Jump to content
Stefani Tee
opinion

Madonna vs. Gaga Battle Game

Featured Posts

Didymus

So, inspired by @Frivolero I threw this little game together :ohwell:

My goal was to link most Madonna singles to equivalents in Gaga's career, which is why there's non-singles on the list. I linked songs together based on sound and/or lyrical content and/or status in Madge's and Gaga's discographies :koons:

Choose the shorter or longer list, mark your favorite in bold and (if you care) write down your scores! :music:

If you don't like the equivalents I chose, feel free to choose your own and post why :gayhat:

SHORTER LIST, SINGLES ONLY:

Spoiler

Just Dance vs. Into the Groove
LoveGame vs. Like a Virgin
Poker Face vs. Who's That Girl
Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say) vs. Cherish
Bad Romance vs. Vogue
Alejandro vs. La Isla Bonita
Telephone vs. Hung Up
Born This Way vs. Express Yourself
Judas vs. Girl Gone Wild
Yoü and I vs. Don't Tell Me
The Edge of Glory vs. Ray of Light
G.U.Y. vs. Revolver
Do What U Want vs. Joan of Arc
Applause vs. Give Me All Your Luvin'
Perfect Illusion vs. American Life
Million Reasons vs. Take a Bow
Shallow vs. American Life
Always Remember Us This Way vs. Live to Tell
I'll Never Love Again vs. Crazy for You

LONGER LIST, INCL. GAGA ALBUM TRACKS:

Spoiler

Just Dance vs. Into the Groove
LoveGame vs. Like a Virgin
Poker Face vs. Who's That Girl
Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say) vs. Cherish
Beautiful, Dirty, Rich vs. Papa Don't Preach
The Fame vs. Hollywood
Money Honey vs. Material Girl
I Like It Rough vs. Erotica
Bad Romance vs. Vogue
Alejandro vs. La Isla Bonita
Speechless vs. Oh Father
Dance in the Dark vs. What It Feels Like for a Girl
Telephone vs. Hung Up
So Happy I Could Die vs. Crave
Teeth vs. Give It 2 Me
Born This Way vs. Express Yourself
Judas vs. Girl Gone Wild
Hair vs. Burning Up
Bad Kids vs. Human Nature
Fashion of His Love vs. Dress You Up
Yoü and I vs. Don't Tell Me
The Edge of Glory vs. Ray of Light
G.U.Y. vs. Revolver
Sexxx Dreams vs. Justify My Love
Jewels N' Drugs vs. Bitch I'm Madonna
Do What U Want vs. Joan of Arc
ARTPOP vs. Bedtime Story
Dope vs. Bad Girl
Gypsy vs. Holiday
Applause vs. Give Me All Your Luvin'
Lush Life vs. American Pie
Perfect Illusion vs. American Life
Million Reasons vs. Take a Bow
Sinner's Prayer vs. Nothing Fails
Come to Mama vs. Celebration
Hey Girl vs. Me Against the Music
Shallow vs. Ghosttown
Always Remember Us This Way vs. Live to Tell
I'll Never Love Again vs. Crazy for You

:woohoo:

Edited by Didymus
  • Like 2

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Didymus

My choices:

Spoiler

Just Dance vs. Into the Groove
LoveGame vs. Like a Virgin
Poker Face vs. Who's That Girl
Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say) vs. Cherish
Beautiful, Dirty, Rich vs. Papa Don't Preach
The Fame vs. Hollywood
Money Honey vs. Material Girl
I Like It Rough vs. Erotica
Bad Romance vs. Vogue
Alejandro vs. La Isla Bonita
Speechless vs. Oh Father
Dance in the Dark vs. What It Feels Like for a Girl
Telephone vs. Hung Up
So Happy I Could Die vs. Crave
Teeth vs. Give It 2 Me
Born This Way vs. Express Yourself
Judas vs. Girl Gone Wild
Hair vs. Burning Up
Bad Kids vs. Human Nature
Fashion of His Love vs. Dress You Up
Yoü and I vs. Don't Tell Me
The Edge of Glory vs. Ray of Light
G.U.Y. vs. Revolver
Sexxx Dreams vs. Justify My Love
Jewels N' Drugs vs. Bitch I'm Madonna
Do What U Want vs. Joan of Arc
ARTPOP vs. Bedtime Story
Dope vs. Bad Girl
Gypsy vs. Holiday
Applause vs. Give Me All Your Luvin'
Lush Life vs. American Pie
Perfect Illusion vs. American Life
Million Reasons vs. Take a Bow
Sinner's Prayer vs. Nothing Fails
Come to Mama vs. Celebration
Hey Girl vs. Me Against the Music
Shallow vs. American Life
Always Remember Us This Way vs. Live to Tell
I'll Never Love Again vs. Crazy for You

GAGA: 24 :ladyhaha:

