Would G.U.Y. Have Been A Better Lead Single?

[flynn99 538]

even tho guy is my fav gaga song of all time people just didnt get the message  behind it and that is why it wasnt very successful, applause has a very easy message 

[Twitter 14]

11 minutes ago, flynn99 said:

 

Off topic: omg you’re back on GGD. Remember me? 

[Tycho 3,694]

It was a really solid lead, she just messed up with the rest of the singles.

[Guest]

The only songs I think should have been singles and performed well were Do What U Want, Applause, and Gypsy.

[RRR 3,996]

Everyone knows Applause, it was a radio smash. It peaked at #4 and stayed high on the charts for a very long time.

It was a sleeper that slayed the gyms and the straights secretly loved it.

[2School4Cool 6,445]

Honestly I think Applause is the perfect lead single. After the BTWB ending the way it did, it was the perfect way of saying “I’m back” with a song all about loving the cheering of her fans.

Although G.U.Y. would be an epic concert opener .

[27monster27 13,126]

I know that I generally am the only person who thinks this, but I think Britney Spears could have been a great DWUW feature. Britney singing about hate from the media would have brought instant attention to the song. However, maybe as a remix though, with the solo being just Lady Gaga. I am not really sure...

[Isidro Guevara 821]

55 minutes ago, ajames said:

was a sleeper that slayed the gyms and the straights secretly loved it.

Now that I think about it, G.U.Y. would be considered too gay of a song for the straights. Luckily Applause slayed, even secretly

[Isidro Guevara 821]

35 minutes ago, 27monster27 said:

I know that I generally am the only person who thinks this, but I think Britney Spears could have been a great DWUW feature. Britney singing about hate from the media would have brought instant attention to the song. However, maybe as a remix though, with the solo being just Lady Gaga. I am not really sure...

I've always thought Britney could have featured in Sexxx Dreams. Her or Justin Timberlake. For some reason I can't imagine another female featured on DWUW. 

[2School4Cool 6,445]

1 minute ago, Isidro Guevara said:

Justin Timberlake

Now that I’d like to see.

[Isidro Guevara 821]

4 minutes ago, 2School4Cool said:

Now that I’d like to see.

I've always pictured a hot and steamy VMA's performance of Gaga and JT with rumors that they were probably dating. Imagine the MV leaking as if it was a sex tape! That would've been legendary and controversial!

[Eighteen 5,430]

applause is personally my favorite from the album. but thinking in terms of the GP, i don't think GUY would have done better than applause. i think manicure would have been the best charting song if it was lead (but since applause is my fav, i'm glad things went down the way it did)

[2School4Cool 6,445]

8 minutes ago, Isidro Guevara said:

I've always pictured a hot and steamy VMA's performance of Gaga and JT with rumors that they were probably dating. Imagine the MV leaking as if it was a sex tape! That would've been legendary and controversial!

Whenever or however it is we need a collab someday (other than 3-way ).

[Bradley 59,063]

It would've done really well even as a third single, if she had performed it at the Grammys and Brits, and sent it to radios, and promoted it extensively live on TV when TV promotion did a great deal.

Dark Horse was given this treatment and it exploded. Even if G.U.Y. doesn't hit Dark Horse-level status, it would've been a LoveGame-level hit (top 10?) and become the Alejandro of the ARTPOP era.

[Rion 95]

I Think G.U.Y. would be a great lead single as well! I made a video analyzing the meaning of the video, hope you like it!