Rate Chromatica from 1 to 10!

[Bonkiii 585]

I am so happy, you all take part on the poll <3

[ARTGOD 3,266]

I tried so hard but I can’t bring myself to like this album and I’m devastated .

The sinking feeling I got halfway through the album when I realized I wasn’t liking it was terrible.

I’m happy for everyone who’s loving it and I hope it does well commercially, but I’m so disappointed.

[Notget 502]

1. Bland and more boring than fun. Lacks any punch. Not the worst album of all time obviously, but a major disappointment and she can do much better than this.

[TheBeast 1,379]

The fact that over 75% of the votes are 8-10.

[Infinity Wave 7,635]

On 5/28/2020 at 12:27 PM, ZiggyZiggs said:

5.5 on initial listen (bar 1000 doves and sine from above)

will probably increase by next week tho

EDIT: after a full day of listening to this album I can say this is easily my fave Gaga album so 50/10 yep yep yep 

GAGA I HOPE YOU HAVE IT IN YOUR HEART TO FORGIVE MY INITIAL BLASPHEMY 

SAME OMG

First, initial listen? Big no.

Second, third, fourth listen? I woke up today chanting every song hook. Every single one.

She did that. SHE ****ING DID THAT 

[Infinity Wave 7,635]

I'd say...

Spoiler

 

Alice - 9,5 (Would have loved less instrumental part, or at least a longer length overall)

Babylon - 9,5 (Would have loved more bird sounds and less predominant saxophones, it kinda kills the mood in some places)

Enigma - 9,5 (Would have loved a bigger hitting instrumental for the chorus)

ROM - 9 (Too short, only complain)

SFA - 9 (would of been 9 but the ending isn't my cup of tea, sorry)

911 - 8,5 (Has the biggest growth potential, will be a 10 soon)

SL - 8

FT - 7,5

Replay - 7,5 (It will grow on me for sure)

FW - 7

1000 Doves - 7 (Yeah)

SC - 6,5 (LOVE LOVE LOVE the hook and the Gaga part, but the BlackPink part doesn't do much for me. But the HOOK IS AMAZING)

PD - 5,5 (It honestly sounds like Heal Me... c'mon sistrens, you can start singing the Heal Me chorus after the pre chorus and it fits - and I know cuz I tried . Plus the synth is the same from HBF . Truly the "Bad Kids" of the album for me)

 

Therefor the album is a solid 8 for me. 

Which is excellent I'd say, given that many songs will grow on me and will get to higher ranks.

To provide comparison, I'd say ARTPOP (my favourite Gaga album) is an 8 too.

So that places Chromatica in the empireum!

 

 

[ZiggyZiggs 30,058]

5 hours ago, Infinity Wave said:

SAME OMG

First, initial listen? Big no.

Second, third, fourth listen? I woke up today chanting every song hook. Every single one.

She did that. SHE ****ING DID THAT 

YESSS

I AM ACTUALLY IN SHOCK CUZ ITS THAT GOOD

[andreas85 394]

I give it 8/10. Maybe I'll change my opinions later but this seems like an appropriate rating for now. A definitely good thing about Chromatica is that it doesn't have any songs that I really dislike so even some of the weaker songs are at least somehow enjoyable. Chromatica feels like a tribute to all those 90s dance pop songs I've been listening to a lot. It is also one of Gaga's more coherent albums and all the interludes lift the mood in an impressive way. I like this overall message that we still should be able to have fun and party in spite of all the bad news. I absolutely adore 911, it is just an incredibly catchy song and it gives me The Fame and The Fame Monster vibes. Fun Tonight is almost as good and Babylon has some of my favorite lyrics. Some of the songs are quite short but it doesn't bother me that much.

Chromatica 8/10

Alice 7/10

Stupid Love 6/10

Rain On Me 6/10

Free Woman 8/10

Fun Tonight 9/10

Chromatica II 8/10

911 10/10

Plastic Doll 8/10

Sour Candy 7/10

Enigma 7/10

Replay 6/10

Chromatica III 8/10

Sine from Above 9/10

100 Doves 6/10

Babylon 9/10

 

[PrettiestStar 414]

those 7 people tho 

[Oriane 20,937]

4, sorry not sorry. The interludes are the only parts I actually like and that says a lot. 

[AgusPop 4,141]

7 madonna's fans  

[GagaUnderYou 4,981]

6/10 for me right now

[Mikebristow 35]

Do we have GD polls from her other albums?

[Mikebristow 35]

Both I and my gf think this is her best album by a country mile;  A solid 10 from me. I liked A majority of the tracks on first listen. I can't say that even about The TF and TFM  I loved Sine so much it took me a while to listen to the whole Album cause I kept replaying it before I finished.  It was full of surprises my one criticism some of the songs are too ^%$#%%^^% short    

[Blackout19 11,792]

It's a good album, but the only songs that I would give 10 is Rain On Me and Free Woman