Kylie Minogue or Madonna? Who made more impacT in your life?

[Naor Daniel 937]

Madonna is an icon, I was born in 95 and know many songs by her, it means she made more impact. 

Kylie is cute but she barely has 2 hits (which I like a lot but meh)

Vogue, Like a Prayer, La Isla Bonita, Like a Virgin, Papa Don't Preach, Die Another Day, Hung Up, 4 Minutes, Material Girl, Express Yourself.

My problem with Madonna is that I really dislike her personality and attitude, plus she can't really sing. 

[Ouranos 510]

I'm Aussie so I grew up with kylie as our national treasure. She is the pop princess!!!

[Ouranos 510]

4 minutes ago, Naor Daniel said:

Madonna is an icon, I was born in 95 and know many songs by her, it means she made more impact. 

Kylie is cute but she barely has 2 hits (which I like a lot but meh)

Vogue, Like a Prayer, La Isla Bonita, Like a Virgin, Papa Don't Preach, Die Another Day, Hung Up, 4 Minutes, Material Girl, Express Yourself.

My problem with Madonna is that I really dislike her personality and attitude, plus she can't really sing. 

2 hits? Look up her discography 

[Ouranos 510]

1 hour ago, ShockPop said:

Tbh if Kylie had tried to crack America early on then she would have eclipsed Madonna because it's the same shtick but Kylie goes bigger every time.

Confide in me

On a night like this

Come into my world

All the lovers

Into the blue

Les sex

Kids

In your eyes (the mainstream debut of Calvin Harris)

Chocolate

Get outta my way

 

Seriously. Smash after smash.

You left out better the devil you know, step back in time, you did it again, slow, what do I have to do, spinning around, red blooded woman, like a drug, speakerphone (which madonna loves) and nudity!!!

 

[PopTwo 288]

I knew more Kylie songs growing up rather than Madonna songs although I did know a lot from both. That year when I got back into both of them, I realiased that there was a whole chunk of music by both of them that I didn't know. My favourite Kylie song from that era is Some kind of bliss and my favourite songs from her overall is Get Outta My Way and In your eyes. My favourite madonna songs from that era is all the Ray of light singles and my favourite was always Music, 4 minutes and Hung up. Overall, I have more memories with Kylie's music than Madonna but I still love them both and what they have both in their careers is inspiring.

[PopTwo 288]

1 hour ago, ShockPop said:

Tbh if Kylie had tried to crack America early on then she would have eclipsed Madonna because it's the same shtick but Kylie goes bigger every time.

Confide in me

On a night like this

Come into my world

All the lovers

Into the blue

Les sex

Kids

In your eyes (the mainstream debut of Calvin Harris)

Chocolate

Get outta my way

 

Seriously. Smash after smash.

Calvin didn't produce In Your Eyes but he did produce In My Arms ☺

[ShockPop 7,747]

5 hours ago, LukeIsGaga said:

Calvin didn't produce In Your Eyes but he did produce In My Arms ☺

That's what I meant 😂

[PopTwo 288]

5 hours ago, ShockPop said:

That's what I meant 😂

Okay, I was just making sure you knew

[Andrew 375]

On 02/01/2018 at 11:48 AM, Naor Daniel said:

Madonna is an icon, I was born in 95 and know many songs by her, it means she made more impact. 

Kylie is cute but she barely has 2 hits (which I like a lot but meh)

Vogue, Like a Prayer, La Isla Bonita, Like a Virgin, Papa Don't Preach, Die Another Day, Hung Up, 4 Minutes, Material Girl, Express Yourself.

My problem with Madonna is that I really dislike her personality and attitude, plus she can't really sing. 

2 hits? Maybe where you're from. She's had dozens and dozens in Europe and Australia!

[Queen Gloria 3,353]

I have respect for Madonna, but honestly, Kylie is the superior performer/live singer. Let's be real. Madonna has a legacy, but so does Kylie, just not as well known in the US. 

Kylie has one of the biggest pop hits of all time. If you don't at least like this one song by her, all of your opinions are invalid.

 

 

[TheWitness 3,630]

Neither had any impact but I know more Madonna songs (like 4 ) so I’ll go with Her

[scallywally 626]

24 minutes ago, TheWitness said:

Neither had any impact but I know more Madonna songs (like 4 ) so I’ll go with Her

You only know 4 Madonna songs?? Stream a greatest hits or something, thats crazy. (Not bad) but youll be blown away!

[TheWitness 3,630]

Just now, scallywally said:

You only know 4 Madonna songs?? Stream a greatest hits or something, thats crazy. (Not bad) but youll be blown away!

Do i want to tho  

[scallywally 626]

23 minutes ago, TheWitness said:

Do i want to tho  

Yeah, if you love gaga youre gonna love Madonna.

 

[Inferno 2,880]

I greatly dig both but I think theres something more fun and fresh about Kylies music trajectory. Shes a lot less contrived and more willing to be imperfect and try new things.