She Doesn't Get Enough Credit

[TwerkinLurkin 4,764]

4 minutes ago, Devyn said:

Talk about an over exaggeration. I haven't seen anyone act like this. I've seen people talk about un-stanning but that's do to more than just the video.

I don't think they mean her career is lazy or uncreative. Most people are critiquing this video solely by itself. What i may find lazy and uncreative, another person may find it inspiring and amazing.

Omg 😂 I guess you've never heard that expression before lmao I'm not saying you can't like the video trust me it's not my favorite either but some people need to stop having temper tantrums over one video like move on with life there will be 100s of more gaga videos 

[He8MyHeart 9,765]

Maybe it's nothing to do with a lack of creativity. Maybe it was just a lack of time when it came to creating the video.

[Batwings 12,885]

A while back, someone made the comment on here along the lines of "So many members on here want to manage Gaga's career when they can't even get their homework in on time." I think that assessment still stands.

 

[Ikvs 2,576]

I can say that I've never seen someone calling HER lazy.

[mattbri 1,369]

I agree with you. All I can say is this: I love the video, but the song had much more potential. If she wanted she could have worked on the video more and delaying it. Now we have that video. But I'm getting sick and tired of comments saying that one cannot state his opinion if it's negative. If that's the case, then it makes sense that no one can praise the video too. As I said, I really like the video, although it could have been much better. 

[SKANK 14,288]

Bowie made compelling art till the day he died, Bjork has been churning out the same quality music/visuals for decades, Madonna still has her pulse on what's relevant and is dedicated to creating vibrant music thirty years after her debut, Beyonce is similar in age to Gaga and hustles just as hard (while taking care of a family) but actually creates fresh culturally engaging art. What does Gaga not being 24 have to do with anything?

It seems like fans are desperately trying to make excuses for why she is falling short of the standard she set for herself.

 

[SpookyKid 15,153]

21 minutes ago, Ikvs said:

I can say that I've never seen someone calling HER lazy.

then check the MV video thread..

[Miel 15,009]

I think a lot of people are really undermining the music itself  because of the video.

Like, yeah the video was awful, but that doesn't mean the album is. Or her artistry. Or all the things she has done before leading up until now. Nor does it mean that future work will be equally as bad (I hope).

[Letmelivemylife 8,715]

2 hours ago, retroglamx said:

I don't particularly agree with these examples though.

 

However I do agree with you with the fact that you can't call the woman LAZY when she LITERALLY BROKE HER HIP FROM TOO MUCH TOURING.

I always get incredibly offended when the critics say that her love for her monsters is artificial. I remember reading somewhere that she was laying backstage in horrible mind numbing pain. She heard us calling for her and she took a shot of whiskey and went out to do the show. She did it because she loves us so much. If that isn't love, idk what is. I just wish the critics could see the deep maternal type of love she has for her monsters. She's always been there for us no questions asked. She's always put our needs above her own and yet it saddens me that when she needs us the most, some people either abandoned her or just started ripping her to pieces

[REALITY 76,374]

3 hours ago, Devyn said:

What makes us ungrateful though? Cause we don't like one video? 

It's not that, it's some of the just blatant hate that we've seen throughout.

You are completely 100% entitled to not like something, it's your opinion, but when you start personally insulting her and insulting her work, creativity, and passion for something, that crosses a line. That's no longer "constructive criticism" nor criticism at all, just blatant hate.

[Doncho 27,241]

Of course she is not lazy. She is just making horrible music videos, thats it.

[Doncho 27,241]

3 hours ago, SKANK said:

Bowie made compelling art till the day he died, Bjork has been churning out the same quality music/visuals for decades, Madonna still has her pulse on what's relevant and is dedicated to creating vibrant music thirty years after her debut, Beyonce is similar in age to Gaga and hustles just as hard (while taking care of a family) but actually creates fresh culturally engaging art. What does Gaga not being 24 have to do with anything?

It seems like fans are desperately trying to make excuses for why she is falling short of the standard she set for herself.

 

THISSSSS! thank you. I am so tired of reading "But she is 30 now so she has matured" 

[Supersonic 49,376]

I love it when people are like "This piece of art has no authenticity, is mediocre, has no concept, is sloppy and trashy" just because they don't personally like it or refuse to understand it.

That's exactly why Gaga is the artist and you're the public.

[REALITY 76,374]

44 minutes ago, Supersonic said:

I love it when people are like "This piece of art has no authenticity, is mediocre, has no concept, is sloppy and trashy" just because they don't personally like it or refuse to understand it.

That's exactly why Gaga is the artist and you're the public.

[Bam 1,695]

Because most of these "creative monster" thinks highly of their windows movie maker or imovie art. 

 

Let's stalk some of their Instagram and see if they have the right to critic. I only believe in critics who is at par with artistic standards.