Where does ASIB rank in your favourite Gaga albums?

[Disco Stick 88]

1 minute ago, Successga said:

A Star Is Born is not even a proper body of work. That's why I put right bellow her trinity. But some songs are really outstanding.

Agreed, it's impossible to ignore the quality of some of these songs! 

[Smother Em Eh 6,906]

BTW> TFM> J> AP> C2C> ASIB> TF 

[HorusRa2 4,978]

1. ASIB

2. Born This Way

3. The Fame Monster 

4. Joanne

5. ARTPOP 

6. The Fame

7. C2C 

I feel bad for putting Joanne at 4. It and TFM may just depend on the day. 

 

I know now it’s way early and maybe silly to put ASIB @1 but the songs she put on there are songs I feel like I’ve been waiting for her to make for almost 9 years now. 

[Nraveles 58]

1. ARTPOP (sue me)

2. BTW

3. ASIB

4. The Fame Monster 

5. Joanne 

6. The Fame 

7. C2C

But literally no album is bad at all

 

[Wet Fire 6,205]

1. Born This Way

2. A Star Is Born

3. Joanne

4. The Fame Monster

5. ARTPOP

6. The Fame

7. Cheek to Cheek

[LUO YI 6,089]

From Favourite to least but still amazing

1. Born This Way

2. Joanne

3. A Star Is Born

4. The Fame Monster

5. Cheek to Cheek

6. The Fame

7. ARTPOP

[ARTGOD 3,266]

1. ARTPOP

2. Joanne

3. A Star Is Born

4. Born This Way

5. The Fame Monster

6. The Fame

ASIB would be higher without the pop songs

[RAMROD 102,190]

It's..... far from the shallow now

[Borislshere 52,662]

At the moment it’s sits at number one 

[Madame Goo Goo 3,658]

Born This Way is her most cohesive body of work. The religious undertones in an album about empowerment really rocked, as did the album in general. Bloody Mary is the best song she's ever made, hands down. 

Next, is Joanne. It was so refreshing, and her toned look was so beautiful. Joanne is such an emotional song and Perfect Illusion never gets old.

After that, The Fame Monster. Bad Romance is THAT BITCH and Speechless is STILL her best ballad. 

Then, I'd put A Star Is Born. Despite the difference of sound in all of the music, its still very cohesive and somehow flows well. Magic, I guess. Plus its gonna win her a Grammy and an Oscar.

ARTPOP and The Fame are equal in my mind. I like the songs seperately, but I cannot listen to either album in one setting. That being said, the song ARTPOP is amazing and could've killed it as a single if it banged a little harder.

Cheek to Cheek is still an amazing album and I feel bad for putting it last. I study while listening this album, it's so calming. Anything Goes and They All Laughed make me feel like I'm listening to a jazz musical starring Lady Gaga and Tony Bennett. They're so charming together, I don't know why it works but it does. I need C3C before Tony dies!