MADONNA: 22 :madge:

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Didymus

No one has as much time to waste as me probably (even though I'm in the middle of writing a thesis) so I'm ready for this to flawp, don't bump this ok

giphy.gif

  • Like 1
  • YAAAS 1

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
GagaXCollection

Just Dance vs. Into the Groove
LoveGame vs. Like a Virgin
Poker Face vs. Who's That Girl
Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say) vs. Cherish
Bad Romance vs. Vogue
Alejandro vs. La Isla Bonita
Telephone vs. Hung Up
Born This Way vs. Express Yourself
Judas vs. Girl Gone Wild
Yoü and I vs. Don't Tell Me
The Edge of Glory vs. Ray of Light
G.U.Y. vs. Revolver
Do What U Want vs. Joan of Arc
Applause vs. Give Me All Your Luvin'
Perfect Illusion vs. American Life
Million Reasons vs. Take a Bow
Shallow vs. American Life
Always Remember Us This Way vs. Live to Tell
I'll Never Love Again vs. Crazy for You

Lady Gaga collector since 2010
  • YAAAS 1

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
AlvariusFlame

I don't really like Madonna so I don't know the half of these songs. 

 

LoveGame vs. Like a Virgin
Poker Face vs. Who's That Girl
Bad Romance vs. Vogue
Alejandro vs. La Isla Bonita
Telephone vs. Hung Up
Born This Way vs. Express Yourself
Judas vs. Girl Gone Wild
The Edge of Glory vs. Ray of Light
Do What U Want vs. Joan of Arc (I don't know this song but I know DWUW is hard to beat) 
Applause vs. Give Me All Your Luvin'
Shallow vs. American Life (same than DWUW, Shallow is real hard to beat) 
 

 

Edited by AlvariusFlame
  • YAAAS 1

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Didymus

Omg I wrote down AL twice, I'm noticing :air: Replacing Shallow/American Life with Shallow/Ghosttown :classy:

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
DiamondKing

Just Dance vs. Into the Groove
LoveGame vs. Like a Virgin
Poker Face vs. Who's That Girl
Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say) vs. Cherish
Bad Romance vs. Vogue
Alejandro vs. La Isla Bonita
Telephone vs. Hung Up
Born This Way vs. Express Yourself
Judas vs. Girl Gone Wild (Judas 0,00005% behind :selena:, Girl Gone Wild is pop perfection :pray: )
Yoü and I vs. Don't Tell Me
The Edge of Glory vs. Ray of Light
G.U.Y. vs. Revolver
Do What U Want vs. Joan of Arc
Applause vs. Give Me All Your Luvin'
Perfect Illusion vs. American Life
Million Reasons vs. Take a Bow
Shallow vs.  Ghosttown
Always Remember Us This Way vs. Live toTell
I'll Never Love Again vs. Crazy for You

 

I'm not a fan of most of Madonna's older stuff tbh

Edited by DiamondKing
We Belong Together, Mirages ❤
  • Like 1

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
RudraCNG

Just Dance vs. Into the Groove
LoveGame vs. Like a Virgin
Poker Face vs. Who's That Girl
Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say) vs. Cherish
Beautiful, Dirty, Rich vs. Papa Don't Preach
The Fame vs. Hollywood
Money Honey vs. Material Girl
I Like It Rough vs. Erotica
Bad Romance vs. Vogue
Alejandro vs. La Isla Bonita
Speechless vs. Oh Father
Dance in the Dark vs. What It Feels Like for a Girl
Telephone vs. Hung Up
So Happy I Could Die vs. Crave
Teeth vs. Give It 2 Me
Born This Way vs. Express Yourself
Judas vs. Girl Gone Wild
Hair vs. Burning Up
Bad Kids vs. Human Nature
Fashion of His Love vs. Dress You Up
Yoü and I vs. Don't Tell Me
The Edge of Glory vs. Ray of Light
G.U.Y. vs. Revolver
Sexxx Dreams vs. Justify My Love
Jewels N' Drugs vs. Bitch I'm Madonna
Do What U Want vs. Joan of Arc
ARTPOP vs. Bedtime Story
Dope vs. Bad Girl
Gypsy vs. Holiday
Applause vs. Give Me All Your Luvin'
Lush Life vs. American Pie
Perfect Illusion vs. American Life
Million Reasons vs. Take a Bow
Sinner's Prayer vs. Nothing Fails
Come to Mama vs. Celebration
Hey Girl vs. Me Against the Music
Shallow vs. American Life
Always Remember Us This Way vs. Live to Tell
I'll Never Love Again vs. Crazy for You

 

I really love Madonna but you just confronted my favorite ones from her against some of my favorite ones from Gaga :noparty:

I think you chose wisely tho.

