Million Reasons would've made a better lead single for Joanne

[MaryJaneHolland 77,348]

Just now, Jessica Germ said:

A-YO as a lead would've made G.U.Y. look like a smash hit 

Lol, whatever floats your boat, boo boo 

A-YO is catchy, radio-friendly, perfectly represents the vibe of the album, and with a snatching video, we would've had a guaranteed top 10, maybe even 5 

[teawhore 7,667]

this PI hate needs to stop 

[JohnWayne92 2,171]

I really think A-Yo should have been the lead single.

[Moo 2,082]

50 minutes ago, Jessica Germ said:

A-YO as a lead would've made G.U.Y. look like a smash hit 

It would do better than Perfect Illusion though sis

[Inferno 2,880]

Its not even debatable that had it been the lead single it would've been huge considering how well it performed as it did. Would it have been the most interesting or preferred choice for the fans? No. Which is why you see so much opposition in this thread because most of you think its too dull and basic. But I think it would've peaked at #2 and been like an adult contemporary staple. As opposed to peaking at #4  and being relatively absent from the radio stations it should normally inhabit. Like can someone from her team tell me WHY its not on every basic playlist used in grocery stores and malls across the country alongside every song by Adele, P!nk, and Kelly Clarkson? Like wtf is that about? That is exactly where Million Reasons belongs and yet its not there.

[Inferno 2,880]

1 hour ago, JohnWayne92 said:

I really think A-Yo should have been the lead single.

Log out.

[Inferno 2,880]

1 hour ago, MaryJaneHolland said:

Lol, whatever floats your boat, boo boo 

A-YO is catchy, radio-friendly, perfectly represents the vibe of the album, and with a snatching video, we would've had a guaranteed top 10, maybe even 5 

That sh*t would have flopped harder than PI and not only that but be an embarrassment as a fan. That song is MANiCUREs even cornier sister which who knew that was even possible. Its fit for a bad Target commercial. Its awful.

[teawhore 7,667]

i think million reasons would have made an amazing outtake  

[TimisaMonster 31,073]

Umm....no that would be like Gaga releasing Dope as the lead single from ARTPOP

Gaga would've been SHREDDED for not releasing an upbeat song after C2C...

[DarkGa 300]

7 hours ago, GaGaAst said:

Best choice was DH.. Could have been #1 if gags promoted it.. it could have been her dark horse its just that good

#1?  This song would not have smashed. It’s too rock for today’s charts, and gets a bit shouty at the end like Perfect Illusion, which I’d assume was a big turn off for people.

[DarkGa 300]

4 hours ago, TimisaMonster said:

Umm....no that would be like Gaga releasing Dope as the lead single from ARTPOP

Gaga would've been SHREDDED for not releasing an upbeat song after C2C...

This seems to be largely why they chose PI as the first and A-yo as the (original) second single. The fans were thirsty after the jazz.

[GaGaAst 13,023]

1 hour ago, DarkGa said:

#1?  This song would not have smashed. It’s too rock for today’s charts, and gets a bit shouty at the end like Perfect Illusion, which I’d assume was a big turn off for people.

ya in the end its mess but its a radio friendly song without being too basic..

Too Rock?? Nope

[Dark Anatomy 2,284]

I truly believe she should've released Million Reasons as the lead single in January before the super bowl, then used the promo of the performance and release of a music video (with imagery like Joanne Piano Version) to shoot the single to number one. 

Then in April, riding off the success and hype of Million Reasons, hit them with A-YO and a big Gaga budget style music video. And shortly drop the album.

With this I think the album and it's singles couldve been a lot more commercial. 

[Vergil 2,296]

Nah. PI was the perfect intro for Joanne.

[REALITY 76,648]

I disagree. Imagine the backlash she would have gotten—not by the general public because I think that they'd be fine with it, but by Little Monsters. Hell, people were divided over "Perfect Illusion." If Gaga released a ballad as her "comeback single" Little Monsters would be more than upset. Sure, in hindsight we say differently, but I guarantee that would have divided people more than PI did.

A-YO would have been the perfect lead single in my opinion.