Jump to content
question

Is any song off of Joanne about Taylor?


Lava

Featured Posts

StrawberryBlond

That whole middle section of the album (DIC, PI, MR, SP) is definitely about him along with Just Another Day at the end. Dancing In Circles is about how they'd broken up and her trying to find solace in self-loving. Perfect Illusion is her coming to terms with the idea that it was never true love and she needs to move on. Million Reasons is her mourning period of realising that the relationship is almost over. Sinner's Prayer begins with her going home to tell her family that they've broken up. And at the very end, Just Another Day is her reminicising on the highs of their relationship and how she got over all the little problems.

The album is basically Lemonade...but without the infidelity and the couple actually break up.

Link to post
Share on other sites

  • Replies 30
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Panchecco
21 minutes ago, Misaki said:

Well Swift went Pop and Gaga went Country... What a reverse SwiftGagian expedition.

z1pO1N3.png 

Link to post
Share on other sites

GagaXCupcakke
1 minute ago, Bio said:

How can people think Diamond Heart is about Taylor? It's obviously about her time stripping in NYC and how she knew she'd be a star from the start.

People are saying that because the song is called Diamond Heart and their engagement ring was a diamond heart. Gaga is very precise about her lyrics, she wouldn't make it Diamond Heart for no reason. It could of easily been Golden Heart. So some how the song has to relate to Taylor. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Illuminati
29 minutes ago, Antonio said:

I'm still skeptical about Perfect Illusion not being about Taylor.

It must've been some sort of inspiration. I don't believe the Instagram filters sh-t

well to begin with the song wasn't even written by her or for her, she confirmed that they rewrote Kevin Parkers demo.

Link to post
Share on other sites

I feel like all of these songs are just about every avenue in Gaga's life and how she widely approaches, sees thing and deals with things, as a whole. I think that none of them are about one certain instance, it's all more of an analysis of what she has gone through and has seen, up to this point in her life. All and everything is included, but very indirectly.

The future's uncertain and the end is always near.
Link to post
Share on other sites

PopThatArt
8 minutes ago, Bio said:

How can people think Diamond Heart is about Taylor? It's obviously about her time stripping in NYC and how she knew she'd be a star from the start.

It's not that Diamond Heart is "about" Taylor per se, but rather inspired by the diamond heart shaped engagement ring he got her. And one could assume, what she is saying is that after everything, she's got her happily ever after, she got her diamond heart, an engagement ring and a man who loves her enough to marry her and accept her after everything she's been through. Which really makes the song sad now since they've broken up. 

Go see A Star is Born
Link to post
Share on other sites

Nothing obvious in the way that "Gypsy" was, but I suspect the whole album is influenced by him, especially in the "country" sound, which we know is his thing.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Illuminati

I think the only songs that have potential to be related to Taylor are Just Another Day and Diamond Heart both of which are still questionable. Lol at whoever brings up DIC

Link to post
Share on other sites

PopThatArt
13 minutes ago, Sure Joanne said:

well to begin with the song wasn't even written by her or for her, she confirmed that they rewrote Kevin Parkers demo.

She didn't say they rewrote Kevin's demo, she said Kevin had the idea for a song called Illusion, and they sat down and she came up with the idea Perfect Illusion and making it about all the false images around us. 

Go see A Star is Born
Link to post
Share on other sites

Illuminati
12 minutes ago, PopThatArt said:

She didn't say they rewrote Kevin's demo, she said Kevin had the idea for a song called Illusion, and they sat down and she came up with the idea Perfect Illusion and making it about all the false images around us. 

he had a demo called Illusion, so that's like a half finished song already. 

they built on top of what was already created

Link to post
Share on other sites

I'm guessing these may be (at least partially) about him.

Diamond Heart
John Wayne
Dancin' in Circles
Perfect Illusion
Million Reasons
Sinner's Prayer
Just Another Day

Link to post
Share on other sites

ARTPOPheartstop
1 hour ago, Creyk said:

Only perfect illusion

He is not good for  her creativity and it totally shows, I'm so glad he is gone from her life

He was there during ARTPOP :what:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


×
×
  • Create New...