Do You Think Shallow is part of Gaga's Top 5 Biggest Hits?

[KatieJudasGaga4 67,907]

I'd say yes.

 

Its up there with Poker Face, Bad Romance, Just Dance and Born This Way

 

Discuss

[geopang 4,831]

Biggest hits, yes. Best songs, no.

[PopCons 26]

Yeah for sure, Bad Romance and Poker Face are bigger, but Shallow is comparable with JD and BTW, probably more WW famous than JD and outselling BTW 

[Andreu 37,216]

definitely

[IAmNotHere1997 25,824]

Yes. It's basically

1. Bad Romance
2. Poker Face
3. Shallow
4. Just Dance
5. Born This Way

[yxi 4,999]

Anyone saying no is delusional

[GypsyRomance 862]

1 minute ago, gabrielflorin01 said:

Yes. It's basically

1. Bad Romance
2. Poker Face
3. Shallow
4. Just Dance
5. Born This Way

I definitely have the same list as this

[PopCons 26]

I totally agree, in Italy Just Dance wasn’t perceived like a big hit, that’s why my rank looks like this:

1) Bad Romance

2) Poker Face

3) Shallow 

4) Born This Way

5) Just Dance

 

(I think Born This Way could be considered bigger than Just Dance, it’s more iconic and relevant, I know JD outselled but BTW was such a big momentum for Gaga)

[Judas Society 3,584]

Yes, I actually think Shallow has the same worldwide cultural phenomenon weight to it. It became this song where people just recognize from the get go and willing to participate in singing along or dancing along. The many videos where people were screaming at the top of the lungs to what is now known as the Gaga howl shows that they don't only know the song, the song is a vehicle for community activity much like Bad Romance's choreo were. 

Poker Face was a huge hit but it's not exactly what I call a cultural phenomenon like BR and Shallow.

[The Child 18,997]

16 minutes ago, Judas Society said:

Yes, I actually think Shallow has the same worldwide cultural phenomenon weight to it. It became this song where people just recognize from the get go and willing to participate in singing along or dancing along. The many videos where people were screaming at the top of the lungs to what is now known as the Gaga howl shows that they don't only know the song, the song is a vehicle for community activity much like Bad Romance's choreo were. 

Poker Face was a huge hit but it's not exactly what I call a cultural phenomenon like BR and Shallow.

PF was a HUGE HIT! You’re a huge mess!

[AmericanxDream 2,049]

Without a doubt.

[Judas Society 3,584]

3 minutes ago, CrazyMonster said:

PF was a HUGE HIT! You’re a huge mess!

well, I never said it wasn't. Mess 

[RoverLoader 1,254]

But Shallow is a duet..does that really count?

[KatieJudasGaga4 67,907]

7 minutes ago, RoverLoader said:

But Shallow is a duet..does that really count?

Considering she wrote, produced and sang 75% of the song, yes.

[AVeryGagaHolyDick 26,199]

Just Dance doesn't deserve to be there. It never really shined, it was just helped by Poker Face honnestly. Yes it has sold a lot of copies, but it never really had a true moment. Paparazzi is well more known and loved, or Alejandro