 6

ARTPOP: 2

Joanne: 1

Chromatica: 5

Link to post
Share on other sites

ToxicHot

I was going to participate in this but I literally got a headache just looking at these song choices. It’s so OVERWHELMING. :giveup: 

You can’t compare them based on track number like..... :bradley: Also this doesn’t add up well, comparing Disco Heaven and Applause to acoustic bonus tracks, and also The Queen doesn’t go after TEOG? Lol.

dOnT sAd ReAcT mE 2 bE sHaDy i WiLL RePoRt U!!1!
Link to post
Share on other sites

Glamourpuss

Just Dance/Marry The Night/Aura/Diamond Heart/Alice

Love Game/Born This Way/Venus/A-YO/Stupid Love

Paparazzi/Government Hooker/G.U.Y/Joanne/Rain On Me

Poker Face/Judas/Sexxx Dreams/John Wayne/Free Woman

Eh,Eh/Americano/Jewels N’ Drugs/Dancin’ In Circles/Fun Tonight

Beautiful, Dirty, Rich/Hair/MANiCURE/Perfect Illusion/911

The Fame/Scheisse/Do What U Want/Million Reasons/Plastic Doll

Money Honey/Bloody Mary/ARTPOP/Sinner’s Prayer/Sour Candy

Starstruck/Bad Kids/Swine/Come To Mama/Enigma

Boys, Boys, Boys/Highway Unicorn/Donatella/Hey Girl/Replay

Paper Gangsta/Heavy Metal Lover/Fashion!/Angel Down/ Sine From Above

Brown Eyes/Electric Chapel/Mary Jane Holland/Grigio Girls/1000 Doves

I Like It Rough/You and I/Dope/Just Another Day/Babylon

Summerboy/The Edge Of Glory/Gypsy/Angel Down(work tape)/Love Me Right

Disco Heaven/The Queen/Applause/ Million Reasons(work tape)/1000 Doves(piano demo)

 

Result: 

The Fame: 2

Born This Way: 5

ARTPOP: 1

Joanne: 2

Chromatica: 5

Link to post
Share on other sites

 
 
 
 
Spoiler

Just Dance/Marry The Night/Aura/Diamond Heart/Alice

Love Game/Born This Way/Venus/A-YO/Stupid Love

Paparazzi/Government Hooker/G.U.Y/Joanne/Rain On Me

Poker Face/Judas/Sexxx Dreams/John Wayne/Free Woman

Eh,Eh/Americano/Jewels N’ Drugs/Dancin’ In Circles/Fun Tonight

Beautiful, Dirty, Rich/Hair/MANiCURE/Perfect Illusion/911

The Fame/Scheisse/Do What U Want/Million Reasons/Plastic Doll

Money Honey/Bloody Mary/ARTPOP/Sinner’s Prayer/Sour Candy

Starstruck/Bad Kids/Swine/Come To Mama/Enigma

Boys, Boys, Boys/Highway Unicorn/Donatella/Hey Girl/Replay

Paper Gangsta/Heavy Metal Lover/Fashion!/Angel Down/Sine From Above

Brown Eyes/Electric Chapel/Mary Jane Holland/Grigio Girls/1000 Doves

I Like It Rough/You and I/Dope/Just Another Day/Babylon

Summerboy/The Edge Of Glory/Gypsy/Angel Down(work tape)/Love Me Right

Disco Heaven/The Queen/Applause/ Million Reasons(work tape)/1000 Doves(piano demo)

The Fame: 1

Born This Way: 3

ARTPOP: 4

Joanne: 3

Chromatica: 4

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Esme Squalor

Just Dance/Marry The Night/Aura/Diamond Heart/Alice

Love Game/Born This Way/Venus/A-YO/Stupid Love

Paparazzi/Government Hooker/G.U.Y/Joanne/Rain On Me

Poker Face/Judas/Sexxx Dreams/John Wayne/Free Woman

Eh,Eh/Americano/Jewels N’ Drugs/Dancin’ In Circles/Fun Tonight

Beautiful, Dirty, Rich/Hair/MANiCURE/Perfect Illusion/911

The Fame/Scheisse/Do What U Want/Million Reasons/Plastic Doll

Money Honey/Bloody Mary/ARTPOP/Sinner’s Prayer/Sour Candy

Starstruck/Bad Kids/Swine/Come To Mama/Enigma

Boys, Boys, Boys/Highway Unicorn/Donatella/Hey Girl/Replay 

Paper Gangsta/Heavy Metal Lover/Fashion!/Angel Down/ Sine From Above

Brown Eyes/Electric Chapel/Mary Jane Holland/Grigio Girls/1000 Doves

I Like It Rough/You and I/Dope/Just Another Day/Babylon

Summerboy/The Edge Of Glory/Gypsy/Angel Down(work tape)/Love Me Right

Disco Heaven/The Queen/Applause/ Million Reasons(work tape)/1000 Doves(piano demo)

Result: 

Born This Way: 6

Joanne: 0

ARTPOP: 5

Chromatica: 3

The Fame: 1

Choosing between Donatella and Replay killed me.

