Should Gaga have featured in Adam Lambert on MTN for the single release?

[Born To Slay 10,996]

i feel like if a version similar to this but more properly mixed were released, the song would've gone top 10.

[Blake 7,385]

Nope. Next.

[Mr S 8,778]

No. 

[juju 18,907]

It's cute but........... Marry The Night is perfect the way she is and doesn't need a feature imo  

[Born To Slay 10,996]

2 minutes ago, that juju said:

It's cute but........... Marry The Night is perfect the way she is and doesn't need a feature imo  

It peaked at 29, so apparently it did 

[sipthistea 21,099]

The song is iconic, whether it was a hit or not 

And that's a fact. Not everything is about the charts. 

[Born To Slay 10,996]

2 minutes ago, sipthistea said:

The song is iconic, whether it was a hit or not 

And that's a fact. Not everything is about the charts. 

But how gr8'would it have been to have another top 10 from BTW?

[juju 18,907]

11 minutes ago, Born To Slay said:

It peaked at 29, so apparently it did 

I mean, if charts were the be all end all. But Adam wasn't even making it to #29 with his singles in 2011 so I doubt a feature from him would've improved MTN's chart position  

And strictly from an artistic point of view, Adam doesn't quite add anything to the song that wasn't there already. 

[Born To Slay 10,996]

1 minute ago, that juju said:

I mean, if charts were the be all end all. But Adam wasn't even making it to #29 with his singles in 2011 so I doubt a feature from him would've improved MTN's chart position  

And strictly from an artistic point of view, Adam doesn't quite add anything to the song that wasn't there already. 

I think Gaga stans would've bought the remix enough to send the song to the top 10 for a week. Three out of four of Gaga's top 10s from that era debuted there.

[juju 18,907]

1 minute ago, Born To Slay said:

I think Gaga stans would've bought the remix enough to send the song to the top 10 for a week. Three out of four of Gaga's top 10s from that era debuted there.

IDK by the time MTN rolled around, people weren't really out trying to score Gaga another hit. Most fans were happy with how the era was going and were mostly just waiting for tour dates  

[holy scheisse 22,458]

Would be a fun feature but the original is just fine!

[Ziggy 12,450]

Lol nothing would have saved MTN on the charts. It was the 5th single of a shaky era that had heavy front-loaded promo. For what it is, I'm happy with it. I love the song and the video so I'm content. I do think had it been released around TEOG (before or after it) it could have fared better because those songs play off of each other nicely with their 80s synths while being different enough to warrant each being a single.

[Born To Slay 10,996]

2 minutes ago, that juju said:

IDK by the time MTN rolled around, people weren't really out trying to score Gaga another hit. Most fans were happy with how the era was going and were mostly just waiting for tour dates  

It would've been a one week top 10 but I think that if the remix was released the week MTN was 29, the so would've went top 10 for a week based off of Gaga stans that already owned the album and therefore didn't buy the single, buying the remix.

I remember the era well and I think stans were hungry enough to save her top 10 streak to pull it off.

[Born To Slay 10,996]

1 minute ago, Ziggy said:

Lol nothing would have saved MTN on the charts. It was the 5th single of a shaky era that had heavy front-loaded promo. For what it is, I'm happy with it. I love the song and the video so I'm content. I do think had it been released around TEOG (before or after it) it could have fared better because those songs play off of each other nicely with their 80s synths while being different enough to warrant each being a single.

Front loaded promo? Gaga promoted the album the entire year. Marry The Night was the most heavily promoted fifth single I can think of.

[Ziggy 12,450]

1 minute ago, Born To Slay said:

Front loaded promo? Gaga promoted the album the entire year. Marry The Night was the most heavily promoted fifth single I can think of.

I mean the album era. There was so much promo before MTN that by the time she got there people were sick of her. I also don't think it helped that a lot of the performances had a sad or somber tone to them (especially the acoustic ones).