Jump to content
question

Why do people say Madonna is Talentless?


Stevo

Featured Posts

So I decided to do some exploring on Madonna's music n stuff and I gotta say her discography has to be one of the most artisticly diverse i've ever seen. I was amazed how many gems there are in her albums and I feel lame for getting into Madonna so late. There's always this stigma about Madonna that she's talentless and she's just in it for the shock value and sex but I think controversy has overshadowed her artistry and legacy. I don't understand how people can call her talentless with amazing performances such as these. Yeah she doesn't have an amazing voice but it's quite pleasant to hear. She's definitely hard-working though and deserves her fame and wealth. Do you guys think she'sa bad singer?

This performance slayed my entire existence. The dancing, choregraphy, visuals, vocals, stage presence. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 187
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Xoxo Adriana

I don't think she's untalented, when she is compared to Gaga people tend to say Gaga is more talented as her vocals are stronger and can hit lower notes better. Also Gaga's voice is versatile when it comes to performing different genres. Madonna's voice is very pop and...meh 

Link to post
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, Stevo said:

So I decided to do some exploring on Madonna's music n stuff and I gotta say her discography has to be one of the most artisticly diverse i've ever seen. I was amazed how many gems there are in her albums and I feel lame for getting into Madonna so late. There's always this stigma about Madonna that she's talentless and she's just in it for the shock value and sex but I think controversy has overshadowed her artistry and legacy. I don't understand how people can call her talentless with amazing performances such as these. Yeah she doesn't have an amazing voice but it's quite pleasant to hear. She's definitely hard-working though and deserves her fame and wealth.

This performance slayed my entire existence. The dancing, choregraphy, visuals, vocals, stage presence. 

She is good at dancing but vocally... :reductive:

Link to post
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Adakam said:

Definetly not talentless, but oh god her voice sucks, its like a soft squeaky toy

Am I the only one who likes her singing? :laughga: I thought the performance in the first video was nice. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Drin Lon

Having a good voice is not the only talent sb can have tho :awkney:

She's an outstanding songwriter and a very creative person.

Mess at the first reaction being "Excuse Me No" :giggle:

 

Link to post
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Drin Lon said:

Having a good voice is not the only talent sb can have tho :awkney:

She's an outstanding songwriter and a very creative person.

Mess at the first reaction being "Excuse Me No" :giggle:

 

There are jobs for that tho

Link to post
Share on other sites

MaryJaneHolland
2 minutes ago, Adakam said:

There are jobs for that tho

She has a nice soft tone and her voice is very versatile. It's not all about belting, whistles and high notes.

Link to post
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Adakam said:

There are jobs for that tho

I think she channels her artistic expression through her performances though. She's more like a performance artist than someone who just sings? does that make sense lol

Link to post
Share on other sites

Ugh, 'cause little monsters can be so stupid sometimes. Like OH NO SHE ATTACKED MOMMY SHE'S AN OLD UNTALENTED *****. Take SEVERAL seats. Whatever's going on with Gaga and Madonna, Madonna she's a HELL of a performer and an artist. I mean, I pray and hope Gaga's going to achieve (and I'm sure she will) the peaks of artistry that Madonna achieved with albums like Erotica, Like A Prayer or American Life. So shocking news, you can love Gaga AND Madonna at the same time, bottom line cut and dry.

Link to post
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, MaryJaneHolland said:

She has a nice soft tone and her voice is very versatile. It's not all about belting, whistles and high notes.

I agree, its not all about measurable skill, many of my faveourite singers are very limited, but personally i dont like her tone, feels, lets say, childish or cartoonish, and untrained. And knowing to adapt it to different atmospheres isnt exactly versatile.

1 minute ago, Stevo said:

I think she channels her artistic expression through her performances though. She's more like a performance artist than someone who just sings? does that make sense lol

I agree, shes all in for the performance a does a great job, but I feel that everyone is able to develop their voice if they put their minds to it, with her I dont feel that.

Link to post
Share on other sites

RocketNumberNine

she is not singer.. she is dancer and performer... but everybody knows she is the queen of pop.. not beyonce not gaga not rih

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...