Link to post
Share on other sites

monstercj

Just Dance/Marry The Night/Aura/Diamond Heart/Alice

Love Game/Born This Way/Venus/A-YO/Stupid Love

Paparazzi/Government Hooker/G.U.Y/Joanne/Rain On Me

Poker Face/Judas/Sexxx Dreams/John Wayne/Free Woman

Eh,Eh/Americano/Jewels N’ Drugs/Dancin’ In Circles/Fun Tonight

Beautiful, Dirty, Rich/Hair/MANiCURE/Perfect Illusion/911

The Fame/Scheisse/Do What U Want/Million Reasons/Plastic Doll

Money Honey/Bloody Mary/ARTPOP/Sinner’s Prayer/Sour Candy

Starstruck/Bad Kids/Swine/Come To Mama/Enigma

Boys, Boys, Boys/Highway Unicorn/Donatella/Hey Girl/Replay

Paper Gangsta/Heavy Metal Lover/Fashion!/Angel Down/ Sine From Above

Brown Eyes/Electric Chapel/Mary Jane Holland/Grigio Girls/1000 Doves

I Like It Rough/You and I/Dope/Just Another Day/Babylon

Summerboy/The Edge Of Glory/Gypsy/Angel Down(work tape)/Love Me Right

Disco Heaven/The Queen/Applause/Million Reasons(work tape)/1000 Doves(pianodemo)

Result: 

TF : 2

BTW : 9

AP : 1

J : 0

Chromatica : 3

Link to post
Share on other sites

qoqo

Which song do you prefer? 

Just Dance/Marry The Night/Aura/Diamond Heart/Alice

Love Game/Born This Way/Venus/A-YO/Stupid Love

Paparazzi/Government Hooker/G.U.Y/Joanne/Rain On Me

Poker Face/Judas/Sexxx Dreams/John Wayne/Free Woman

Eh,Eh/Americano/Jewels N’ Drugs/Dancin’ In Circles/Fun Tonight

Beautiful, Dirty, Rich/Hair/MANiCURE/Perfect Illusion/911

The Fame/Scheisse/Do What U Want/Million Reasons/Plastic Doll

Money Honey/Bloody Mary/ARTPOP/Sinner’s Prayer/Sour Candy

Starstruck/Bad Kids/Swine/Come To Mama/Enigma

Boys, Boys, Boys/Highway Unicorn/Donatella/Hey Girl/Replay

Paper Gangsta/Heavy Metal Lover/Fashion!/Angel Down/ Sine From Above

Brown Eyes/Electric Chapel/Mary Jane Holland/Grigio Girls/1000 Doves

I Like It Rough/You and I/Dope/Just Another Day/Babylon

Summerboy/The Edge Of Glory/Gypsy/Angel Down(work tape)/Love Me Right

Disco Heaven/The Queen/Applause/ Million Reasons(work tape)/1000 Doves(piano demo)

 

The Fame: 1

BTW: 4

ARTPOP: 6

Joanne: 2

Chromatica: 2

Link to post
Share on other sites

PrettiestStar

Just Dance/Marry The Night/Aura/Diamond Heart/Alice

Love Game/Born This Way/Venus/A-YO/Stupid Love

Paparazzi/Government Hooker/G.U.Y/Joanne/Rain On Me

Poker Face/Judas/Sexxx Dreams/John Wayne/Free Woman

Eh,Eh/Americano/Jewels N’ Drugs/Dancin’ In Circles/Fun Tonight

Beautiful, Dirty, Rich/Hair/MANiCURE/Perfect Illusion/911

The Fame/Scheisse/Do What U Want/Million Reasons/Plastic Doll

Money Honey/Bloody Mary/ARTPOP/Sinner’s Prayer/Sour Candy

Starstruck/Bad Kids/Swine/Come To Mama/Enigma

Boys, Boys, Boys/Highway Unicorn/Donatella/Hey Girl/Replay

Paper Gangsta/Heavy Metal Lover/Fashion!/Angel Down/ Sine From Above

Brown Eyes/Electric Chapel/Mary Jane Holland/Grigio Girls/1000 Doves - had very hard time deciding

