Ten years on...Has your opinion of Gaga changed?

[Dex 117]

In the 10 years (wtf) of Gaga's career has your opinion of her changed at all? What were her best moments? What were her worst?

[Dex 117]

In the 10 years (wtf) of Gaga's career has your opinion of her changed at all? What were her best moments? What were her worst?

[Monster7 5,697]

Her worst moments the cancellation BTWBT and the messy promotion of ARTPOP. The best the iconic performances and videos TF/TFM/BTW eras gave us, and finally being recognized by the GP as the talented singer she's always been after Million reasons and Superbowl

Edit: I hope for success, grammys and oscars for ASIB, which would be among the best moments of her career

[Mirrion Rizzons 11,639]

2009 - I thought she had BOPS

2010 - 2011: Crazy af but had bops

2012: forgot about her

2013: oh yeah I remember this bih, applause and DWUW are bops

2014: forgot

2015: remembered her because I was an AHS Fan

2016: Fan

2017: hardcore fan

2018: hardcore fan

 

looking back all years were amazing, especially 2009-2011

best moments: bad romance, vmas 2009/10/11/13, grammys with elton, Sound of music, TIYTY, superbowl

worst: ARTPOP blackout, hip, fibro attacks

[Gagadonna 10,801]

Of course. It all changed with ARTPOP. I overestimated her and forgot sometimes that she was a human being. It's when we fans witnessed her weakest moments during ARTPOP that I really started to love her, not as a character, but as a person. Stefani is much more appealing to me than her persona. That's why I've loved Joanne (era) so much 

My favorite moment was definitely the SuperBowl, I was crazy for weeks before and after it happened. And when it did, I just lost my ****. Everything was perfect about it  

[Zombiecat 16,989]

I think her best moments were during TFM era/BTW and then Joanne/superbowl/right now

I think ARTPOP era was kind of her worst because imo she lost alot of authenticity and it seemed like she was trying too hard to be controversial at times but idk

 

I love her all the same  

[XXXXX 4,775]

I went from hating her to stanning her 

[FfFfFfFF 56,333]

Well I was 9 when Poker Face was released.  

 

[PeachJug 3,091]

at first i viewed her as a distant star, now she feels like a close friend 

[Jake D 576]

For sure. She seems like a totally different person.

She started as this distant mysterious presence that was wildly creative, super gay, and really forward thinking in her fashion, imagery, and music. 

I think she's really shifted her artistry to be much more down to Earth. Now I appreciate her more exclusively for her vocal ability and songwriting talents. I love her as much as I did in the beginning (if not more), but sometimes I do consider the fact that if she'd started with an album like Joanne or even ARTPOP, I definitely wouldn't be a stan. 

[PMKKARDASHiAN 8,570]

Absolutely. My opinion on her has changed and evolved much like she has.

i don't stan as hard as I used to, but she still gets me excited with the ideas of future projects. 

2009 vmas remain her best performance because of the shock value and how no one saw that iconic performance coming, and I'd say SuperBowl has tied it. 

 

[Original Diva 4,987]

22 minutes ago, FfFfFfFF said:

Well I was 9 when Poker Face was released.  

 

I was 5

[stupidrain71 1,459]

i remember when i was in 6th grade, i searched on youtube “poke her face” 

 

OP: yes, when i started watching videos of her singing live versions of her songs or just doing covers of other artists’ sonngs, that’s when i knew she is a vocal powerhouse 

[Reginald 13,841]

The first time I heard just dance I was like meh

The second time I heard it, months later, I was like hold on.... 

And once Poker Face dropped, I became obsessed

 

I miss the days when  I would go out clubbing and hear all of her big singles throughout the course of a night. I would be out on the dance floor working every single step of the LaurieAnn Gibson  choreography lmaooo 

There were several iconic moments when little monsters would flock to the floor, none of us knowing each other beforehand, and bonding over shared knowledge of Judas, Telephone, or Bad Romance's choreo😅

[Bebe 17,106]

My opinion of her has changed, not necessarily for better or worse, it's just that as an artist she evolves so much and she continues to add dimensions to her work and legacy. 

I wouldn't have thought this girl:
 

Would have evolved into this high fashion superstar, mutated into an alien chick with horns on her face singing about self empowerment, worked with Robert Wilson for portraits hung in The Louvre while dabbling in performance art with Marina Ambramović, transformed into a classical Jazz singer with Tony Bennett and then become a lead actress in a major picture movie. 

Honestly it's just been ****ing cool watching her morph and adapt and evolve throughout the years. She doesn't fail to surprise me, even when I think I know the limits to her insane talent she ends up showcasing some other hidden expertise.