Jump to content
question

Why do people "hate" American Life?


Henri Bardot

Featured Posts

FfFfFfFF

It had mixed reviews upon its release because political themes are not working with the GP. A ndespecially not when they come from rich people/ celebs.

Link to post
Share on other sites

andreas85

I think American Life is not that bad but it still is an unstable album and that's why it is not one of Madonna's greatest efforts. Those artificial computer sounds don't really work well at all most of the time. For example, Nobody Knows Me could have been even a great song but that annoying and exaggerated autotune ruined it. Then there are songs like I'm So Stupid and Mother and Father both of which suffers from unoriginal and bland tunes although the lyrics are somewhat interesting. I like American Life quite a lot but it would have been better without the rap because rapping isn't really Madonna's thing. Simplest songs are the most impressive in this case. My favorites from the album are Hollywood, Love Profusion, Intervention, Nothing Fails and X-Static Process.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Esteban

Imo her best albums are: 

1) Ray of Ligh 

2) American Life 

3) Bedtime Stories

American Life is very well produced and the meaning is great, Ahmadzaï made a great work alone and i dont understand how we can hate this album...

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

×
×
  • Create New...