I Like It Rough/You and I/Dope/Just Another Day/Babylon

Summerboy/The Edge Of Glory/Gypsy/Angel Down(work tape)/Love Me Right

Disco Heaven/The Queen/Applause/ Million Reasons(work tape)/1000 Doves(piano demo)

 

Result: 

Chromatica: 6

Joanne: 4

Born This Way: 3

ARTPOP: 2

The Fame: 0 :billie:

 

EDIT: Why haven't you included TFM, @andrew23?

Link to post
Share on other sites

Biggest Bitch
16 minutes ago, PrettiestStar said:

Just Dance/Marry The Night/Aura/Diamond Heart/Alice

Love Game/Born This Way/Venus/A-YO/Stupid Love

Paparazzi/Government Hooker/G.U.Y/Joanne/Rain On Me

Poker Face/Judas/Sexxx Dreams/John Wayne/Free Woman

Eh,Eh/Americano/Jewels N’ Drugs/Dancin’ In Circles/Fun Tonight

Beautiful, Dirty, Rich/Hair/MANiCURE/Perfect Illusion/911

The Fame/Scheisse/Do What U Want/Million Reasons/Plastic Doll

Money Honey/Bloody Mary/ARTPOP/Sinner’s Prayer/Sour Candy

Starstruck/Bad Kids/Swine/Come To Mama/Enigma

Boys, Boys, Boys/Highway Unicorn/Donatella/Hey Girl/Replay

Paper Gangsta/Heavy Metal Lover/Fashion!/Angel Down/ Sine From Above

Brown Eyes/Electric Chapel/Mary Jane Holland/Grigio Girls/1000 Doves - had very hard time deciding

I Like It Rough/You and I/Dope/Just Another Day/Babylon

Summerboy/The Edge Of Glory/Gypsy/Angel Down(work tape)/Love Me Right

Disco Heaven/The Queen/Applause/ Million Reasons(work tape)/1000 Doves(piano demo)

 

Result: 

Chromatica: 6

Joanne: 4

Born This Way: 3

ARTPOP: 2

The Fame: 0 :billie:

 

EDIT: Why haven't you included TFM, @andrew23?

With 8 songs? :huntyga:

Link to post
Share on other sites

gagaxsebert

Just Dance/Marry The Night/Aura/Diamond Heart/Alice (Gaga really knows how to make an intro)

Love Game/Born This Way/Venus/A-YO/Stupid Love

Paparazzi/Government Hooker/G.U.Y/Joanne/Rain On Me

Poker Face/Judas/Sexxx Dreams/John Wayne/Free Woman (this was hard)

Eh,Eh/Americano/Jewels N’ Drugs/Dancin’ In Circles/Fun Tonight

Beautiful, Dirty, Rich/Hair/MANiCURE/Perfect Illusion/911

The Fame/Scheiße/Do What U Want (Solo)/Million Reasons/Plastic Doll (Scheiße vs DWUW was difficult)

Money Honey/Bloody Mary/ARTPOP/Sinner’s Prayer/Sour Candy

Starstruck/Bad Kids/Swine/Come To Mama/Enigma

Boys, Boys, Boys/Highway Unicorn/Donatella/Hey Girl/Replay

Paper Gangsta/Heavy MetalLover/Fashion!/Angel Down/ Sine From Above

Brown Eyes/Electric Chapel/Mary Jane Holland/Grigio Girls/1000 Doves

I Like It Rough/You and I/Dope/Just Another Day/Babylon

Summerboy/The Edge Of Glory/Gypsy/Angel Down(work tape)/Love Me Right (Summerboy could’ve won)

Disco Heaven/The Queen/Applause/ Million Reasons(work tape)/1000 Doves(piano demo)

Result: 