  • Thanks 1

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
corvus albus

Just Dance vs. Into the Groove
LoveGame vs. Like a Virgin
Poker Face vs. Who's That Girl
Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say) vs. Cherish
Beautiful, Dirty, Rich vs. Papa Don't Preach
The Fame vs. Hollywood
Money Honey vs. Material Girl
I Like It Rough vs. Erotica
Bad Romance vs. Vogue
Alejandro vs. La Isla Bonita
Speechless vs. Oh Father
Dance in the Dark vs. What It Feels Like for a Girl
Telephone vs. Hung Up
So Happy I Could Die vs. Crave
Teeth vs. Give It 2 Me
Born This Way vs. Express Yourself
Judas vs. Girl Gone Wild
Hair vs. Burning Up
Bad Kids vs. Human Nature
Fashion of His Love vs. Dress You Up
Yoü and I vs. Don't Tell Me
The Edge of Glory vs. Ray of Light
G.U.Y. vs. Revolver
Sexxx Dreams vs. Justify My Love
Jewels N' Drugs vs. Bitch I'm Madonna
Do What U Want vs. Joan of Arc
ARTPOP vs. Bedtime Story
Dope vs. Bad Girl
Gypsy vs. Holiday
Applause vs. Give Me All Your Luvin'
Lush Life vs. American Pie
Perfect Illusion vs. American Life
Million Reasons vs. Take a Bow
Sinner's Prayer vs. Nothing Fails
Come to Mama vs. Celebration
Hey Girl vs. Me Against the Music
Shallow vs. Ghosttown
Always Remember Us This Way vs. Live to Tell
I'll Never Love Again vs. Crazy for You

Am I standing still?

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Didymus

Omg some super interesting, unexpected choices :oprah: Love it.

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Gagadonna

Just Dance vs. Into the Groove
LoveGame vs. Like a Virgin
Poker Face vs. Who's That Girl
Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say) vs. Cherish
Bad Romance vs. Vogue
Alejandro vs. La Isla Bonita
Telephone vs. Hung Up
Born This Way vs. Express Yourself
Judas vs. Girl Gone Wild
Yoü and I vs. Don't Tell Me
The Edge of Glory vs. Ray of Light
G.U.Y. vs. Revolver
Do What U Want vs. Joan of Arc
Applause vs. Give Me All Your Luvin'
Perfect Illusion vs. American Life
Million Reasons vs. Take a Bow
Shallow vs. American Life
Always Remember Us This Way vs. Live to Tell
I'll Never Love Again vs. Crazy for You

  • Like 1

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Gagadonna

Just Dance vs. Into the Groove
LoveGame vs. Like a Virgin
Poker Face vs. Who's That Girl
Eh, Eh (Nothing Else I Can Say) vs. Cherish
Beautiful, Dirty, Rich vs. Papa Don't Preach
The Fame vs. Hollywood
Money Honey vs. Material Girl
I Like It Rough vs. Erotica
Bad Romance vs. Vogue
Alejandro vs. La Isla Bonita
Speechless vs. Oh Father
Dance in the Dark vs. What It Feels Like for a Girl
Telephone vs. Hung Up
So Happy I Could Die vs. Crave
Teeth vs. Give It 2 Me
Born This Way vs. Express Yourself
Judas vs. Girl Gone Wild
Hair vs. Burning Up
Bad Kids vs. Human Nature
Fashion of His Love vs. Dress You Up
Yoü and I vs. Don't Tell Me
The Edge of Glory vs. Ray of Light
G.U.Y. vs. Revolver
Sexxx Dreams vs. Justify My Love
Jewels N' Drugs vs. Bitch I'm Madonna
Do What U Want vs. Joan of Arc
ARTPOP vs. Bedtime Story
Dope vs. Bad Girl
Gypsy vs. Holiday
Applause vs. Give Me All Your Luvin'
Lush Life vs. American Pie
Perfect Illusion vs. American Life
Million Reasons vs. Take a Bow
Sinner's Prayer vs. Nothing Fails
Come to Mama vs. Celebration
Hey Girl vs. Me Against the Music
Shallow vs. Ghosttown
Always Remember Us This Way vs. Live to Tell
I'll Never Love Again vs. Crazy for You

  • Like 1

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Didymus

Let's hope Gaga releases a track that we can compare to LAP :pray:

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Bambino
3 minutes ago, Didymus said:

Let's hope Gaga releases a track that we can compare to LAP

Inb4 someone says Bloody Mary :giggle:

  • Like 1

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites
Didymus
2 minutes ago, Bambino said:

Inb4 someone says Bloody Mary :giggle:

I actually thought of that but... :air: Doesn't seem fair :emma:

I was dying to include Promise to Try against Joanne though but I guess I'd just stick to singles 'cause I don't know how well acquainted everyone here is with her albums :giveup:

Share


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Restore formatting

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...