What do you make of the BBC’s review of the Birmingham show?

[Batwings 12,885]

3 hours ago, DoremonLove said:

This same article was trashed b4 JWT got cancelled now ppl agree with it. How can ppl be so bitter is beyond me. Whatever gaga does will never be enuf for anyone looks like she truly deserves better then this. Im so sure if she starts doing what she did for TMB she will be trashed for doing same things. She can nveer win.

THANK. YOU. When this was posted yesterday, everyone was trashing the hell out of it, saying that the JWT was amazing, and then immediately after the cancellations, people are suddenly saying that it's a crappy show. This fanbase is so damn fickle at times, it's enraging.

[Sailor 3,321]

I mean I agree with this tour or no tour but whatever.

[DoremonLove 8,147]

4 hours ago, Batwings said:

THANK. YOU. When this was posted yesterday, everyone was trashing the hell out of it, saying that the JWT was amazing, and then immediately after the cancellations, people are suddenly saying that it's a crappy show. This fanbase is so damn fickle at times, it's enraging.

And i thot madonna fans were bad i mean woah look at this mess 

[Gay 1,370]

Ouch 

[ignotus 1,403]

It’s kinda true tho. 

[RodeckDanny 2,450]

Uh i think that they don't get how the essence of all she does is everchanging

[Bradley 59,023]

I haven't attended the artRAVE or the Born This Way Ball, but as someone who has witnessed the Joanne World Tour live, I think it's safe to say Gaga is one of the finest artists out there in the industry who knows how to sing and dance well at the same time without compromising on serving visuals and chills and everything a live performer needs to have.

[YoungWildCanadian 277]

I mean what do they want... first she’s too much now it’s not enough??? Just let an artist be an artist... 

[sladygaga 66]

As someone mentioned earlier in the thread it feels like a greatest hits+ a little bit of Joanne.

That's exactly why I've always felt off by Lobster Eye for the creative team/haus. It seems like to me they weren't bringing anything fresh to the table and were rehashing past items that were a hallmark of gaga but packaged in a digestible way for the GP.

In general I've summed it up in my mind this was more or less a tribute phase to cement her legend status for the later part of the Joanne era. Nothing was produced too "out there" to be off putting.

[freebit 6,240]

God, this dude can f*ck off. She sang and danced her heart out. He didn't deserve to see her live. He deserves to go to nothing but Bieber and Drake shows for the rest of his life. 

And yes, she's going to sing Joanne songs (which "promote" Joanne) at the Joanne World f*cking Tour. He's not only a ****, but a dumb one too. 

[Addison Rae 16,632]

Lol and suddenly people care about what a middle aged straight white guy that works for the BBC has to say?  

He can keep his lame opinion and can let the fans actually enjoy the show which they have been. 

[gagaforgaga2010 120]

Though it's a bit of a harsh critique, and I wouldn't say the tour was "safe" (hello epic technical aspects), but the show lacked a cohesive element that her other shows had. I think she tried to throw too much old stuff in to vary it up for people who didn't care for the country vibes Joanne was serving. (Disclaimer, I saw the show in the US).

[just another gay 836]

Well, rather have well-done play-safe than an Avant-grade mess...

[Tan Fei 1,324]

To me shes trying to strike a balance cos she has to cater to a wider audience (old and new fans ) . ive seen reviews saying they want more piano Gaga, some wants more soothing music , ballads, some want more crazy Gaga with better costumes , choreo and props , some wants her to dance more and connects more like bringing fans on stage  , so i think on her part shes trying to make sure everyone gets entertained . I dont think thats conservative. I thought shes quite meticulous on that part . The stage itself is already not conservative.........Moreover shes already dealing with pain..

[Babel 41,431]

Of course calling herself a slut that loves to masturbate and singing about it, killing herself on stage and having two male dancers touching each other is way too conservative.

That’s it without mentions how she spoke about teenagers gays coming out to their parents on her show (at least in my date).

Taylor Swift who? We got our new republican queen