Born This Way: 7

Joanne: 2

ARTPOP: 3

Chromatica: 3

The Fame: 0

Used to be HighRoad
Link to post
Share on other sites

Bling

Just Dance/Marry The Night/Aura/Diamond Heart/Alice

Love Game/Born This Way/Venus/A-YO/Stupid Love

Paparazzi/Government Hooker/G.U.Y/Joanne/Rain On Me

Poker Face/Judas/Sexxx Dreams/John Wayne/Free Woman

Eh,Eh/Americano/Jewels N’ Drugs/Dancin’ In Circles/Fun Tonight

Beautiful, Dirty, Rich/Hair/MANiCURE/Perfect Illusion/911

The Fame/Scheisse/Do What U Want/Million Reasons/Plastic Doll

Money Honey/Bloody Mary/ARTPOP/Sinner’s Prayer/Sour Candy

Starstruck/Bad Kids/Swine/Come To Mama/Enigma

Boys, Boys, Boys/Highway Unicorn/Donatella/Hey Girl/Replay

Paper Gangsta/Heavy Metal Lover/Fashion!/Angel Down/ Sine From Above

Brown Eyes/Electric Chapel/Mary Jane Holland/Grigio Girls/1000 Doves

I Like It Rough/You and I/Dope/Just Another Day/Babylon

Summerboy/The Edge Of Glory/Gypsy/Angel Down(work tape)/Love Me Right

Disco Heaven/The Queen/Applause/ Million Reasons(work tape)/1000 Doves(piano demo)

Result: 

Born This Way: 8

Chromatica: 5

Joanne: 1

ARTPOP: 1

The Fame: 1

 THIS WAS SOOO HARD

Looks like I'm a BTW kween :huntyga:

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Just Dance/Marry The Night/Aura/Diamond Heart/Alice

LoveGame/Born This Way/Venus/A-YO/Stupid Love

Paparazzi/Government Hooker/G.U.Y/Joanne/Rain On Me

Poker Face/Judas/Sexxx Dreams/John Wayne/Free Woman

Eh, Eh/Americano/Jewels N’ Drugs/Dancin’ In Circles/Fun Tonight

Beautiful, Dirty, Rich/Hair/MANiCURE/Perfect Illusion/911

The Fame/Scheisse/Do What U Want/Million Reasons/Plastic Doll

Money Honey/Bloody Mary/ARTPOP/Sinner’s Prayer/Sour Candy

Starstruck/Bad Kids/Swine/Come To Mama/Enigma

Boys, Boys, Boys/Highway Unicorn/Donatella/Hey Girl/Replay

Paper Gangsta/Heavy Metal Lover/Fashion!/Angel Down/Sine From Above

Brown Eyes/Electric Chapel/Mary Jane Holland/Grigio Girls/1000 Doves

I Like It Rough/You and I/Dope/Just Another Day/Babylon

Summerboy/The Edge Of Glory/Gypsy/Angel Down(work tape)/Love Me Right

Disco Heaven/The Queen/Applause/ Million Reasons(work tape)/1000 Doves(piano demo)

 

Results:

Born This Way: 5

ARTPOP: 4

Chromatica: 3

Joanne: 2

The Fame: 1

 

Honorable mentions to LoveGame, Government Hooker, BDR, Paper Gangsta, Sine From Above, Just Another Day and TEOG, that was so hard to choose. D':

Link to post
Share on other sites

martiniglistens

Just Dance/Marry The Night/Aura/Diamond Heart/Alice

Love Game/Born This Way/Venus/A-YO/Stupid Love

Paparazzi/Government Hooker/G.U.Y/Joanne/Rain On Me

Poker Face/Judas/Sexxx Dreams/John Wayne/Free Woman

Eh,Eh/Americano/Jewels N’ Drugs/Dancin’ In Circles/Fun Tonight

Beautiful, Dirty, Rich/Hair/MANiCURE/Perfect Illusion/911

The Fame/Scheisse/Do What U Want/Million Reasons/Plastic Doll

Money Honey/Bloody Mary/ARTPOP/Sinner’s Prayer/Sour Candy

Starstruck/Bad Kids/Swine/Come To Mama/Enigma

Boys, Boys, Boys/Highway Unicorn/Donatella/Hey Girl/Replay

Paper Gangsta/Heavy Metal Lover/Fashion!/Angel Down/ Sine From Above

Brown Eyes/Electric Chapel/Mary Jane Holland/Grigio Girls/1000 Doves

I Like It Rough/You and I/Dope/Just Another Day/Babylon

Summerboy/The Edge Of Glory/Gypsy/Angel Down(work tape)/Love Me Right

Disco Heaven/The Queen/Applause/ Million Reasons(work tape)/1000 Doves(piano demo)

 

Result: 

Born This Way: 8

Joanne: 1

ARTPOP: 1

Chromatica: 3

The Fame: 2

 

Which makes sense because this basically falls in line with my album rankings lmao

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...